Wednesday, December 02, 2009

Obama on Afghanistan

Hello. Hope everyone is having a decent day.
Last night Jamie made some really good tortilla soup for us for dinner. It was really good, and just the right thing to eat on a cold, rainy night. Thanks, McSteans!
So the big news last night was, as expected, Obama's announcement that he's sending 30,000 more troops to Afghanistan, with an exit strategy goal of withdrawal in three years (beginning the withdrawal 18 months after the deployment). Also, as expected, no one is entirely happy with this plan. Many Democrats think the war just needs to be drawn to a close immediately (believing that we're never really going to stabilize Afghanistan to any meaningful extent, anyway) and many Republicans are unhappy with the fact that the president is already setting a timetable for withdrawal (the theory being that this sort of schedule setting only emboldens the enemy by giving them a certain time that they have to "hang in there for" before American troops will begin to make their exit). As I said yesterday, it was easy to know before Obama ever made his speech that he was going to have an impossible time making everyone happy.
Having listened to his thinking and his arguments, I definitely understand the president's thinking and respect his choice about a course of action. It sounds like sort of a risky strategy, and my guess is that we're going to end up being in Afghanistan longer than 3 years, but at least I respect the man's reasoning and I understand why he felt compelled to make the choices that he did.
I guess the biggest question in evaluating whether or not President Obama made the right decision is probably the issue of whether or not there really is a legitimate likelihood that Islamic extremists (i.e., Al Qaeda and the Taliban) would/could reestablish a base of operations (presumably to be used to attack the U.S. and other Western powers) in Afghanistan if we simply packed up and left.
That's a tough question to answer if you haven't actually been to the country, witnessed the activities of the militants and the civilian population, and talked to the locals.
My guess, though, based upon history and upon the current fighting in both Afghanistan and Pakistan, is that the extremist Muslim hardliners in the region continue to pose a real, legitimate threat to not only our own national security, but also to the nations of Western European and to other allies of the U.S..
I've read the argument that Al Qaeda and the militant Islamic movement are now so decentralized and globally scattered that it makes little sense to focus on securing one country or region as a means of denying them a base of operations (the theory here is that Al Qaeda and other groups have now made a strategic decision to train and mount operations by way of smaller groups of people that are more widely dispersed, thereby denying foreign fighters the opportunity to attack them en masse at any single "base of operations"). I believe that Al Qaeda really might be employing this kind of strategy, but I also think that given a safe, secure place from which they could gather together and mount attacks, Al Qaeda and/or other groups would probably take advantage of such a resource, reestablishing training grounds, munition depots, and generally using the area as a safe haven to house nasty people who travel the world doing nasty things to America and its allies. Plus, they'll probably grow lots of opium poppies to help finance their efforts.
Anyway, if I were the president I wouldn't be too happy about needing to stay engaged in this war, and I would keep my door wide open to any and all suggestions regarding ways to disengage America from this conflict while simultaneously continuing to deny Afganistan as a safe haven for terrorists and extremists. I would guess that Obama took so long in making his decision because he was trying to make sure he wasn't overlooking some other viable option.
So good luck to the troops. Who knows? Maybe this new offensive will see quicker, better success than any of us expect. The Surge in Iraq certainly ended up working better than I expected (although, in the end, the long term stability of Iraq is still pretty questionable, and we're still propping the country up with our troops).
This whole thing is a bit of a nightmare scenario for a commander-in-chief. People keep making the comparison to Vietnam, but in at least one crucial way this thing is actually worse than Vietnam. At least when we were in Vietnam we didn't have the same kind of immediate threat and concern that the Vietcong were going to launch attacks against the U.S. or our allies if we withdrew from the war.
Sooooo... good luck to the troops as they dig in to be in Afghanistan a while longer. Let's hope our generals have some good ideas in terms of how to use the additional troops that we're sending.

No comments: