Wednesday, March 01, 2006

Well, online colleges got a big break this week when Congress changed a budget bill to allow students to receive federal financial aid even if the institutions which they were attending didn't host at least half of their classes on an actual, physical college campus.
I may be wrong, but it seems like the federal government may have acted a little too quickly when approving financial aid for these sorts of educational programs. Many of the schools that offer extensive online degree programs are schools which are operated on a "for profit" basis (rather than traditional universities, which tend to be non profit), and these "for profit" schools, as a group, have managed to put together some fairly extensive lobbying efforts in order to free up federal dollars (in the form of federal financial aid) so that they might be spent at online universities. As far as I know, there are currently no nationwide academic standards which seek to guarantee the quality of education provided by many of these online schools, and critics have accused a number of these "for profit" universities as being set up to do little more than collect financial aid from their students (as opposed to seeking to deliver any sort of meaningful education). These schools may be collecting fees from their students with no intention of seeing the students through the entire educational process (from entrance to graduation), or the schools may be granting degrees and diplomas to students who have, in truth, gained no real knowledge or skill sets as a result of their participation in the online programs. With these degree programs now open to federal financial assistance, the incentive for "for profit" universities to spring up and enroll students may be more attractive than ever, but unless new academic standards are put into place, the requirement that these schools provide their students with a quality education has not improved.
Let me hasten to say that I'm not against distance education, per se. My brother, Ryan "Roundball" Steans works in the distance education field at Arizona State University, and he knows a whole lot more about all of these issues than I do, but I'm sure he would be quick to point out that distance education has its place in the academic community. Online education provides information and teaching resources to people who otherwise might not have the access or opportunity to attend college classes. Students in rural areas, students who are working full time, and even professionals who are out working in the field all might legitimately benefit from distance education. Distance education which is part of a legitimate educational program is not what I'm talking about here (in my mind, legitimate educational program means that there is the opportunity for ongoing interaction between students and instructors, there are tests, projects, or other benchmarks by which one can measure how much learning is taking place, and the classes, as a whole, are part of an accredited program which is open to review by other academics or professionals within that field of study). The real issue arises in terms of accountability- particularly when an institution of higher learning is operating in a "for profit" capacity. I'm just saying that I'm extremely reluctant to see federal (tax supported) financial aid programs made avialable to "for profit" universities when there is no reliable system of oversight in place to make sure that these online universities are actually teaching anyone anything. Without oversight, I envision a multitude of fly by night "universities" popping up which are eager to take federal financial assistance from well-meaning students, but which rarely graduate any students, or which produce students with degrees that aren't worth the paper thast they're printed on. I hope I'm not coming off as too much of an academic snob, either. I just think that if you go to school you should probably actually learn something. Hopefully that's not too much to ask.
OK. Enough of that. I should have left that rant up to Roundball, anyway. Just ask him about The University of Phoenix (which I think is currently the biggest online university in the U.S.). He doesn't really rant about it, but whenever I've asked him about it he kind of rolls his eyes.

In other news- well, there's not much other news in the world of Steanso. Crack practice tonight! Kim Bloom got a phat new car (it's a black Volkswagon Passat, and it's wicked cool- we went to lunch in it today). The weather is getting unseasonably warm, and I think Cassidy is itchin' for a trip to Barton Creek (or maybe I'm just projecting).

7 comments:

The League said...

First of all, thanks for sabotaging any chance I might ever have had for moving into the educational private sector. In case you ever want to run for judge, I just want for everyone to know Steanso does the least possible to see to it that justice is served as a prosecutor.

You said, "in my mind, legitimate educational program means that there is the opportunity for ongoing interaction between students and instructors, there are tests, projects, or other benchmarks by which one can measure how much learning is taking place, and the classes, as a whole, are part of an accredited program which is open to review by other academics or professionals within that field of study"

Quite right. All universities are held to academic standards to be accredited. The problem comes when the consumer/ student doesn't know about accreditation but sees a legitimate chance to receive an education. Academic accreditation is the hallmark of an accceptable educational institution. They usually find out around the time they try to get a job and find out an "electronics degree" is not the same as an electrical engineering degree.

When I roll my eyes at UofP, it isn't because of what they're actually teaching, which I believe to be sound. UofP uses the hard-sell approach to recruiting vs. the traditonal method of first becoming a recognized school and then turning away applicants who don't make the cut. With expanding face-to-face satellite campuses set up in office parks and with a global onlien effort, UofP also doesn't have the restrictions that a brick and mortar institution might face. And, yes, they do make money. Gobs of money. You can find their annual report on their website and it's amazing.

But I think lobbing stones at online programs because you assume that the programs are not academically sound is actually a reflection of the sad state of American collegiate academics. In truth, UofP's academic model is probably more correct from an Instructional Design standpoint than standard classroom based instruction of lecture to exam, and certainly much more sound than the beloved Socratic method, which seems more determined to cram short term to avoid humiliation than to actually learn anything.

UofP is largely project based, and largely constructivist. UofP is also accredited in many of their online degree programs. Regarding faculty/ student instruction, unlike many universities which have hundreds of students in a course, UofP maxes out class sections at around 20. All faculty are adjuncts, teaching to an apporpritately designed set of curriculum. All faculty go under review with each and every semester. If the students can't pass or give the instructor bad marks, the adjunct is not asked to return. What they are not is a research institution, but that's why you won't find them teaching Engineering or the Natural Sciences.

All that said, the semester system is intended to bring students through at a very rapid pace and (1) get as much money from each student as quickly as possible, or (2) get working professionals the degrees they seek in a shorter time period.

Do they abuse the federal funding for education? I think that's a debate I'm not prepared to have. Do they use it to make money? Sure.

You can knock for profit institutions, but keep in mind that whenever the legislature votes not to increase spending at a university, that means that the value of research and education at state and private educational institutions takes a major hit. Universities then need to go scrounging for money, usually diverting attention away from their primary mission of serving students. Most online efforts at Universities are launched not due to an interest in public service, but because many see it as an opportunity to recover costs lost in the past several years.

Just FYI

J.S. said...

Okay, but what I still want to know is: 1) is the U of P (and are most online universities) actually accredited? and 2) have there been any studies to see if people learn and/or retain as well when they learn in an online enviroment? (the good old Socratic method may blow, but you still have to pass the bar exam to see that you SOMEHOW learned the material before they let you practice law- I wanna know if people still manage to pass licensing tests or similar licensing exams after learning the material in an online manner. I'm actually genuinely curious about how well people manage to learn when they're not put in a classroom-type enviroment which, at least somewhat, tends to force them to pay attention). Is computer learning better or worse for people who have problems paying attention?

J.S. said...

By the way, the whole idea of profit-based education still scares me, but I'm not sure why. I think I'm uncomfortable with the bald assertion that the number one priority of the school is making money rather than educating students (although I know this view can be criticized as hopelessly naive given the way most modern universities are operated). I think I'm also made a little nervous by the possibility that the nature of education may be shaped more by the demands of shareholders than the needs/desires of students (once again, recognizing the practical counterarguments that might be made in terms of traditional university systems).

Still, are they honestly going to teach us about the enviromental dangers posed by the petroleum industry at Texaco University?

The League said...

Yeah, some of the pertinent programs that usually have accreditation are accredited (sp?) at schools like UofP. If you want to make a profit, you need to make sure you've got that value for your customer. I should mention that ABET (engineering) accreditation requires that online work mirrors/ equals on-campus work. Students are expected to meet similar criteria and have similar syllabi to on-campus students.

The research on online learning for higher ed tells you very little. A few years ago it said that online students perform better than on-campus students. I would attribute this to the fact that most online students take one class at a time rather than showing behaviors of on-campus students who are taking a full load, working, etc... Also, online students who realize that they aren't doing well tend to pull out quickly and never receive grades and are never assessed. Anecdotally, I can tell you that my experience says it's usually up to the student and class.

To answer your attention question: As someone who was once diagnosed as ADD (and had a wild ride on the Ritalin) I can say that the online classes I've taken, which were largely discussion and text based, were easier for me to follow than some boring dude droning on at the front of the classroom, having you read boring chapters and then lobbing an exam at you that they wrote five years ago.

I think your questions regarding stock holder control are a good one. I don't really see online for profit programs dealing much in controversial areas currently, but as things progress... What I don't know is if we'd see Universities of this type able to maintain accreditation in an atmosphere of intellectual intimidation or how, say, Texaco would benefit from owning an intellectual institution which doesn't perform research (which would inevitably lead to intellectual issues making research moot). I think Google already has some sort of ed online. And they're a perfect company to do it as they're dedicated to the broadening of knowledge.

For all the bashing online education gets, the fact is, online for-profit institutions are providing an opportunity for an education that a lot of people otherwise may not have. Not everyone is able to take on more loans right after undergrad for grad school. Some people may wish to change career paths after the kids have arrived. Some folks are on military ships floating a few miles out in the Persian Gulf with a lot of free time they can't use but could use the information to better perform their duties.

I think there's a fear that "just anyone" can now have a degree, and I think it's both alarmist and elitist. The bottom line is that we're in an age where information is our commerce, and for-profit institutions reflect a huge need in society. Their ability to provide content delivery anytime, anywhere to folks who WANT the information (rather than "undeclared" freshmen coasting through on Mom and Dad's dollar) is serving a vast market. The honest truth is that the cost isn't really that high. If the education itself sucks, then schools like UofP will be out of work as employers will no longer foot the bill for their coursework. Further, if schools begin to gain a reputation as making their students unemployable, then I don't think their stockholders are going to be too happy.

That's my $0.02

Anonymous said...

Well what I have gathered from all this information is that Roundball should be able to move to Austin and keep his job at U of P (he can just do all the work via internet)I do have a question for steans meister, what is it with the acid induced word verification required to post a response?/donna karon

The League said...

Just for clarification, I do not work at UofP. I work at a State School in Arizona. And, no, I cannot do all my work online. We're actually a video based online educational distributor, which means I am geographically locked down to where the faculty live.

The League said...

I had no idea that the Transylvania School of Mad Science had online programs, especially an MD in Witch Doctoring. Congratulations on being a pioneer!