Hey! Not too much to report. Jamie made a nice fish dinner last night, and Cassidy got to play with Scout and Lucy. We watched a couple episodes of a British show called The IT Crowd. It's a comedy about some folks who work for the IT department of some large company. It had some funny stuff in it, but on the whole, I'm not entirely sure it's up my alley. Ryan says this might be because I don't really work around computers as much as he does. He might be right. Anyway, it's got a couple of the guys from The Mighty Boosh in it (Richard Ayoade and Noel Fielding), and, maybe not surprisingly, I thought they were the funniest parts of the show (even though, initially I didn't even recognize Richard Ayoade from Boosh). Anyway, I probably ought to give it another shot at some point.
And can I just go ahead and tell everyone that I'm sort of conflicted about Inglorious Basterds? The first reviews of the movie that I read weren't all that positive (there was one that was just downright negative), but now the thing has like an 88% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes. Anyway, even the positive reviews that I've read have all gone out of their way to talk about how violent the movie is and about how Tarantino's answer to the Holocaust is to turn his Jewish protagonists into a bunch of thugs who are just as sadistic and depraved as the Nazis. I'm just not sure that I'm going to want to sit through a movie like that.
As I told Reed when we were talking the other day, it's not so much that I mind violence in movies per say (I loved District 9, and there was violence o' plenty in that), but there's just something about having to watch violence inflicted upon helpless people, whether they be Jews, Nazis, or whomever, that I just have a hard time watching.
Also, frankly, I just find it a little juvenile and ridiculous that Tarantino's response to the horrors of Nazi Germany is to try to outdo the Nazis in their level of violence and general awfulness (seems like there's some kind of an old parable about an eye for an eye leaving the whole world blind... well, what happens when we take turns torturing one another to death?). Anyway, this is in addition to my annoyance with the general Hollywoodification of the Jewish experience during World War II. I read in an article, I think in Newsweek, that Tarantino said that he made this movie because he was tired of seeing the Jews portrayed as victims in movies about World War II. Well, uh, aside from a few, small exceptions, the Jews pretty much were victims in World War II. This isn't because of any sort of collective character defect on the part of European Jews during that time period- it's because the Nazis were pretty sneaky about what was actually going on (many people just thought the Jews were being "relocated"- which was very bad but not nearly as horrifying as what was really going on), and because the Jews just didn't have the training, equipment, support, and/or experience to mount any real sort of effective resistance (they didn't exactly have big stockpiles of weapons laying around). It strikes me as classic American arrogance (and naivete, in a way) to just reject the idea that a people could be systematically victimized by another group of people just because we find such a thought distasteful. The truth is that in the face of overwhelming military superiority that people sometimes don't have much choice other than to comply with orders from the people who would otherwise annhilate them. When your only choice is to do something that you don't like (i.e., get on a Nazi train or go to a camp or whatever) or else face immediate execution, people will take whatever course of action allows them to survive a little longer in the hopes that they will be able to later change their situation or that some external force will change it for them. Americans have a hard time accepting the truth that this sort of thing could potentially happen to any given group of people once another powerful group has demonized and dehumanized them enough to begin committing atrocities against them (hell, it has happened over and over- even in recent memory we've seen genocide in Bosnia, Rwanda, Darfur, Cambodia, etc.) . Americans sit in their houses polishing our guns and convincing ourselves that such things are beyond the realm of possibility for us, in a country where people fashion themselves as having a John Wayne style indepence and an unmatched ability to defend ourselves. Well, if soldiers rolled up on our streets in large numbers with military grade weapons, armor, training, and tactics, the people who chose to resist with the guns that they bought at Walmart probably wouldn't buy themselves much other than the privilege of being killed first. So I think Tarantino's film also just sort of annoys me in terms of it's "this is how American Jews woulda stuck it to the Nazis" theme. In my mind, the actual, real world way of fighting the kind of atrocities inflicted by the Nazis is to be intolerant of political movements, leaders, or groups which demonstrate intolerance and xenophobia, to reject groups and ideologies which would dehumanize or denigrate other groups of people, and to promote and vigorously defend the idea of basic, international human rights and civil liberties.
All of that being said, Tarantino has long ago proven that he's capable of writing some really interesting characters, and some cool dialogue. I'm sure there are things in the movie that I would really like. I'm just not sure I feel like sitting through scenes of people getting their heads bashed in and/or being burned alive in order to try to enjoy myself.
Well, I guess that's it for now. Maybe more later. I'm looking forward to the weekend. Hope you guys are, too.
No comments:
Post a Comment