Tuesday, August 25, 2009

MSNBC is Lame, Too; Democrats Weak on Health Care Reform; Torture Investigation Backlash

Hello, Adventurers! What's up?
I don't have too much to report. Last night I watched half of Synecdoche, New York. It's an interesting movie, but it was just too much to take in one sitting. I'll hold off on reviewing it until I've finished it, I guess.

I also watched a bit of MSNBC last night. Here's the thing about MSNBC, I've decided: it's decided to brand itself as "the liberal news network" (sort of a counterweight to conservative TV networks like Fox News), which means that I should be right in their target audience, but I don't really like MSNBC coverage because, as with Fox, I feel like I'm not necessarily getting the full picture. Last night they were talking about health care reform, and although I thought they were rightly criticizing some of the lies, distortions, and twisted propaganda of health care reform opponents, the analysts and anchors on the shows that I was watching (Ed Schultz from The Ed Show comes to mind) seemed unwilling to admit that some legitimate concerns and issues actually exist in the health care debate, and that people have a legitimate worries that need to be addressed (the extent of taxation to support the program and the reluctance of the federal government to control healthcare costs by further regulating frivolous medical malpractice lawsuits may be among these concerns).
Anyway, I just don't want my newscasters to be cheerleaders, regardless of which side they're pulling for. Just give me the facts. Or when an issue has two legitimate sides to it, cover both of them, but don't treat opposing arguments as equally cogent when, in truth, one side or the other makes little or no sense. I'm a progressive, and I'm a Democrat, but I just want to know the actual facts so I can tell whether or not I think our leaders are doing the right thing. I'm a lot less interested in distortions or omissions of the facts that are meant to make our leaders look like they're doing the right things.
The media is frustrating. I think CNN is my favorite at the moment, but they sort of hang out there in a ratings limbo. Fox and MSNBC's ratings seem to swing up and down in keeping with political shifts- whichever side (conservative or progressive) happens to be in opposition to the government at a particular time seems to draw higher ratings as people seek out reassuring voices from likeminded TV people who are willing to watchdog the government and lend voice to the frustration and confusion that their politically charged audience is feeling. People watch these news channels in order to be comforted and have their feelings normalized. CNN, still mostly attempting to remain neutral, tends to voice too many contrary opinions to keep either side entirely happy.
The press is supposed to be the traditional watchdog of government, but it seems like lately there's been an awful lot of collusion going on from both sides of the aisle. And I'm not sure what to do about it. The free market seems like it should support the media (because of, yeah, the whole watchdog thing), but it also seems like the American audience that makes up the free market is much more interested in just watching and supporting TV networks that support their political points of view than in watching networks who have objective reporting of the truth as their first priority (and I know I'm opening a whole line of argument here for people who would argue that I'm being naive and that there really is now way to objectively report the truth, but I still think that there's a way to at least attempt to do so for people who are willing to make journalistic integrity a much higher priority than their political beliefs).
I'm just really worried about the direction that American journalism seems to be headed.

I also have to admit that I find all of the debate over health care reform a bit exhausting. In the end, the general population isn't going to vote on the thing, and we all really know that the Republicans are going to use every single vote that they have to vote against it, so really I think this is a matter of getting the Democrats in a room and sorting things out. And yeah, I think the White House might need to twist a few arms. When Blue Dogs stand up and say that they don't support health care reform, I would tell them that they're totally entitled to their opinion and can vote against the bill- but they better give back all of the health care industry dollars they've collected before they cast that vote. If not, I think the White House and the Democrats ought to be endorsing and supporting primary opponents against these people in the next election and torpedoing every piece of legislation that smells anything like pork for these people's constituencies. It's time the president encouraged a little discipline within his own party. The internal discipline of the Republicans has allowed them to "accomplish" an awful lot over the years while the Democrats squabble and bicker and waste their opportunities.
This thing isn't over yet, but Obama needs to start stepping up (he needs to go on the offensive in this healthcare thing- do a much better job of pointing out the bureacracy and costs in the current system, remind people that they can't quit their jobs or move because of the current system, point out that reform opponents are trying to take away people's choices by shooting down the public option, etc.) and he needs to get the Democrats organized, on message, and in line. It's the only way major changes are going to happen. The Democrats have really disappointed me in their handling of this reform debate. More swiftboating. And this time we knew it was coming.

Also, apparently a bunch of Republicans are stating that they will formally protest the investigation of CIA personnel who interrogated and tortured prisoners in U.S. custody. Keep in mind that we haven't even come close to seeing any indictments and we're only looking into the matter at this point. I'm not sure what the hoopla is. We have laws, we have people designed to investigate and prosecute those laws, and being an intelligence agent in no way puts you above the law. Let the Justice Department do its job. If no laws were broken, there should be nothing to fear, right? Right??

No comments: