Last night I went to Jackbart's book signing over at Austin Books. It was cool. In addition to, of course, getting some issues of Poe that were signed by Jackbart, I also picked up the first issue of John Constantine: Hellblazer, a comic which I've really enjoyed over the years (even after they made that watered down, lamer movie version of the book starring Keanu Reeves). So, anyway, the signing was pretty cool.
Abdelbeset Ali Mohmed al Megrahi, the terrorist who killed 270 people when he blew up Pan Am flight 103, was released from prison in Scotland today because he's dying of terminal prostrate cancer and the Scottish justice system decided he should be able to die at home.
Steanso is pretty liberal about a lot of things, Adventurers, but this really pisses him off. This guy blew 270 people into little pieces (many of whom were Americans), and Scotland is worried about showing him compassion? Maybe the Texan in me is finally coming out, but honestly, I feel like he was shown compassion when he wasn't immediately executed for his crime (I really pretty much hate the whole idea of torture, but this is one of those guys that I really wouldn't have lost a lot of sleep over if I heard that they were doing some nasty things to him).
Anyway, send doctors into the jail, get the guy some medical treatment, etc., but no frakkin' way should he be going home under any circumstances. Even allowing the man to die with some semblance of dignity in jail shows much more compassion than he ever attempted to show for his victims. I know that the Scots think they're just doing the proper, civil thing by releasing this guy, and I can respect their desire to be compassionate people, but I think that this decision was an affront to the victims of this crime and their families, and that, frankly, it was a decision that was simply unjust. When you slaughter 270 innocent people you have proven yourself unworthy and undeserving of mercy and compassion. This ruling by Scottland strikes me as a decision that wasn't so much about justice as it was about a government and judiciary which felt like it wanted to make a display of its own benevolence and mercy. The focus seems like it shifted away from the actual crime and its victims and at some point moved to Scotland's ability to send a political message regarding its ability to rise above the desire for simple revenge. Well, I really do think that making this man die in prison would have satisfied justice, not revenge. Already there have been claims by some observers that the real motivation behind this Scottish decision stemmed from a desire by leaders in the U.K. and the U.S. to shore up relations with Libya in order to facilitate the purchase of oil from that country. Also worth noting is the fact the U.S. was supposedly assured by Scottish authorities at the time of trial that the bomber would serve out his full prison sentence in Scotland without being returned to Libya if he were tried in Scottish courts and never extradicted to the United States. Now the bomber is headed home to say his final goodbyes and spend the final months of his life in peace.
If he wanted to say goodbyes, they should have been said from the confines of a Scottish prison. Grrrrr....
The people making the decisions in this case ought to be truly, deeply ashamed of themselves.
What else is in the news? CNN reports that debunked rumors continue to influence the health care deabte. Well, no shi*t. Really? That's a headline? Still just figuring that out? What strikes me as even more annoying is the fact that CNN and other news outlets keep acting as though all of these health care protesters who are disrupting meetings and spreading misinformation are just poor, hapless dupes who are victims of a disinformation campaign by the health care lobby and right wing organizers. Here's the thing: most (or at least many) of these people either know that the soundbites and talking points that they're spouting (or yelling) are bullsh*t, or else they just don't care about whether they're true.
They don't really understand what healthcare reform involves or how it will effect them, but they know that Rush Limbaugh, Glenn Beck, Sarah Palin, and Sean Hannity are against it, so by God, they're against it, too. It doesn't matter if it will ultimately keep more people healthy or help to keep down healthcare costs- healthcare reform is a plan that Democrats are advocating, so it must be evil, it's undoubtedly ruining our country, and it must be opposed by any means necessary (well, to be fair, they haven't actually killed anyone yet, but they've started carrying guns to rallies, so we'll just keep an eye on that statistic for a while and see what develops) . CNN and other news outlets don't want to offend any potential members of their audience (can't afford to lose a single viewer, you know), so they won't just admit that by now this thing is way beyond facts, figures, and things that make logical sense. We're way into the "us against them" phase, and I tend to think that a significant number of health care reform opponents see facts as just suspicious tools that those sneaky Democrats somehow always find a way to use against them. Facts being so rarely helpful to the sort of conservatives who enter into shouting matches and propaganda wars like this one (can we all fondly remember the beautiful simplicity of the swiftboating campaign against John Kerry?), many of those on the right have now decided to reject facts entirely and to fabricate reality out of whole cloth in order to create a fictional world which better suits their sensibilities.
Working on the mental health docket I deal with delusional thinking on a daily basis, and I'm going to just go ahead and say that I've begun to see signs of it again and again in these town hall meetings. The biggest weaknesses in a democratic governmental system are ignorance and unthinking, emotional reactions within the populace, and the legacy of Karl Rove is a whole new methodology (through new ways of manipulating the mass media and new organizational structures that are used to "control the message") that exploit exactly those weaknesses. Deny facts. Disseminate misinformation. Stoke fealings of fear and anger. Develop an "us against them" worldview, and present your party as a safe haven for the "real Americans". It's not a methodology based on logic or facts at all. And many of the people consuming it have gone so far down the rabbit hole that they no longer have any deisre to seek out information. They just want the soundbites and propaganda that's fed to them through certain, approved channels (specially designed to reinforce their worldview).
CNN is wrong. The reform opponents aren't concerned with facts. They simply don't trust them. They've been taught for decades now not to trust any piece of information that comes from anything other than an approved, conservative source (and Fox News, who's still telling people not to trust the "mainstream media"- which has long been described by the right as liberally biased- now has more than twice as many viewers as CNN and MSNBC combined, and recently came in as number one across a ratings comparison of all TV news programs. So now that Fox is mainstream, shouldn't they be distrusted too? Or shouldn't people be at least be cross checking their Fox data against less "mainstream" sources?). We have networks and news shows which freely admit to having a progressive agenda these days (i.e., the anti-Fox people at MSNBC and Air America, for example), but the conservatives continue to lump in any news outlet that doesn't have a conservative agenda as "liberal". They won't even allow for the possibility of objective, fact-based journalism.
Anyway, it's nice to think that people are coming to town halls and shouting down leaders simply because they've become fearful after becoming rattled by disinformation, but the truth is that lots and lots of people just don't want to look at real facts, and Fox is perfectly willing to step in and fill the void with propaganda that fits neatly into the hole in people's lives that used to be filled by actual reporting.
The irony is that there really probably are some very legitimate reasons for people to be concerned about health care reform (How will we pay for it? How will it effect the availability of specialists and elective procedures? What kind of wait times will we be talking about in order to get in to see a doctor? Will subsidization of a government option really drive private providers out of business, in trun limiting our choices? etc.,), but the tradgedy is that if health care reform were to fail in a vote tomorrow, it probably wouldn't be because of anything resembling a legitimate reason. Instead, it would fail because of opposition garnered through scare tactics, fearmongering, and simple, visceral animosity toward "the other side" (death panels, a communist/Nazi takeover, direct government access to our bank accounts, etc.).
There's a very real, very intelligent public debate out there to be had about health care, but industry lobbyists, political leaders (some conservative and some just in the pockets of the health care lobby), and even the public seem to afraid to address the real issues. Maybe they're afraid that a lot of the fears surrounding legitimate issues can be allayed, so instead they're clinging to lies, distortions, and emotion in their desire to "win" (another irony, I think, is that a lot of the people who are protesting at these town hall meetings are going to be the same people who will be suffering in the coming years if health care reform doesn't pass).
Our health care system just isn't all that good. By almost any measure and in almost any poll that you see, we're lagging behind many other countries in the industrialized world. People who work hard every day in our country can't afford health care. And most every prediction says that things will get worse if changes aren't made.
Anyway, I keep promising myself I won't get sucked farther into this healthcare tomfoolery, but obviously it's not working. I'm going to go surf the internet and look for cute, soothing pictures of puppies, dolphins, and penguins now.
No comments:
Post a Comment