Friday, July 17, 2009

Too Hot to Handle, Dems and Health Care

Hey! Well, the weekend is pretty much upon us. Hope everyone has a good one.
Man, the heat is sort of killing me this year. I usually just cope with the heat and don't think about it too much (as a Texan, I just sort of consider it as part of the deal, and I try not to whine about it), but this year I've noticed that I actually have started to feel kind of crappy when I've been out in it. Of course, I think a big part of this isn't just because of the heat, but because of the fact that I'm constantly moving between 100+ degree enviroments and indoor buildings that are about 72 or 73 degrees (even going back and forth between my office and the courthouse in the afternoons I notice this). It's enough to make your body confused, I think. Anyway, it's only mid July and things probably won't really cool down until, the end of September. Jeez.

Sounds like the Democrats are starting to come unravelled on this whole health care reform thing. That really annoys the crap out of me. Although I have some ideas about what form a different health care plan ought to take, mostly I just feel really strongly that we need to just get something done to provide health care coverage for the 43.6 million Americans (under age 65) who are without health insurance and the 8.9% of American children (under 18) who are without coverage. If Democrats can't get something done to help improve the current health care system, I will see that as a colossal failure for this administration and for all of the Democrats holding office on the national level right now.

Well, I know this has been short, but I don't have much to say at the moment, and I need to run.

Hope you guys have a good weekend.
You Texans make sure to drink lots of fluids and try to stay cool this weekend!

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

wish I could read this so called bill and someone explain it in laymans terms so the less educated people in america can undertand and make a decision based on facts not a good speaker.

J.S. said...

Anonymous, glad to have you commenting, but I've got a sort of informal policy on here of just asking to sign some kind of name to their comments, just so we can differentiate one person from another. You don't have to create a blogger profile or anything- just sign you comments with some kind of name at the end so we can differentiate, if you don't mind. Thanks! (And I appreciate the comment)

- Steanso

J.S. said...

And to your point, Anon, I don't really know what this plan is going to look like, either. Mostly, I just want there to be an option which can cover people for emergency, crucial health procedures without making people bankrupt. I feel like our current health care industry is controlled by pharmaceutical companies who are artifically inflating costs (other countries pay a lot less for the same meds that we get, the pharm companies pass on costs to their consumers for things like TV ads and pharmaceutical sales reps who wine and dine doctors in order to get them to presscribe more of their drugs, etc.) and our insurance companies keep constantly raising costs while increasingly limit the services they cover.
People keep criticizing countries like England and their government controlled system, but the people over there seem to be overwhelmingly in support of England's National Healthcare System. In a 2007 survey, 90% of English patients said they felt good about their health care and only 2% said it was poor - http://www.inthenews.co.uk/thebigissue/news/health/patient-satisfaction-$1085847$1085847.htm

I think that most of the stories that you hear about how awful it is are mostly propaganda put out by people here in the U.S. who have a financial interest in maintaining the status quo. This being the U.S., I think people should still have an optioin for a private doctor, but I'm increasingly convinced that we need some sort of a public option in health care that can provide for people who can't afford health care. Analysts are saying that rising costs in current health care mean that services are going to continue to shrink as people pay more and more, so even people who are happy with their insurance right now will probably find themselves in a worse position within 5 years or so. SOMETHING has to change.

The Pope said...

Steanso--
--I agree to some extent about the drug companies inflating costs. But I think the days of doctors getting cruises and golf clubs on the drug companies' dimes are long gone. At Vanderbilt (where I am a professor!!!) the presence of drug companies has been largely curtailed. No free dinners, no free lunches....we are not supposed to use the free pens that were abundant 2 years ago. Is it the same at a private practice? I don't know. I hope not. Not to defend drug companies, but if you want new and better medications, you need to put a LOT (billions) into research. They are going to try to recoup those costs by charging a high cost for a new drug before it goes off patent. Is it fair to patients to do this? That's a question for debate.

The Pope said...

And let me add my perspective as a physician.....
1. I am currently at a county hospital in Nashville where I see cancer patients who are generally homeless or lower socio-economic status. Do I think they should receive the same quality of health care as the millionaire Titan players? Absolutely. But you also see a lot of people who have no health insurance, yet somehow are driving nice SUVs, carrying around iPhones, etc. There is already abuse of the system. My wife saw a patient who is pregnant and has no private insurance....and she is paying $3500 cash to a midwife to be present at her delivery?!?! (The midwife has no malpractice either.....everything is on the doctor).
2. Doctors order unecessary tests to avoid being sued. Some states (Illinois, for one) are worse than others (Texas has a cap these days). I don't think this is the main problem with the health care system....but I see plenty of doctors who order MRIs or PET scans "just in case".
3. There is already a shortage of doctors in the US. Physicians in countries which have socialized medicine (i.e. Canada, Sweden) are not well compensated for there efforts, compared to US physicians. I spent 4 years in medical school (accruing a substantial debt which will not be paid off any time soon), 3 years in residency making sub-minimum wage working 100+ hours a week (which is no longer the case), 4 years in fellowship....not to mention 4 years of undergraduate debt. I am on call for the hospital 22 weeks out of the year, including weekends and holidays. This may all seem very selfish, but my point is this.....if you want people to spend 12-15 years learning this profession there needs to be either a)a pot of gold (kidding...) at the end of the rainbow or b) free medical education and lower compensation. Otherwise, if the US turns into Canada, the number of docs will decrease. Simple supply and demand.
And I have worked in an ER in Stockholm.....you would be surprised how non-interventional the docs are over there.
4. I think there are plenty of health care reforms that need to be placed. There solution is not rushing a mystery bill through ASAP. Frankly, it worries me.

The Pope said...

$&%#!!!!!
"There" = "their" in item 3, line 4.
"there" = "the" in item 4.

I think it's time I go to bed. I'm sure I will get flamed for my obvious self-interest in this debate. Oh well.