Muslim protestors torched Danish and Swedish embassies in Syria today in retaliation for the printing of cartoons containing what they consider to be blasphenous depictions of the Prophet Mohammed. Although the story seemed a little ridiculous at first, when I really thought about it it kind of freaked me out. Here are people from one culture who are resorting to violence because of something printed in a cartoon from another culture. Talk about a disconnect between cultural values.
My first instinct was to kind of scoff at these Muslims for being uncivilized religious zealots who clearly don't understand the value of free speech. But is that view a bit ethnocentric? Is it possible that these Muslims understand free speech, but expect people who exercise that speech to be held more accountable for its content than the way that we typically hold writers accountable here in the west? After all, western culture tends to encourage criticism of and challenges to ideas on an almost reckless basis- I mean, normally political or humor writings are expected to be shrugged off in good humor or to be responded to in kind by the criticized (with similar writings or counterarguments). In the west, we value the open discussion of ideas over the protection of concepts (regardless of whether the open discussion of these ideas might constitute sacrilege to someone else). Westerners seem to have kind of abandoned the concept of "fighting words", or the concept that there are some subjects so sacrosanct that to attack them is an open call for hostility.
Part of the disconnect comes from the fact that it's hard for a lot of people in non-Muslim nations to understand the depth and scope of commiment involved in the religious faith of many Muslim believers. I think that for many Muslims, the faith that they pracitice is not akin to religion in the west. Muslim faith is not something which quietly lies below the surface, truly practiced and discussed only on weekends or at church. Instead, religion is a central keystone of their daily existence- a central component of their usual decision making processes and belief structure (yes, yes, I can hear Christians rising to clamor that it is the same for them, but I would assert that the very structure of western society in which we allow for and respect the freedom to practice different forms of religion precludes the kind of faith based daily living which occurs in the Muslim world. I mean, in Pakistan it is a crime punsihable by death to insult Mohammed or the Quran. Muslim followers are called to daily prayer in many middle eastern cities by the voices of imams being blared over loudspeakers in public places. Compare this to western tolerance of other religions combined with the largely secular western governments and you get an environment where tolerance of opposing ideas becomes more practically important than the pursuit of a life in keeping with perfectly practiced relgion).
Ah, crap. I gotta go over to Crackbass's house for dinner. Suffice it to say that I was gonna wrap this whole cultural relativity exploration by saying that I think ultimately the Muslims who torched the embassy were wrong for doing so, despite their religious convictions. I think that the failure to at least restrict their protests to argument (as opposed to the violence involved in burning down diplomatic embassies) leads only to a fascist, totalitarian state. Steanso is still a big believer in rights for ideological minorities, and the Muslims here are not leaving room for beliefs other than their own. Gotta go eat. Whooo hooo!
3 comments:
Steanso hasn't quite moved into the realm of allegory on his blog yet, so no, this has nothing to do with the A&M controversy (you no drinking, no dancing, Bible-hugging, God-squadding Baylor jackass).
The dinner was fine. Watching Crackbass and Jackbart make sweet, sweet love after dinner was less satisfying.
The intolerance of Muslims for any other thought or belief system is precisely why they should be ridiculed. They wouldn't be happy with the USA until we are all kowtowing to Mullahs, living in mud huts with no clean water and flies crawling around on our eyeballs. I say give them a chance to join the world in a spirit of live-and-let-live, and for the rest who refuse common courtesy, turn their homelands into an irradiated plain of baked glass.
Phlegmfatale, I think you might be oversimplifying things a bit. Also, in the context in which you used it, plane is spelled with an "-ane" as opposed to "-ain".
Post a Comment