Well, I finally got around to seeing the Watchmen movie. And it was... pretty good but not great.
It's kind of a weird movie to critique, just because I really liked the book (although as I've said previously, I liked the book, but didn't really enjoy it in the same kind of way that I've enjoyed a lot of other superhero material), and so much of the movie is lifted directly from the panels of the comic book. There are a few key points which were changed between the book and the movie (including part of the ending), but I was okay pretty okay with the deviations (they actually made sense, mostly, and didn't stray too far from the plot of the comic).
The main issues that I had with me movie were with some of the acting, with a little bit of the directing, and with the music.
The music might seem like a minor thing that's sort of nitpicky, but musical choices really do affect the overall tone and mood of a movie. Once again, you have to remember that in a very real sense, the director of this movie had an awful lot of his choices made for him by virtue of the fact that he chose to stick so closely to the source material, so little things like the music were, to some extent, some of the few real choices that he was left to make (selecting actors was another one, but I thought that there were some problems there, too).
Anyway, the music choices kind of gave the movie a strange feel, and to some extent, I thought they detracted from some of the weight and impact of the movie. Some of the songs were more easily recognizable than others, but the well known songs seemed like they were almost too obvious for the scenes that they appeared in (you're going to use Flight of the Valkyries for the Vietnam sequences Zack Snyder? Really?), and other times I just thought that the music made the film seem lighter and campier than it probably should have (and some of the music choices in the trailers came off better than some of the music choices made in the actual film). A criticism of an arguably minor point, perhaps, but like I said, music really does impact the whole mood of the movie, and when you're shooting an almost frame by frame remake of a comic, things like music are some of the director's bigger decisions.
I also had an issue with some of the acting. The acting wasn't universally poor, but I thought Malin Akerman's Silk Spectre and Patrick Wilson's Nite Owl were both pretty weak (I thought Jeffrey Dean Morgan did a pretty good Comedian, though, and there were some other decent performances, but they almost made the weaker performances stand out more by comparison).
The direction was okay for the most part (and at some points very good), but there were a few moments that just fell sort of flat or seemed awkward.
Anyway, I don't want to spend too much time knocking the movie because it really was a decent flick, and it easily could have been a really bad film. It just didn't knock the ball out of the park, and although it might not be entirely fair, I will admit that I had a hope for something a little bit stronger in light of the fact that the source material is considered such a classic (although translating this thing to the screen was, admittedly, no easy task- oftentimes dialogue that seems very effective in comics just doesn't translate very well once you hear it coming out of an actor's mouth). And Watchmen is an interesting enough book that it's easy to get caught up in some of the ideas associated with the plot, even if the execution of the film isn't flawless (it doesn't take long to start asking yourself what kinds of effects costumed heroes would have upon the real world if they actually existed once you start watching the movie, or how well they would actually be received by the public and the government).
Anyway, there was never any way that this movie was ever really going to appeal to a wide audience if it was actually made in a way that was true to the book, and sure enough, this movie isn't for everyone (a few people walked out of the movie while I was watching it, and my brother reported to me that the same thing happened in the theater where he went to see it). The comic book was written by Alan Moore (one of the best respected writers in the comic industry) in the attempt to get comic fans to reexamine their preconceptions and stereotypes about costumed heroes and their place in the world (Moore is a genius at defying people's expectations and sort of stretching the limits of their imagination), so you're beginning at a starting point which many people find quite fantastic in the first place (the whole superhero thing) and then ratcheting up the strangeness factor several degrees on top of that (i.e., making the heroes and their entire world a darker place). Watchmen is a movie that deals with personal dysfunction and the messiness of real life, but in the context of a superhero format (which ends up making for a sort of twisted take on superheores for those who aren't expecting it), and it's a work with a very dark view of human nature. Sooo.... not for everyone.
If you're going to go see it and haven't read the book, you should probably approach it with the knowledge that it's striving to be a movie that comments on the way that we perceive heroes rather than a movie that's simply striving to be an adventurous superhero flick. If you go in with that knowledge, you might enjoy it more than if you go in thinking you're just going to get a variation on The X-Men or The Fantastic Four.
Zack Snyder may not have created a perfect movie here, but he stuck to the themes and the plot of the book closely enough to create something which merits debate and conversation. Even if it's not exactly what we were hoping for, it's still good that we got a version of Watchmen which was clearly made by someone who deeply respected and revered the source material.
Sticking with the comic book movie theme and quoting Jack Nicholson's Joker from Tim Burton's Batman:
"I don't know if it's art, but I like it."
No comments:
Post a Comment