Ahhhhhhhh.... Friday. Just let it wash over you, Adventurers.
Hope everyone is doing okay. Watchmen comes out this weekend. [spoilers sort of in here a bit for people who haven't read the graphic novel, but if you haven't read it, you should do so. It's the only comic book to make it onto Time Magazine's 100 top novels of the 20th century, and it's an interesting read even if you normally aren't into such things] I've read the graphic novel a couple of times and thought it was good, although I never really pegged it as the crowning achievement of the entire comic book industry in the way that so many movie reviewers and commentators are now doing. I always liked Watchmen, but I always saw it as something of a curiosity and an experiment that occurred outside the realm of normal comics (which means that I might classify it as a great book, but it just feels like comparing it to more traditional comics is a bit like comparing apples and oranges). The heroes in Watchmen aren't our usual superheroes (i.e., they're not the Batman or Superman of D.C. comics, nor the Spiderman or X-Men of Marvel. There are historical reasons why the "regular" superheroes weren't used- licensing and editorial decisions about how well-known characters were to be used), and the book itself always seemed more like a sort of commentary on the entire concept of superheroes than a "true" superhero story itself. In saying this, I mean I always felt that Watchmen was more concerned with pulling superheroes down- showing us why people in the real world just can't live up to the idealized fantasy characters presented in traditional comic books- as opposed to the more traditional comic book tales where our superheroes are built up and meant to represent some of the best and most admirable character traits found in our society (which doesn't necessarily mean that the heroes are without flaws, but the focus is typically on the positive traits that elevate the characters to the level of being "heroes", whether such depictions are "realistic" or not). Traditional comics have usually been about how heroes overcome their circumstances and their personal flaws in order to become heroes. Watchmen posits the theory that only a flawed person would make the decision to don a costume and violently fight crime in the first place. In Watchmen, people are "heroes" because of their flaws, and the fact that they engage in such work is almost as much a symptom of some pathology as it is an altruistic calling.
(Also, for my money, you still can't beat The Dark Knight Returns when it comes to handing out awards for the best comic of all time- which is a subject ripe for debate, but I stand by Frank Miller's reimagining of the Batman character as well as the world that he finds himself in).
Anyway, my point is that I just didn't see Watchmen as a real "superhero story" so much as a literary experiment designed to show kind of show a twisted, darkened version of the superhero concept as expressed by people who wanted to launch a bit of an attack on the traditional notion of a superhero.
All of this, of course, to say that the director of the Watchmen movie was fighting one heck of an uphill battle when he was handed the task of moving this book to the big screen. To me, the very act of appreciating Watchmen is somewhat dependent upon the knowledge of the audience. It may not be strictly necessary to have read a ton of comic books in your time in order to appreciate Watchmen, but it certainly helps. It's just that you can't really shatter comic book stereotypes in the minds of the viewer if the viewer doesn't necessarily understand what those stereotypes are in the first place (although the recent trend in putting so many comic book superheroes on screen may have helped to alleviate this problem somewhat).
I've read a bunch of reviews of this movie, and they're kind of mixed, but it sounds like, for the most part, we're going to get a Watchmen movie which isn't as bad as we had feared (and it could easily have been a total disaster), but not as good as we might have hoped. Anyway, the fact that the movie is receiving sort of mixed reviews now has me more curious than before (if it had been widely panned I might have just skipped it- and frankly I just can't imagine a world in which a Watchmen movie would have been universally met with acclaim. The whole thing is just too far out there for everyone to love it).
Anyway, I'm glad the movie is finally coming out, if to put an end to the endless anticipation and speculation, if nothing else. Even if Watchmen ends up sucking, we still have a new Star Trek movie and a new Terminator movie to look forward to (and that Terminator movie is looking pretty cool).
No comments:
Post a Comment