My friend Chris has recently been giving me the hard press about going to see Jane's Addiction on what is apparently going to be a new tour with Nine Inch Nails. My initial reaction was, "no way". Jane's Addiction was one of the favorite bands of my youth, from when I was about 17 or 18 until I was 20 or so. I listened to their first three albums a whole lot, and knew just about every note of every song. Their concerts at City Coliseum and at the first Lollapalooza are amongst my best memories from that period of time.
Sometime after that first Lollapalooza, though, Eric Avery, the bass player left the band (and he was one of the most central figures in the band- the bassline carries the melody in lots of Jane's Addiction songs while the guitar kind of explodes in pyrotechnic curly cues). There have been other variations of Jane's Addiction with a number of different lineups (some with some good musicians like Flea), but none of them ever seemed to have the energy, uniqueness, or cohesiveness of the original lineup.
So the answer was easy.
"Jane's Addiction has never been the same since Eric Avery left the band. I'm not interested."
So then Chris sent me this. Apparently Jane's Addiction played with their original lineup at a not-so-secret "secret show" at South by Southwest Thursday night, thereby pretty much confirming (or going a long way towards confirming) the strong rumor that Jane's Addiction is going to play with their original lineup on this Nine Inch Nails tour.
I find myself feeling weird about the whole thing. Conflicted. I definitely loved the Jane's Addiction of my youth, and I realize that these are the same guys, playing the same songs, but somehow I'm having a hard time feeling excited about it. In fact, somehow I feel a little bummed.
I think part of it is the fact that Jane's Addiction is a band that I still strongly connect with a certain time and place in my life. There was a long time in my youth when I would have been overjoyed to see Eric Avery rejoin Jane's Addiction and for these guys to put out some new albums. But Jane's Addiction is a band that I relate to a period of my life when I was stumbling in and out of mosh pits, covered with other people's sweat and the smell of patchouli oil. Jane's Addiction was a band that, to me, sort of symbolized a particular youth subculture at a particular time period. At the time, Jane's Addiction felt like they were pouring gasoline on the mainstream culture and lighting a match. By point of comparison, I tend to wonder if this is what fans of bands like The Who, a band who definitely identified themselves with a certain youth counterculture of their day (i.e., after all, The Who were the ones who told sang about hoping to die before they got old when they sang "My Generation"), felt as their beloved band got older and older, eventually having to replace Keith Moon, but still continuing to play. As with Jane's Addiction, it's not really the band's fault- they continue to put on high quality shows and strong performances (although I do have some questions about why they're doing this now. Did the California mortgage crisis leave some of the guys in a pinch? And Perry Farrell has been notoriously willing to commercially exploit aritstic ideas for a long time). Mostly it's just that the music feels out of place, or more specifically, in the wrong time.
And it's not necessarily a bad thing that these guys are still playing. It's not them- it's me. I'm happy that younger fans are getting a chance to hear their music live. But right now, maybe because Jane's Addiction hasn't recorded a new album with the original lineup (they're just playing all of their old, classic material- which does contain a bunch of songs that I love), it feels like they're more about putting on a travelling museum showcase of a period of musical time that once was rather than working as a living, breathing band that's still active, dynamic, and relevant. It just makes me sort of feel old. I'm not going to go charging back into any mosh pits, but it's going to feel weird to go to a Jane's Addiction show and stand in the back of the crowd with the old farts.
I mean, I have to admit that I don't drive around with "Three Days" or "Mountain Song" blasting out of my speakers as I roll to work most mornings these days (okay- every once ina blue moon, but mostly only when I really need something rollicking that can wake me up). I haven't moved into the Lawrence Welk period of my life, but my tastes have changed. And I think that's a good thing. I'm not as angry or angsty as I was at 18 or 19 (or at least I show it and channel it in different ways), and so it makes sense that the same music doesn't provide the soundtrack for my life that it did in those days. I still love rock and roll, and I still love hearing new, different sounds that surprise me and catch me off guard, but the visceral howl of Jane's Addiction is something that I related to the most strongly when I was younger, less sure of who I was, and (and this one's mildly depressing- or maybe just amusing) a lot more cocky in my confidence that both myself and my generation were going to turn the world on it's ear (incidentally, I still believe in the power of my generation to change the world- it just seems a lot more difficult when you get older and start to realize how much heavy lifting is involved).
Anyway, I may go see the reunited Jane's Addiction yet, but maybe I just needed to talk this thing out with some blog therapy (so if you've made it reading this far, kudos, because clearly this was mostly about me just thinking this out). I don't want to be an old fuddy duddy, but I don't think my feelings on this are entirely invalid, either (hopefully). On the other hand, I still dig the music (even if it doesn't make it into the iPod rotation as often as it used to), and I have that nagging feeling of being afraid of missing something potentially cool.
I don't want to go see Nine Inch Nails very much, though. I like Trent Reznor's albums and think, in particular, he comes up with some interesting rhythms for his melodies, but in my opinion they've never been that great in concert (unless you have a thing for hanging out with goth kids and seeing disturbing film video shown on a big screen for two hours while watching guys play along with sequencers and click tracks).
Aarrgh! Oh well. We'll see.
No comments:
Post a Comment