Hey! How is everyone? Hot as sheeyat here in Austin. S'posed to get up to 105 or 106 today. Hoo ray.
Last night we had Crack practice over at my place. It was a pretty good practice and we played some pretty cool stuff. I tried to record practice on my digital recorder, but I had battery and memory issues, so it didn't work. Oh well. That's okay.
I have sort of mixed feelings about recording, anyway. In some ways, of course, making recordings is great. Helps you enjoy and share your music, right?
But playing music live and then going back and listening to what you've done later can be tricky business. Sometimes I'll be playing with friends and having a really great time making music, feeling the tempos and sharing melodies and harmonies in a really profound sort of way, but then when I go back and listen to the recordings later, they just don't sound as good as I would have thought (every once in a while something sounds better than you would have thought, but this is more rare- at least in my experience). There are a number of reasons the music seems to sound better live. First, it's easier to overlook mistakes and problems when you're focused on making the music, so you often notice problems during passive listening that you didn't spot while they music was being played. Another thing that happens is that it's often difficult to capture the sort of live sound that you're getting in the place where music is being played when you're reducing the music down to a recording (things like equipment quality, mic placement, sampling rates, etc. can play into this). Additionally, teensie, tiny mistakes which fly by pretty much unnoticed, disappearing into the ether while playing music live, become much more painful and obvious when you listen to them over and over again in a recording. And, of course, there's always the fact that it's easy to become a bit deluded about how good your music is actually sounding when you're just having a really good time making it. I think this last one helps to explain why there are so many musicians out there who are enthusiastic and eager to share their music, even when it's not very good (note: this clearly isn't a reference to Crack. We rock.).
Anyway, recording can be great, but it can take some of the magic out of playing music live.
Live music seems like it should be, at least to some extent, about shared moments between musicians (and their audience, if there is one). Recording takes away the transitory, fleeting nature of musical experiences- moments which traditionally have been the sort of stuff that musical legends have been built upon.
It used to be that an audience member would hear a musician play a particularly moving solo or melody on some song in some club, and that person would go out and tell their friends about that experience, and stories about a particular performance would flourish and spread. Legends about particular performances were built and spread this way. Occasionally there were bootlegs or other recordings, but these recordings were often of lower quality, and they were meant to simply serve as some sort of record of a performance rather than as media through which the exact sound of the performance would later be reproduced.
Now, though, we have small, portable, high powered devices that can record and reproduce music easily and very accurately, and so we've moved into an age where almost everything public performance that occurs is recorded in some kind of format. Now when people hear about a performance that was reported to be very good (or which someone enjoyed very much), people rush out to find the recording and the analyze it piece by piece in excrutiating detail. A solo or improv might have seemed truly amazing at the moment it was performed, but people will go back after the fact and declare it worthy or unworthy based upon a missed note, slight tuning issues, or a phrase which had miniscule tempo irregularities.
Recordings can kill the magic of live music. Recordings often fail to capture some of the all important intangibles- the emotion and energy between people as music is being made (smiles, nods, sweat, tears, and empathic connections), a cool breeze or ray of sunshine on an outdoor stage, and, perhaps most importantly, the magic of being present in a moment of true spontaneity- moments of eruption where intellect, feeling, and agility all come together to convey human emotion in a language of pitch, timbre, and tempo.
Listening to music after the fact can't convey the same emotional impact that occurs as a person witnesses music being born.
So, anyway, I have mixed feelings about recording live music. Sometimes I like to capture every note. Sometimes I still think it's better to just play the music, remember it however I want to, and build stories around my own performances.
Even when the legends are delusion, they're probably still good for the soul.
Sounds like the protesters were back at it in Tehran today, marking the anniversary of the 1999 Iranian student uprising with new protests designed to denounce the allegedly false results of Iran's recent elections. About 2,000 to 3,000 people filled the streets near Tehran University today, but were met with force by riot police who used tear gas and batons to disperse crowds. Seems like this sort of story probably ought to rate up there in importance as compared to the Michael Jackson memorial service, but somehow.... yeah. Americans just don't care about democracy in Iran quite as much as they care about Michael Jackson's death.
Not sure what to do with that.
Well, I think maybe that's it for me today. I just don't have more gas left in the tank.
You guys take care.
No comments:
Post a Comment