Thursday, March 05, 2009

Wendigo Update

Does everyone remember the crazy story about the guy who randomly attacked some guy on a Canadian bus last August, ending up beheading and partially cannibalizing the victim before the police were able to take him into custody? Well, I wrote about it a bit on my blog at the time that it occurred, mostly because the case seemed so bizarre, and I was sort of convinced just from reading the newspaper accounts that the defendant must have suffered some sort of psychotic episode and been extraordinarily delusional at the time that he committed the crime (I know this wasn't exactly an amazing insight on my part, given the complete lack of rationality involved with the crime, but I guess the events immediately struck me as a more extreme version of something similar to a few of the crazier criminal mental health cases we've seen here in Travis County).
Anyhooooo, a judge up in Canada ruled today that Vince Li, the defendant in the case, was mentally ill and not criminally liable for the killing. Li was ordered into a locked psychiatric facility where he will undergo periodic reviews to determine whether he continues to present a danger to himself or others. The judge's ruling was delivered after a two day trial, during which two psychiatrists presented testimony about Li's mental illness and his state of mind at the time of the incident. The victim's family expressed outrage and suggested that changes in the law were necessary to prevent future defendants from escaping conviction by reason of mental illness.
So it's a very strange case, sensational case, and I get to write off some of my curiosity as being professional as opposed to strictly morbid. I just wanted to update everyone, in case anyone was interested in that particular chain of events besides me.

2 comments:

NTT said...

Yes but who's going to take responsibility for when the psychiatrists deem him fit to re-enter society? It's surprising that the prosecution so willingly went along with the defense posture in this case.

None of the articles goes into any account of proper institutional care for such inherently dangerous patients.

J.S. said...

There are some cases that even prosecutors can't make sense of in terms of any kind of normal human instinct or impulses, and I guess this was one of them. There was a case in Austin a while back in which a college music student killed his piano teacher and hacked up her head with a butcher knife because he thought she had a computer chip in her head that she could use to control people. A friend of mine, Corby Holcomb, tried the case in felony court, but he didn't really go out of his way to secure a criminal conviction. Instead, he just presented the facts to the jury as he understood them, including the testimony of a psychiatrist who said that the kid had suffered a severe psychotic break (schizophrenia), and then he just let the jury decide what to do with the case as they saw fit (he didn't make a strong argument for conviction over insanity). The kid was found insane and placed in an institution for violently mentally ill people, but he comes up for review every year. Incidentally, when the defendant was finally medicated and normalized after the incident, he expressed suicidal ideation in a manner similar to this Canadian guy (even the defendant couldn't believe what he had done).

Mental illness is tough to deal with. Lots of people want to be touchy feely about it when it only involves minor crimes, but when major crimes are involved people have a much more difficult time accepting that mentally ill people may not be in control of themselves. The problem, though, is that if we're really going to take mental illness seriously, we have to be able to accept what it can do in the really bad cases as well as in the easy ones. (one thing I would be quick to point out, though, is that once a person has been diagnosed with mental illness and they know how to treat themselves for it, they should be held responsible for their actions if they refuse or fail to take care of themself or refuse medication. Both the Canadian bus case and the Austin microchip case involved "perfect storms" of apparently bad circumstances in which people had a really bad episode at the onset of their illness, before they realized that they had an illness which could make them spin violently out of control).
Anyway, the Canadian system sounds a little different than the one that we have in the U.S., but yeah, there is always the possibility that one of these people will get out of their institution after being cleared by a doctor. Usually they're going to continue to be monitored by a mental health professional (like an MHMR caseworker), but there is a real chance that they will return to the community. It's a very tough issue, and I'm not saying there are easy answers.