Wednesday, February 22, 2006

Well, when I first heard about protests over an Arab company gaining control over some U.S. ports, I was kind of annoyed because the whole thing seemed like a vaguely rascist, knee-jerk reaction to what seemed like a pretty commonplace business transaction. I mean, just because a company is Arab doesn't automatically mean that their motives should be suspect or that they are any less dedicated to running a safe and secure operation than any other group of people. But last night on The Newshour I watched an analyst who pointed out that Dubai Ports World (the company seeking to gain management control of ports in New York and New Jersey; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; Baltimore, Maryland; Miami, Florida; and New Orleans, Louisiana) is actually a government-controlled subsidiary of The United Arab Emirates (the UAE). This means, in effect, that our government is going to be turning over some of our ports to be controlled by part of the government of another country (which seems like a big ol' potential conflict of interest- not to mention the fact that it kind of raises questions about why the U.S. is handing over control of our ports to other countries when these other countries are confident that they can turn a profit by managing them- are these other countries that much more efficient than us?) Then some other guy on The Newshour (I wish I had gotten the names of all of these guys, but I didn't) pointed out that the UAE, although generally considered an ally by the Bush administration, was the home country of two of the 9-11 hijackers, and that terrorist funding for the 9-11 hijackers and other terrorist operations have been traced to financial centers in Dubai, in The United Arab Emirates. Furthermore, the UAE was one of only a few countries to officially recognize the rule of the Taliban in Afghanistan when that fundamentalist group was providing shelter for Al Qaeda during the '90's and the earlier portion of this decade. Also, critics maintain that the UAE was an important transfer point for shipments of smuggled nuclear components sent to Iran, North Korea and Libya by a Pakistani scientist. To sum it up, the UAE may be allies, but their record is hardly spotless.

Anyway, I'm not saying that we should start bombing the UAE, but maybe we should exercise a little caution before we start handing over control of our ports to them. The White House has argued that even if the UAE were to be given managerial control over the ports, security operations would remain in U.S. hands and would not be compromised. Maybe I'm just dense, but it seems to me that granting managerial control of an operation to a foreign group has got to result in that group having increased opportunities to move people or materials in and out of the country (possibly surreptitiously) if they really wish to do so.

I'm still not exactly sure whether or not this whole port handover is a real problem, but I guess my real question is why the White House is so eager to seal this deal if there's even a potential likelihood of weakening our national security. I would guess that it's just a money issue, but for an administration which has tried to build its reputation on protecting the American people, it seems a foolish misstep to rush through this process without first allaying the concerns of the American people. In essence, Bush continues to claim that his greatest concern is the safety and welfare of our country, but once again his actions belie his words.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

Maybe we can get a bid from them to handle our airport security. Just another sign of what happens when you have smart people in government! /dk

J.S. said...

Why can't we invade and take over some cool country that would make a good vacation destination? How about The Virgin Islands or maybe The Bahamas. Those places are just begging to become U.S. territories...

The League said...

Some of the Virgin Islands are US territories (like lovely St. Thomas), thus the name U.S. Virgin Islands.

J.S. said...

Look, if you're gonna be a smartass about it, we'll invade Phoenix.

The League said...

You will be welcomed as liberators.