Monday, August 17, 2009

Weekend Update; Health Care Reform and the Public Option

Hey! The weekend was pretty good, if not overly eventful. Friday night I went and had Chinese food with Ryan and Jamie and then watched some TV at the crib (I got Ryan to watch a new episode of The Colony with me). Saturday I got up and took Cassidy to the pet store for food, followed by a trip down to the Barton Springs spillover, where we got in some sun and splashing. Saturday afternoon I went and saw District 9 with Team Steans (review here). The movie was especially crowded, and I ended up not even being able to sit with Ryan and Jamie, but it was good. Saturday night I went out to Don and Jajuan Wilson's house for a wedding shower for Andy and Rami. It was nice, and the food was really good. Sunday I got up and went and had brunch with the family at the Iron Cactus down on 6th Street (my parents were in town, so we celebrated my dad's birthday, even though it's really not until next Friday). The Iron Cactus has a really good brunch on Sundays. I piddled away much of the afternoon on Sunday( a little reading, little guitar, little nap), and went out to dinner with Matt, Nicole, Ryan, and Jamie at Maudie's on Sunday night. It was good to see Matt and Nicole.
So it was a good weekend. Lots of good meals and good company. I ate too much.

And the New York Times ran a front page article saying that the "public option" may be dropped from the health care reform legislation. This means that there wouldn't be a government run health insurance program to compete with private insurance providers and drive costs down. I think I'm pretty strongly in favor of the inclusion of a public option. Private insurance companies and health care providers are claiming that such a program would be subsidized by tax dollars, would compete unfairly, and would drive private insurance companies out of business. On the contrary, I think that a big part of the problem with our current health care system is that the companies involved with health care have allowed prices to become unnecessarily inflated (I think there's just a lot of waste and inefficiency built into the system, and, of course, the goal of the health care companies, like any other business, is to maximize profits rather than always providing patients the best treatment possible at the lowest price). I think that if the legislation is written to keep subsidization of the public option to a minimum, and if private health care providers operate their businesses fairly and honestly, there's no reason private companies can't be very competitive and continue to make money (we have companies like Fed Ex and UPS competing very successfully against the government-run U.S. Post Office, and the private companies seem to be the ones who are thriving while the postal service sort of struggles).
There's a big part of me that thinks a government option is probably the only way to keep private industry honest within the health care industry. People will continue to buy private insurance if the prices are competitive and if private industry can provide extra services or a quality of service that the public option cannot. On the other hand, if private insurance continues to grow increasingly, ridiculously expensive, people will have a public option to turn to if they are otherwise unable to afford coverage.
All of that being said, I recently watched a piece on CNN that discussed health care reforms that were implemented about 3 years ago in The Netherlands, and it seems like they've managed to effectively implement a system that's devoid of a "public option", but which instead has a heavily regulated system of private health care providers. Dutch citizens are now required to have health insurance, and they receive government subsidies to help with it when they can't afford it. Anyway, according to the CNN story, this Dutch system is much less expensive than the American system (the average amount spent per patient per year was almost half of that in the U.S.), many more people are covered (theoretically, the coverage is almost 100%), the ratio of doctors to patients throughout the country is much higher, and the life expectancy of Dutch citizens is about a year to two years longer than in the U.S.. So even though there's not a public option in The Netherlands, they seem to have found a health care model that's working more effectively than ours.
All of this to say that maybe the death of the "public option" isn't necessarily the end of the world in the health care debate.
Mainly, though, I worry about whether or not we can effectively regulate the health care industry and control costs here in the U.S.. The minute we pass new regulations I'm afraid that the health care industry will hire armies of lawyers and lobbyists to find loopholes and create end runs around cost control legislation. I'm not sure.
Anyway, ideally I'd like to see a public option in the health care reform package, but if we don't get it, maybe we can still make some positive changes, anyway.
Off and on for a while now the White House and top Democrats have periodically raised the possibility of private, possibly non-profit insurance cooperatives and other options that might help to quell right wing worries about the public option and its potential for turning into a single payer, government run health care system (leaving the public with few if any alternative choices).
Frankly, if the end result is effective health care at lower costs for more people, I'm not really that concerned about how we get there. As we've seen before, I think Obama is a fairly pragmatic president, so I doubt that he's inclined to get hung up on ideology if he thinks that he can accomplish the same goals by different, less controversial means. It'll be interesting to see how this all plays out.

No comments: