Wednesday, March 25, 2009

Obama, the Media, and the Intelligence of American Viewers

I watched Obama's press conference and thought he did a really good job. Frankly, it's pretty amazing to have a president get up there and speak with charisma, eloquence, and an amazing command of the facts, figures, logic, and philosophy behind the policy decisions that he's making, especially after the last eight years (Bush mostly avoided press conferences altogether, and when he gave them, he had little to offer other than bad grammar and an extraordinarily superficial understanding of GOP talking points).
The media coverage of the president's performance after the press conference was pretty ridiculous. Fox News immediately jumped on the criticism that the president was boring and that he delved too much into policy and detailed explanations of his policies (really, Bill O'Reilly? You think the president's job is to be entertaining for the American people? Maybe he should tap dance next time as he talks to reporters. Come to think of it, entertainment isn't even really supposed to be a newsperson's job, leat alone the president's...) while Anderson Cooper's big insight over on CNN was that the president looked sort of tired (what a shock. The guy has been working round the clock for 60 days trying to solve what might be the biggest economic crisis in the nation's history, and you're surprised that he doesn't look well rested?). Also, the press tried to make some kind of hullabaloo about the fact that the president sounded a bit annoyed when answering one reporter's question, an inquiry about why the president didn't express more immediate outrage upon learning about AIG bonuses that were paid out of taxpayer bailout money. The president's terse response was that he thought it was a good idea to know what he was talking about before speaking on a matter publicly, and frankly, I think that's a pretty good policy (when the American people are already busy gathering up their torches and pitchforks, it's probably a good idea to have cooler heads prevailing in leadership. The president may have taken some time to try to get the facts in finding out if his administration was an integral part of the screw up in this deal, but I think that's perfectly understandable, too). I think the president was largely annoyed with the question for the same reason that I found it annoying- it wasn't really a question so much as a thinly veiled accusation, and it seemed geared toward self promotion by the reporter who asked it by way of fanning the flames of false, partisan controversy. After eight years of a Republican administration who often refused to even discuss extremely important policy matters, I don't really fault the president for investigating a matter for a day and a half before getting back to us.
Anyway, my main point is that the press are so nervous about appearing to be "in the tank" with Obama that they are bending over backward to find ways to criticize him. Granted, I understand that it's the job of the press to be the watchdog of government and to keep politicians honest (and their work transparent) as they go about their jobs, but I'm getting tired of the lack of objectivity. It seems like the modern American media does little more than overcompensate these days in their eagerness to show how "objective" they are. What happened to just trying to report the facts as they appear? Why do we constantly need a hundred pundits constantly interpretting reality for us, anyway? There was a quote once on one of my favorite shows, The Wire, in which a character comments on the media by saying, "A lie ain't a side of the story. It's just a lie." Today's journalists would do well to keep that quote in mind as they go about their work. The job of journalists isn't to try to provide some sort of political or moral balance to the world by trying to convey opposing viewpoints as fact. The job of reporters is to seek out the truth and to report it as objectively as possible. The moral and political fallout of that erporting should be left to people other than journalists, but when reporters feel the need to try to provide "balance" in their reporting, there is a temptation to spin facts in a way that may not be accurate in order to present a story as "fair". Fiarness is not the job of reporters. Presenting reality is the job of reporters.
Also, the reporters last night went on and on about how complicated the president's dialogue was and about how most Americans weren't going to have understood large parts of it. Well, I understood every word, and I'm pretty sure that most all of my friends and family would have understood it as well. I'm just really tired of the media assuming that Americans are idiots, and I've got to say that if we're all as dumb as TV journalists seem to think we are, then this country is screwed, anyway, because we're not going to be able to compete against industrialized nations that have an educated, intelligent population (and workforce) which can understand issues requiring an insight slightly higher than that possessed by your typical 2nd or 3rd grader (and this issue isn't just limited to news media- we had an entire discussion the other night at Jamie's birthday party about the fact that the BBC and other European television stations give their audience much more credit for their intelligence when writing dramas, comedies, and other programs. They seem to endeavor under the foolhardy notion that people can actually follow complex plots from time to time or tolerate nuanced character development and storytelling.)
Anyway, I think that part of the reason the news media seems to underestimate the intelligence of their audience is that such a depiction helps them to validate their own existence. It's a lot easier to justify the need for constant analysis and opinion projection when you've convinced yourself that your audience isn't capable of understanding these things or forming an opinion about it on their own. When you see your audience as a bunch of numbskulls, you can try to paint all of that criticism, analysis, and editorializing as a form of "education". When you see your audience as knowledgeable equals who really only need you to provide them with objective facts, you start to look a lot more like a blowhard.
And I'm not saying there's no place for analysis, editorializing, and discussion. These things help to spur very important, hopefully constructive debate. The issue that I have is with the confluence of news reporting and editorializing, with the ever eroding difference between an attempt at objective reporting and editorialization in news media. Opinions seem to be reported as fact with ever increasing regularity, and little distinction is drawn between objective reporting of historical events that are occurring in the world as compared to opinion and spin on those facts (e.g., Bill O'Reilly reporting on his "No Spin Zone" program immediately after the press conference that the president just gave a "boring press conference" which "people won't be able to understand". Someone remind me how in the hell anything O'Reilly has ever done constitutes a "no spin zone"? It's really not even good analysis, but that's a whole different discussion).
Oh well, I gotta go, and I'm almost ranted out, anyway. Hope you guys have a good one.
Make sure to scan down one post and read up about Jamie's birthday! Once again, happy birthday, Jamie!!!

No comments: