Wednesday, March 11, 2009

Kind of dark and gloomy in Austin today, but hey- we got rain!! We got rain!!!

For those of you who don't live in Austin, it might be a little difficult to understand why rainfall might be a cause for celebration, but Central Texas is currently experiencing a drought which ranks right up there as one of the worst in the last 40 or 50 years. So despite the traffic snarl ups and the gray skies this morning, I'm happy for the rain. Hopefully the trees and plants in my yard are soaking it all in.

There's an editorial column in Newsweek this week written by David Frum, a conservative who's a former Bush speech writer and Wall Street Journal columnist, who argues that Rush Limbaugh is causing serious damage to the Republican party. Frum is a true conservative, and I disagree with him on many of his policy positions, but it's refreshing to just hear someone put forward conservative arguments with a sense of civility and respect- presenting honest viewpoints without feeling the need to be antagonistic, self-righteous, or derogatory. To be honest, I thought that Louisiana's Republican Governor, Bobby Jindall did a pretty good job of expressing similar sentiments in response to the president's first address to Congress a few weeks ago, although the press blasted him for his uncharismatic speaking style (which, I have to admit, was pretty bad and made to look even worse when the man had the misfortune to have to follow up a strong Obama speech) and for a few of his weaker policy arguments (Hurricane Katrina made your state stronger because you had to learn to perservere and rebuild? You guys are doing that with federal dollars- the exact sort of thing your party keeps railing against!). Anyway, I thought Frum made some good arguments. And I hate Rush Limbaugh. No- not just because I disagree with him politically (there are some conservatives that I have respect for and even like- John McCain is still one of them), but because he's just a self important, an insufferable ass who pretends to know everything and who's greatest joy in life seems to come from sarcastically mocking other people (I also happen to think that he's a racist and a horrible misogynist, but we'll save that for some other time). Frum is smart to recognize that the GOP is going to have a hard time attracting new adherents so long as Limbaugh is seen as one of its leading figures.



And some nutjob in Alabama went on a shooting rampage yesterday and killed 11 people before killing himself. I know that most gun owners are fine, law abiding people, but once again I feel compelled to point out that it would be a whole lot harder for someone to go on a killing rampage if they weren't armed to the teeth with firearms (and yes, I understand the whole guns for self defense argument, but how often are people really going to be armed to defend themselves against family members or other people that they know? A very significant portion of the victims of murders and other violent crimes actually have some sort of personal relationship with their attackers, whether they're family, friends, lovers, or whatever). Anyhoo, the gun debate is never ending, but whenever we have one of these mass shootings, I kind of think about it again.

Also in the news today comes a report by anonymous officials that one of the Taliban's new top operations officers in Southern Afganistan is a former inmate who was housed at Guantanamo Bay. Conservatives, of course, are jumping all over this turn of events, pointing to the reappearance of the former prisoner as proof that the inmates of Gitmo are too dangerous to ever be released. Closer examination of the details involved in the case, however, reveals that the former inmate, Abdullah Ghulam Rasoul, formerly Guantanamo prisoner No. 008, was actually released from custody under the watch and supervision of the Bush administration, meaning intelligence services and the military must have in some way greenlighted his release (they must have decided that he wasn't that dangerous or that he wasn't a key player- after all, Gitmo still has over 250 prisoners housed behind its fences, so clearly they've hung onto some of the people who they considered truly dangerous).
So once again we essentially have an intelligence screw up (under the Bush administration), but that mistake is supposed to justify a policy which houses people indefinitely without trial on a simple suspicion that they were once dangerous or that they might be again.
Look- no one is advoctaing the release of truly violent, vicious men who pose a threat to our country or our military, but at the same time, I think many people in our country just see the situation in Guantanamo Bay as morally wrong (i.e., holding people without trials and denying them basic rights under the Geneva Convention). No one is advocating the release of dangerous terrorists. Instead, we just want to move these men into normal, maximum security prisons and try them for their crimes in a court of law. If people have to be released and end up resurfacing again doing bad things, then that's because we didn't gather the evidence to hold trials and convict them. The alternative is that we hold people indefinitely without evidence in a prison in a foreign country where we don't have to follow our own laws- a solution which could end up holding innocent people in captivity indefinitely and which makes us look like lawless hypocrites to much of the rest of the world. I find that "solution" unacceptable. (I don't think we should be sacrificing innocent people in order to feel more secure)
Anyway, what's actually disturbing about this guy showing up in a Taliban leadership position is that it indicates another intelligence failure on our part. If we had known that this guy had any real skills or political clout, undoubtedly he would be one of the 250 prisoners still sitting locked in Guantanamo.

Well, that's about all that I have at the moment. Hope you guys are having a good day!

** Update/Addendum- apparently there was a mass shooting/massacre of 16 people in Germany yesterday by a teenager who went on a rampage. Germany is supposed to have much stricter, tighter regulations for their gun control, but the shooter in this case was apparently still able to get ahold of a gun- possibly one that was registered to his father. Maybe I'm just wrong about gun control laws helping to prevent these sorts of massacres. I don't know.

No comments: