I went and saw District 9 on Saturday afternoon. [spoilers] Distric 9 is a sci fi movie about a segregated district that is set up as a sort of alien ghetto or slum after an alien spaceship becomes stranded on Earth (floating above Johannesburg, South Africa, actually). As one might expect, human reaction to the arrival of aliens is sharply divided, with some people demanding that the aliens receive the same civil rights and privileges as the human population, while another, more xenophobic segment of the human population resents the expenditure of resources upon the
aliens, distrusts their motivations (though few humans have direct contact with the aliens, so few people really know them), and generally wants to see them leave (which the aliens apparently can't do), or at least see them remain as far away from the human population as possible.
I thought District 9 was a really good movie. It had a lot to say about human nature and about the way that we treat other people that we see as different from us (many of the humans in this movie see the aliens as utterly different than humans, but as the film gives you a closer look at the aliens, it becomes clear that many of their instincts and motivations, in fact, have a lot in common with their human counterparts. And, of course, given the way we've seen mankind demonstrate inhumanity towards other humans over the course of history, it doesn't take a huge leap of logic to assume that large numbers of humans might have little difficulty exhibiting brutality toward beings who were actually from another world).
The movie is thick with metaphor, and it's really one of those movies that shows us what good science fiction can be. Although the movie deals with aliens and their arrival on earth, the main messages and questions that the movie presents are clearly the kind of thing that actually address human nature and the human condition. The movie isn't just about funny space men. There are themes in the movie that easily recall real world- historical events such as apartheid, the medical experiments carried out by the Nazis, concentration camps, etc.. Equally important, the movie asks what kind of characteristics a person has to have in order to deserve equal rights (should we base such decisions upon the way that a person looks? upon their habits and customs? Upon their point of origin? Shouldn't the ability to reason and think be enough?)
The film does a good job of carrying out the clever task of introducing aliens who look scary and inhuman (i.e., they look a lot different than us), before revealing that the humans in this movie are the real monsters. This might sound like a bit of a cliche (certainly not the first time we've seen that theme in sci fi), but the movie also takes pains to show that not all of these aliens are just a bunch of warm and fuzzy, E.T.-like aliens who are simply being chased by mad, bad scientists. The movie goes out of its way to show that there are aliens who are carrying out crimes and otherwise reacting poorly to the stresses of ghetto life and oppression, and there are some human political groups- though we see little of them- who are applying political pressure in order to try to safeguard the rights and the safety of the aliens (not all of the humans are necessarily bad- in fact, on the whole, the movie makes it appear as if there might be both malicious and well-intentioned people in both the alien and human populations). In keeping with the theme of discrimination and segregation, the movie takes pains to show that some of the aliens occasionally engage in bad behavior, and as in real life, the people who oppose alien rights and support segregation exploit these alien crimes to build distrust and spread fear of the aliens within the human populace.
Anyway, the movie isn't flawless (e.g., I thought there were a few issues in terms of pacing and the development of supporting characters- which can be difficult to overcome in a 2 hour movie), but I thought that it was quite good. They even managed to squeeze in some good action sequences and big explosions (now that I think about it, there were a lot of big explosions).
It's probably been my favorite movie of the summer (well, I still liked Star Trek, but that came out in May, so it's barely a summer movie). It kind of made a lot of the other sci fi that's come out lately (the new Terminator, Transformers 2, etc.) look even stupider than they already did (which was pretty freaking stupid).
So Steanso gives District 9 a hearty thumbs up. As a word of warning, there's definitely some pretty graphic violence in it, but it's a good flick.
aliens, distrusts their motivations (though few humans have direct contact with the aliens, so few people really know them), and generally wants to see them leave (which the aliens apparently can't do), or at least see them remain as far away from the human population as possible.I thought District 9 was a really good movie. It had a lot to say about human nature and about the way that we treat other people that we see as different from us (many of the humans in this movie see the aliens as utterly different than humans, but as the film gives you a closer look at the aliens, it becomes clear that many of their instincts and motivations, in fact, have a lot in common with their human counterparts. And, of course, given the way we've seen mankind demonstrate inhumanity towards other humans over the course of history, it doesn't take a huge leap of logic to assume that large numbers of humans might have little difficulty exhibiting brutality toward beings who were actually from another world).
The movie is thick with metaphor, and it's really one of those movies that shows us what good science fiction can be. Although the movie deals with aliens and their arrival on earth, the main messages and questions that the movie presents are clearly the kind of thing that actually address human nature and the human condition. The movie isn't just about funny space men. There are themes in the movie that easily recall real world- historical events such as apartheid, the medical experiments carried out by the Nazis, concentration camps, etc.. Equally important, the movie asks what kind of characteristics a person has to have in order to deserve equal rights (should we base such decisions upon the way that a person looks? upon their habits and customs? Upon their point of origin? Shouldn't the ability to reason and think be enough?)
The film does a good job of carrying out the clever task of introducing aliens who look scary and inhuman (i.e., they look a lot different than us), before revealing that the humans in this movie are the real monsters. This might sound like a bit of a cliche (certainly not the first time we've seen that theme in sci fi), but the movie also takes pains to show that not all of these aliens are just a bunch of warm and fuzzy, E.T.-like aliens who are simply being chased by mad, bad scientists. The movie goes out of its way to show that there are aliens who are carrying out crimes and otherwise reacting poorly to the stresses of ghetto life and oppression, and there are some human political groups- though we see little of them- who are applying political pressure in order to try to safeguard the rights and the safety of the aliens (not all of the humans are necessarily bad- in fact, on the whole, the movie makes it appear as if there might be both malicious and well-intentioned people in both the alien and human populations). In keeping with the theme of discrimination and segregation, the movie takes pains to show that some of the aliens occasionally engage in bad behavior, and as in real life, the people who oppose alien rights and support segregation exploit these alien crimes to build distrust and spread fear of the aliens within the human populace.
Anyway, the movie isn't flawless (e.g., I thought there were a few issues in terms of pacing and the development of supporting characters- which can be difficult to overcome in a 2 hour movie), but I thought that it was quite good. They even managed to squeeze in some good action sequences and big explosions (now that I think about it, there were a lot of big explosions).
It's probably been my favorite movie of the summer (well, I still liked Star Trek, but that came out in May, so it's barely a summer movie). It kind of made a lot of the other sci fi that's come out lately (the new Terminator, Transformers 2, etc.) look even stupider than they already did (which was pretty freaking stupid).
So Steanso gives District 9 a hearty thumbs up. As a word of warning, there's definitely some pretty graphic violence in it, but it's a good flick.
3 comments:
In case anyone's wondering why I erased Lonzo's comment, it's because his account was actually just a spam deal (some kind of vacation packages). Anyway, in his place I will take a second out to congratulate myself on my insightful review: Good job, Steanso!!!!
That was an insightful review, but you neglected to warn, when you warned that it was violent, that it was also heart-breaking. I really wasn't expecting it. SPOILER, I was extremely disturbed and freaked out by the "it sounds just like popcorn" scene, but then later in the movie when Charles finds out that they're performing experiments on his people, I was bawling like a little baby. And yeah, there were in my opinion, some problems with the movie, but I was impressed by how interesting and moving it was. And reading your blog review, I'm also intrigued by the "human rights" issue vs. alien rights and then it got me thinking about animal rights. And really, even treating them "humanely," killing them for our pleasure when it's not necessary for sustenance makes me feel bad. And I always thought I should be a vegetarian, but I like barbeque so much... I don't eat it that often, but I just can't imagine life without it. But I'm not entirely sure what entitles me to kill sentient beings...
Killer Kraber
Well, I'm glad to hear that you appreciated (and hopefully still liked) the movie, even if parts of it were really depressing. For me, the movie had this weird one, two punch where I would watch and think, "Well, that's troubling, but at least it's all just fiction, and those are just make believe aliens." Then, of course, half a second later I would realize that most of these ideas were gathered from things that people had done to other people at various times, and I would become really bothered again. It's a good movie.
Post a Comment