Saturday, March 25, 2006

Well, the Texas Alcohol and Beverage Commission has recently been taking it upon itself to seek out and punish people who appear to be intoxicated in bars. There is a public intoxication statute here in Texas which allows officers to arrest a person who is intoxicated in public if that person may potentially pose a threat to the safety of himself or others (which the law has interpretted to include the mere possibility that a person may stumble or fall down).

Given the amount of drunk driving, domestic violence, and other collateral consequences of alchohol consumption that plague our state (and country), I kind of understand what TABC is trying to do (which I presume is to stop drunk drivers before they get behind the wheel), but, c'mon... arresting people for being drunk in a bar? Having dealt with TABC officers and their enforcement policies both in JP court as a prosecutor and county court as a defense attorney, I've kind of mulled this over a bit. I think the real problem is that our society is sending strongly mixed messages about alcohol consumption. We advertise alcohol, glamorize alcohol, and sell it to the tune of a billion dollar national industry. The consumption of alcohol occurs at pro sporting events, musical concerts, in restaurants, at fairs and festivals, and in a hundred other venues that I can't even think of. Billboards, television commercials, print ads, and radio commercials all remind us of the good times that are to be had by consuming alcohol, and bars, taverns, and eating establishments across the country rely heavily upon the sale of alcohol as a profitable cornerstone of the food and beverage industry.
But the same impaired judgement and lowering of inhibitions that make the consumption of alcohol so popular (I mean, drinkers think of these effects in other terms, but they do recognize the effects of alcohol) also lead to drunk driving and other problems, and for every bartender or waitress who relies on beer, wine, and liquor to make his living there is a MADD mother out there somewhere who would rather just see prohibition reinstated.
Anyway, I just see these latest actions by the TABC as a symptom of the "mixed messages" problem that we're facing in this country in terms of alcohol. It seems absolutely ridiculous for government officers to hang out in bars and then arrest people for consuming the beverages that the bar has been legally distributing and which the customer has legally been consuming for the better part of the night (especially when there's no indication that the patron has demonstrated any desire to get behind the wheel of a car or engage in any other truly harmful behavior).
I also, for the record, think that the DWI laws are really screwey (and I imagine that people are going to really think I'm nuts because of this rant). As the laws now stands, it is legal for a person to drink and drive so long as that person is not intoxicated (a person is considered intoxicated once they have a blood/alcohol concentration of .08 or once they are deemed to have lost the "normal use of their mental or physical faculties"). Here's the rub- we allow people to drink and drive so long as the person uses sound judgement and monitors their own alcohol intake/consumption so that they're still able to drive safely once they get behind the wheel of a car, but the whole problem with alcohol in the first place (i.e., one of the main reasons we don't let people drive while intoxicated) is that it impairs a person's judgement. So we're relying upon the judgement of a person who has ingested a substance which has been shown to impair a person's ability to objectively make judgements, and we're hoping that this impaired person knows their own limits enough to police themself. I guess that the problem is that once a person has reached a level of intoxication where they shouldn't be driving, then that person is probably also not in a position to be the best judge of whether they're really capable of driving.
We've all seen the person who is going to drive home, despite the fact that they've clearly had too much to drink, because they don't want to admit or are unable to recognize that they aren't completely in control of their faculties, and we all know people who claim to have a high tolerance to alcohol, failing to recognize the fact that tolerance of alcohol has much more to do with learned coping mechanisms and familiarity with the effects of alcohol than the absence of alcohol's effects on the body and mind.

Although a lot of times having one drink, in reality, isn't going to effect someone's driving once they get behind the wheel, the whole slippery slope of deciding "how much is too much" becomes problematic when we're asking people who have had a few drinks to make the decision if whether to drive. It's a stupid way of looking at drunk driving. Our policy (and again, I know this won't be popular with a lot of my friends) ought to simply be a zero tolerance policy for drinking and driving. A zero tolerance policy would simply force people to make alternate transportation plans if they are planning on drinking at all. It would make the privilege of driving contingent upon the fact that a license holder will promise not to drive if he's got any detectable alcohol in his system.
I really haven't convinced myself of this whole zero tolerance idea, but they use it for pilots and some other countries already have it, and here's why it might be a good thing:
1) a zero tolerance policy would let people know without any uncertainty where they stood if they got behind the wheel of a car after drinking. Most people don't realize how low a .08 Blood alcohol concentration is, and how easy it is to rise above that limit (as a guideline, I believe that most drinks will boost your level by at least .02 and that the body can only process, or get rid of, .02 per hour, at most. Keep in mind that mixed drinks may have an alcohol content considerably higher than .02). As a defense attorney, I had a number of clients who got DWIs who honestly were shocked to see how high they had blown on the breathalyzer or how much difficulty they had with field sobriety tests after just a few drinks. You have to keep in mind that the standard is "loss of the use of your normal faculties", and not falling down drunk. Usually if you can really feel the effects of alcohol you're probably pushing the legal limit.
2) I think that once a zero tolerance policy were put into effect, eventually the need to find alternate forms of transportation (rather than driving oneself) would become simply become a fact of life that most people would learn how to deal with. I'm not advocating prohibition here, but rather the adoption of new attitudes toward alcohol consumption as a culture. People might be more willing to give each other rides and hopefully the zero tolerance law would make true designated drivers more common (as opposed to the "whoever drinks the least drives" rule), and there might be more use of cabs and public transportation, etc. Austinites might finally vote for light rail so people can go out for dinner and some drinks downtown and then ride the train safely home.

But I think that the alcohol industry and its lobby are too strong. They won't let a zero tolerance law go into effect, even if such a law might ultimately make drinking safer and more acceptable.
Man, I don't know. I just think that our alcohol laws are hypocritical, inconsistent, and that they create a situation involving uncertainty and ambiguity for citizens out there who are just wanting to have a good time.

But now it occurs to me.... What am I doing? It's Saturday for God's sake. Time to take Cassidy outside!!!!!!!!!

No comments: