Steanso spent just about all day today in court. He sat second chair for a bench trial with Laura, but the bad guy slipped away.
Tonight Steanso is attending a Spoon show with Crackbass. I hope it's good.
Not too much news. Mono E practice last night was good. Having become pissed off while watching Bush's address on Wednesday night, Captain Gottula put pen to paper and wrote the band a solid new tune called State of the Union. It's undoubtedly the best thing to come out of that speech.
And here's sopmething that's funny. The Aggies are suing the Seattle Seahawks for using their "12th Man" phrase, and apparently the Seahawks may actually put up a fight. The Seahawks filed motions to transfer the case to a federal court in Houston, moving the case 100 miles away from the original venue in Brazos County.
The whole thing is stupid for several reasons. First of all, the suit just reinforces the notion that Aggies are a bunch of humorless, overly fanatical nuts who place way too much emphasis on silly traditions. Second, the Seahawks should probably just dump the phrase (who needs it?), but if the multimillion dollar corporation which is the Seahawks actually choose to fight the Ags on this, the Ags are gonna end up spending countless dollars defending a stupid phrase- money which could be going to scholarships, infrastructure improvements, or even a big party for the student body (rather than into the pockets of a bunch of lawyers). What I'm saying here is, if they have to litigate this, even a win is really a loss for the Ags. Finally, as anyone who's ever made a trip to College Station knows, the Ags have more traditions than any reasonable person could count. You can't protect all of these absurdities. What's next? Suing people with pet Collies? Injunctions against individuals who refuse to let their neighbors walk on their lawns? Protests against other schools that are dumb enough to have all male yell leaders instead of attractive cheerleaders in short skirts? A ban against people who's campfires grow large enough that they might be in danger of being considered bonfires?
Lighten up, Ags!
10 comments:
In all fairness, it is a copyrighted slogan. How would you like it if some other guy started telling the ladies "Prepare for the Steans-Machine!"(tm) in their intimate times?
I assume you would be upset.
I wrote this and tried to post it before leaving work, but the blog server was down. Since almost everyone who reads this blog went to UT or supports UT, I felt compelled to respond. However, I appreciate the support Ryan, and that was smart for the Steans boys to trademark that phrase. I see a lot of money making in the future.
I know A&M is an easy target, and often is for most of the residents of this state, but I am surprised you bashed them in this case. Actually, this is the first time since you've written this blog that I'm surprised by your post (especially considering you are an attorney). If you think A&M suing the Seattle Seahawks is stupid then as far as I'm concerned what you are basically saying is that all US copyright and trademark law is stupid. Which is an argument that may have some merit, but direct your bashing to the correct source. Don't limit your bashing to just A&M, and certainly don't bash it's alums or fans for legal action that they had nothing to do with. This wasn't caused by some huge uproar from A&M's crazy alums and/or fan base because otherwise I would have heard about it (as you well know). I didn't even know Seattle was using the phrase until I watched the NFC Championship game two weeks ago. If you're going to bash or blame someone, bash your own profession, and our lawmakers. Well, you do the latter quite a bit so no need to increase the bashing there.
This has nothing to do with Ags being a bunch of humorless, overly fanatical nuts who place way too much emphasis on silly traditions (which by the way some are and some do). This is simply about MONEY (the almighty dollar which everyone worships), and A&M protecting its copyrights and trademarks. They have no choice. They have to take Seattle to court since the Seahawks are profiting off of an A&M trademark. They asked Seattle to stop using it in 2004, and they didn't. They asked them again this year to stop using the trademark, and they didn't.
Sure it's silly, but so are a lot of things in the legal profession (as I'm sure you will attest to). If A&M doesn't take Seattle to court then other groups, organizations, and people could start using A&M trademarks and copyrights to make money with no fear of reprisal. Then A&M's copyrights and trademarks would be worthless. I don't know why I feel compelled to explain this to an attorney, but I do after reading your post.
If I opened a t-shirt business, and sold 1000s of rip-off UT national championship shirts with the Longhorn logo on them without permission from UT then I will guarantee you that UT would send me "cease and desist" orders. If I didn't stop they would sue me and take me to court. It's that simple. It would have nothing to do with UT fans or alums or any perceptions about them. If the Houston Texans started using the Longhorn logo instead of their current one, and started profiting off of the use of that logo on merchandise, do you think UT would have a problem with it? Would UT be stupid for pursuing legal recourse in these cases? For protecting their trademarks and copyrights?
Don't blame A&M for having smart attorneys who thought in 1990 that it might be a good idea to trademark a phrase that A&M invented in 1922 when A&M student E. King Gill was called out of the stands to suit up for A&M due to the excessive amount of injuries that occurred while playing Centre College. He never went in, but he was the last sub on the bench. That's why A&M's student body always stands at home games. A symbolic gesture that each and every student is ready to come down and suit up for the maroon and white (the way we've been playing football recently, we may have to do this again). A&M's athletic booster organization is called the 12th Man Foundation. A&M walk-ons wear the number 12, are called the 12th Man, and represent the student body. The student body is called the 12th Man. But all of this is beside the point.
The point is A&M has the trademark and Seattle doesn't. Seattle is profitting off of the use of that trademark. Seattle could have made it their trademark in the 80s (that's when they started using the phrase), but they didn't. A&M did. So as far as that goes I say tough s@#t. Burger King can't use "I'm lovin' it", and AMD can't use "AMD Inside".
You're right this is a loss for A&M no matter what happens in court. In the grand scheme of things this is pretty silly, but I think that is a reflection of our legal system, and what this world has come to. How much money each year is wasted in legal battles over silly, pointless things that could have gone to good causes, but instead went into the pockets of attorneys. My wife used to work for a family law attorney and in the nastier divorces, people would end up having to sell the house they fought so hard to keep just to pay attorneys.
I'm not trying to bash attorneys here. I know a lot of your readers are attorneys, a lot of my friends are attorneys, I almost became an attorney myself (no kidding), and I think attorneys are necessary in a society governed by laws, and it can be a worthwhile and honorable profession (despite some of the sleezeballs and ambulance chasers). Too often attorneys get a bad rap. I know quite a few attorneys that are out there trying to help people (yourself included).
But don't throw me and other Ags under the bus because A&M's leadership and attorneys are suing the Seahawks (especially after the support we gave UT in the Rose Bowl). This is the world we live in. We live in a world that has thousands of laws, and plenty of attorneys to enforce them. Even for silly copyrighted phrases like "The 12th Man".
If you want to tell someone to lighten up, tell that to our lawmakers, and your fellow attorneys.
Look, just because you CAN sue doesn't mean you SHOULD sue, and for every attorney who files a lawsuit, there's an individual, corporation, or institution that's standing behind them as their client asking that legal action be pursued. Of course A&M has a right to sue- my point was just that it would have been a much better PR move to just let the Seattle fad slide by (it'll probably fade away anyway after the Superbowl, but if it doesn't, action could have quietly been taken in the off season). It's true than none of this would have happened without lawyers, but I don't think it happened BECAUSE of lawyers (that's kind of like blaming a mechanic for the way that a car gets driven). Also, Weedo, although I don't think YOU are humorless, I'm not sure your long response did much to convince me that Aggies aren't humorless and overly defensive about their traditions. No offense, but I think you kind of helped me prove my point...
I'm happy to have proved your point. However, you have proved my point. I expected this response from you because if this was any other group besides A&M, you wouldn't bash them, and you certainly wouldn't write a post about it. I knew I should have written a shorter response, but those that know me, know that I'm long winded. I should have left the boring stuff out. I agree that A&M should have chosen a different time to pursue this lawsuit (certainly after the Super Bowl). However, it's obviously not going away. A&M tried that last year, and Seattle didn't do anything.
You also missed another point I was trying to make. I never said it happened because of lawyers, I said it happened because the world we live in has laws, and Seattle is violating the law. However, silly that particular violation is. We have plenty of lawyers to enforce all of laws. How many of our congressmen are attorneys? We live in a world dominated by attorneys. Our government continues to get bigger and pass even more laws (like the Patriot Act). I'm not saying that's a good or a bad thing (well, the Patriot Act is a very bad thing), I'm just saying that's the reality of the situation. Whether it's AMD moving over the aquaifer, Sal Costello trying to stop the toll roads in our county, or Cindy Sheehan getting arrested at the State of the Union address (yes, the charges were subsquently dropped), or writing a will, attorneys are needed. I wouldn't have even gone down this road, but when you said that A&M was wasting all of this money on attorneys that could be going to good causes, I felt it was like the pot calling the kettle black. This isn't the first or last time that someone is going to spend money on attorneys that could have gone to something worthwhile. Yet, I have never heard you bring up your issues with our copyright laws in any previous post until A&M does something like this.
A&M's leaders told their attorneys to pursue legal action. Yes that's correct, but let's get this straight: 99% of A&M's students, alums, and fans had nothing to do with this action. Yet who doesn't like bashing A&M. It's the easiest target (Lee already took the bait).
I'm far more concerned with what our president has been doing illegally then with this minor case.
Lee, don't count out A&M in this legal battle. If they do lose this, I'd be surprised.
Company X has registered trademark Y. Company Z makes money off of trademark Y. Company X asks Company Z to cease and desist for 2 years. Company Z continues to sell trademark Y. Company X pursues legal recourse against Company Z for violation of US copyright laws.
I guess I proved your point again. I'm a pretty humorless guy. That must be someone else that's laughing on most of our recordings.
I didn't say everyone went to UT or supports UT, I just said most readers.
You're welcome Crackbass. Glad to entertain.
Wait. What point did I prove? Lawyers suck? I'm confused.
Also, Crackbass, doesn't your lady get tired of hearing the Steans-Machine mantra called out every time things get romantic?
No you didn't prove that lawyers suck, and now you're putting words in my mouth. Show me where in my comments that I said that lawyers suck.
The point you proved is that if this was any other school (or any other company for that matter) that was trying to defend it's trademarks, it wouldn't even get a mention on your blog. I haven't done an exhaustive search of your previous posts, but I don't recall any uproar from you over any trademark or copyright infringement no matter how silly some of them are. Since it's A&M though, it's worthy of a post and a bash on all of the silly, absurd traditions that we have. We're not the only school with traditions, but we are probably the one with the most, and we probably have the silliest traditions. Ok fine. Bash us for that. But don't link that with this lawsuit. I think that is the fallacy in your original post.
Again, A&M suing the Seattle Seahawks has nothing to do with the A&M's silly traditions. It's about money, and trademark infringement. That's it. It's not because A&M has the craziest alums and students. Any school in A&M's position would have done the same thing (well, maybe not during the Super Bowl) when dealing with another group or organization that is infringing on their trademarks and copyrights.
That's why I was surprised by this post, and why I had to respond to it. The lawsuit has nothing to do with A&M's "crazy traditions". If Marvel created a character named Superguy, and who used the Superman logo, but with a different color, wouldn't DC go after them? Sure it's a waste of money. Sure it's silly. It's a symbol on a comic book character, but nonetheless it's their trademark, and no one can use it without their consent or without shelling some money.
I guess if this argument still doesn't make any sense to you then so be it. We might as well stop it here. Well, I'm stopping it here because frankly I don't know how to explain my point any further.
I just hope you scour newsreports for other trademark and copyright infringements so that you can be fair, and bash them too for protecting their silly, absurd copyrights...
It's about money. I guess that should have been my only comment.
No. I wanna get the last word in.
there's really like watching Reed go into meltdown, is there?
I think any case to be made that A&M fans aren't humorless may have just evaporated.
This is why I am so glad I went to the school in Texas where students aren't even aware of any traditions.
Post a Comment