Monday, August 03, 2009

Weekend Update; Japanese Reinstate Juries

Hey, guys!
Well, the weekend started out okay, but then it sucked. Friday night I had dinner with Ryan and Jamie and hung out at their house a bit. We watched Pleadings, a movie which Jim Dedman, a friend of Ryan's from the RTF program at UT, had written and produced with some friends of his. There were some things that were well done in the movie, but on the whole, it just wasn't entirely my ball of wax. Maybe it was because it was about lawyers, and I get more than enough of lawyers and their tomfoolery already. Saturday I got up and went to Barton Springs with Team Steans. It was sort of overcast, but we got some swimming in, and went to the Central Market Cafe afterwards for lunch. Saturday night I went out to dinner with Ryan, Jamie, and Nicole.
The sometime very early Sunday morning I woke up feeling sick. I ended up feeling sick for most of the day. I even called off band practice, which is sort of a drag because we have a hard enough time getting practices together these days as it is.
Anyway, Sunday was a waste. I feel better today, but still not quite right.
Getting sick on the weekends is a super drag, but it seems like whenever I get sick, it happens on a weekend.

And I read on the BBC site today that Japan is getting ready to start using jury panels in its trials again after having relied on panels of professional judges for more than 60 years. Apparently the system that has been exclusively using judges has fallen under criticism for lacking transparency and possible convictions of innocent defendants. Even the new system, though, will require at least one judge from a three judge panel to reach the same decision as the one reached by the jury in order to validate a verdict.
As the Japanese get ready to implement this new jury system, some have voiced concerns about whether or not randomly selected members of the public are really qualified and knowledgeable enough to make decisions on major felony cases- especially cases that could involve the death penalty.
It just strikes me as interesting that one of the very things that Americans pride themselves upon- the use of randomly selected citizen juries of our "peers"- is one of the things that's arousing suspicion on the part of the Japanese.
And I'm not entirely sure that their wariness is unfounded. On the whole, I think juries mostly do end up doing a pretty good job and representing the viewpoint of the community. On the other hand, the process that gathers jury panels is random, and anyone who's worked in the court system for any length of time has seen jury panels that seem chock full of people who fall to one end or the other of the political spectrum (i.e., the "cop is always right" hanging juries at one end of the spectrum and the juries who are totally suspicious of the police, the prosecution, or any case that's brought by the government at the other end). Plus, there are those times when you get one strongly vocal person with some kind of strong ideological or political agenda on the jury, and occasionally you can just sort of watch those types of people sort of derail the whole decision making process of the entire group. Also, there's sort of a question in some cases about whether the members of the jury all possess the requisite comprehension and analysis skills to really fully understand the facts and law involved in the case.
On the whole, I'm definitely in favor of a jury system because I think it helps to provide some insurance against government "railroading" (i.e., pushing cases through to conviction in a sort of perfunctory manner without a real, objective examination of the evidence) and because I think that a democratic society ought to include a right to have one's guilt determined by one's peers rather than by a government official (I'll set aside the question of whether current juries are really made up of people who are the defendant's peers). On the other hand, I certainly don't think that our jury system is flawless, so it's interesting to see how another country is approaching the issue of setting up their own jury system after going without one for 60 years.

Well, that's all I have time for right now. Maybe more later.
Ciao!

No comments: