Friday, August 07, 2009

GI Joe; Polling Methodology and the Media

Hey! Not too much to report. I'm taking a vacation day today (I just had some extra ones, so I thought I'd go ahead and use one).
Last night I went and had dinner with Ryan, Matt, and Justin at Habana (Jamie was having a ladies night/So You Think You Can Dance party over at Steans Manor). It was kind of fun to hang out with the guys for a while, and hopefully Jamie had a good time with her freinds as well.

Today I just went to see the new G.I. Joe movie (technically called G.I. Joe: The Rise of Cobra). [mild spoilers] It was just about exactly what I expected. I was a G.I. Joe fan as a kid, collecting the toys and watching the cartoon and whatnot, so I pretty much knew what I was getting into. It's kind of hard to make a fun, adventurous, kid-friendly movie about soldiers and warfare. The idea that this would even be possible is sort of an outmoded concept, I think. Nonetheless, G.I. Joe has been filling the role of soldiers as superheroes for several decades now, so I was curious to see what Hollywood would do with the material. And, as promised, there were lots of gadgets and high tech vehicles and explosions and even some ninjas, but it was, in the end, a pretty dumb movie. The plot was perfunctory, the dialogue was bad, and the pacing was hyperkinetic. There were a couple of pretty cool fight scenes, though, and the movie made at least some attempt at providing some background on some of the key players (although even their backgrounds seemed pretty cliched and lame, for the most part).
I guess this movie is supposed to be geared toward kids? There's a lot of shooting and violence, but not much blood or gore. There was a family sitting in front of me with two young sons, and they weren't entertained at all. about half an hour into the thing they lost interest and started fighting with each other, talking, and walking up and down the aisles.
Anyway, on the ol' 1 to 10 scale, GI Joe would maybe come in at 5. Maybe.

CNN is compiling some sort of "report card" data on President Obama after his second 100 days in office, but I'm pretty suspicious of the whole thing. The scores are mostly concentrated at the extremes, with A's and F's getting the most votes. Here's the thing- this data relies on people self reporting, mostly by computer, so only the people who are most strongly motivated to send a message one way or the other are likely to take the time to participate (i.e., people who are big Obama supporters or people who really don't like him and have an axe to grind). On top of that, I would say, mostly on the basis of personal experience, that people who are really annoyed with or angry at the president are probably the most likely to vote. Just kind of looking at my own experience, I know that I've been much less inclined to blog about politics and participate in things like polls and surveys when I'm actually pretty satisfied with the way that things are going. When I was outraged at the policies and tactics of the Bush administration I was much more inclined to want to find ways to make my voice heard- venting my frustration and expressing my disapproval in the hopes that things would change, but now that I feel better about things I feel less compelled to take the time to voice my opinion. I think this is also the reason that you see conservative "tea parties" and other protests, while you don't see a ton of "let's support Obama" rallies (plus, small, vocal groups have begun to find ways to make themselves much more visible and within the media). As the media has found new ways to influence and gather data on their audience, the audience has simultaneously found ways to try to manipulate and alter the coverage that the media produces in their reporting.
Anyway, relying on people to come forward in order to voice their opinion (as opposed to seeking out a random sample of people in order to collect their opinion) is just a bad way of collecting "polling" data, and it makes the results pretty suspect. I'm not saying that Obama's support is as strong as it once was, by the way. I'm just saying that when you look at these sorts of polls you have to look at the methodology under which they were conducted in order to determine their reliability (and the methodology for CNN's "report card" kind of sucks). Oftentimes the media really don't care that much about the accuracy of their results, though. They really just hope they get something interesting to hyperanalyze on the air.

Well, that's it for now.
Hope you guys are having a good one. I'm going to go do some more "day off" type stuff.

No comments: