Wednesday, July 08, 2009

Keeping the White House Honest on Health Care; Nothing Great from the G-8 (So Far)

Hey, guys! Not too much to report on from the home front.
Some progressive Democrats are expressing frustration and anger with the White House, particularly Rahm Emanuel, for discussing the possibility that the implementation of a new health care plan might end up being conditioned upon a "trigger" which would only put a health care system with a public insurance option into play if private insurance companies failed to meet certain pre-established standards regarding coverage and cost. Progressive Democrats see such a trigger clause as providing a technical loophole which private insurance companies are likely to exploit as they struggle to prevent a new, more comprehensive health care system from being implemented (a system which they see as threatening their profits). I tend to agree with the people who are voicing this criticism.
If a trigger clause is included in the health care plan, I think insurance companies are likely to try to find superficial, artificial ways of making it look like they're providing good coverage at a low cost, but in truth, as always, they'll really be more concerned with maximizing profits for their shareholders as opposed to providing quality, reasonably priced health care for the American people (this isn't a huge criticism of the insurance companies- private companies are supposed to be focused on making profits, but this may be why a public system that is instead focused on the well being of patients might be more appropriate). Artifices will be created with the intention of keeping the healthcare plan from being triggered, but the insurance companies will continue to try to generate the most profits possible (which ultimately means that it will remain in their best interests to collect as much money as they can from patients while trying to spend as little money as possible on providing treatment). Furthermore, whenever this "trigger" is supposed to be activated in order to put the health care plan into effect, the insurance companies are likely to tie the issue up with litigation and claim that the preconditions for the trigger have not actually occurred. The whole trigger clause just leaves way too much room for legal wrangling and could jam up the entire process, once again leaving America's patients and/or potential patients in the lurch.
Incidentally, I tend to support the idea of a public option for insurance, and the opposition on this matter sort of annoys me. The insurance industry has said that a public option would insert unfair competition within the marketplace and unfairly hurt their businesses. So on the one hand we have the insurance companies claiming that they provide the cheapest, most efficient and effective coverage possible (this claim is typically accompanied by some kind of dogmatic claim about how government never does anything as well as private industry), but on the other hand, they're claiming that a government healthcare program would most likely drive them out of business. It's hard to imagine a government-assisted public option as being the kind of thing that would drive all of these supposedly more efficient, more effective private insurance companies out of business.
I'm not sure exactly how this public option component is going to effect people from a taxation standpoint, but I will be so bold as to say that I think healthcare actually seems like the kind of thing we should be spending our taxes on. It might do us a little good to have a few less random wars or spend a few less dollars on increasingly elaborate and extravagant military systems (sorry- yes, I still think the advanced jetfighters are really cool, but...) and spend more of our dollars on trying to keep our population healthy. This is one area where I'm not afraid to be pretty much unabashedly liberal or progressive or left leaning or whatever. I see a basic level of healthcare as one of the most fundamental elements of a civilized and humane society, and I want to live in a country that sees the provision of basic healthcare for its citizens as one if its highest priorities. Maybe I'm a wild eyed socialist, but I think poor people ought to be able to go to the doctor when they're sick, especially when we're living in a country where CEOs continue to draw multimillion dollar bonuses, even when their companies are failing.
Anyway, personally, I'm actually pretty satisfied with my insurance coverage. Then again, I work for the government. When I worked for myself, I didn't even have insurance for a while (those start up years were pretty lean), and at other legal jobs I was required to pay for at least half of my insurance (and the insurance was pretty darn expensive). Anyway, as a lawyer I felt like I was having a hard time paying for insurance, so it's hard to imagine how people can manage it who are working for much lower wages.
Enough about healthcare reform. I'm sure I'll be writing about it more as this issue is addressed in Washington.

The G-8 is meeting today, and has already abandoned an agreement which was supposed to obligate participating countries to cut carbon emissions by 50 % by the middle of the century.
Super.
Meanwhile, back here in Central Texas we're experiencing the worst drought since the 1950's and experiencing extended periods of record-breaking temperatures. I don't want to be an alarmist, but I'm pretty sure it's the end times. Again.
Anyway, the players at the G-8 summit did at least agree to try to limit gas emissions enough to prevent the planet's temperature from rising more than 2 degrees. We'll see how that goes. The scientists don't sound very hopeful. Getting nations to agree on actual limits for gas emissions would have felt a lot more concrete, in my mind.
Greenpeace unfurled a banner from the top of Mount Rushmore that encouraged participants at the G-8 summit to stop global warming. Sometimes those activists might seem a little nutty, but then again, it's hard to know what the appropriate reaction is when the entire temperature of the planet's atmosphere is being altered and our leaders still don't seem to be able to address the problem with the urgency and seriousness that it deserves.
Anyway, it's too early to get into any substantial bitching, but I'm not really thrilled with the White House so far this week. Between this whole "trigger" thing on the health care reform to another lackluster result on the global warming front at the G-8, it just doesn't feel like Obama and crew are fighting quite as hard as they maybe should. I know that Obama has made a point of his need to be pragmatic, and that's okay, but there are some areas where we just need to see some progress being made, and I think global warming and America's health care situation both fall squarely into that category.
Well, that's it.
It's hot out there. Stay inside. Eat a popsicle.

No comments: