Wednesday, December 23, 2009

Christmas Tomfoolery; What it Takes to Get Work Done in the Senate; Health Care Unconstitutional?







I saw this on TV this morning, and it kinda made me laugh. This guy's friends (who are in an improv comedy troupe) decided to present him with the gift of all the stuff he already owned when he returned from a trip. Check it out.

Not too much to report. Last night I worked on cleaning up and editing some songs that we played at band practice last week. They sound a little rough. They're sort of just afterthought recordings of a practice (we're still working on the parts of these songs and figuring out what the final versions might sound like- not focusing on making perfect recordings), but it's fun stuff, and I enjoy messing around with it.

I heard on CNN this morning that the health care bill was looking like it might not reach a vote until relatively late in the night on Christmas Eve (around 10:00 p.m., probably), so, instead, Senators have reached a bipartisan agreement to vote on the bill earlier in the day (around 8:00 a.m.) in order to avoid travel delays and insure the fact that they can be home with their families on the holiday. It struck me as sort of ironic/crazy/bizarre thing that the Senate, which has been pretty much unwilling to reach a bipartisan agreement on anything, and the GOP senators, who have been making hyperbolic statements about fighting the health care reform bill tooth and nail to the death (some of them saying they would hold out until Valentine's Day in order to kill it), can all set aside their differences and reach an agreement on scheduling this thing for a timely vote when failure to do so might cause them a personal inconvenience on their holiday. How ridiculous is that? The fact that 40 million Americans are uninsured didn't force a any sort of bipartisan agreement on any given issue, the fact that thousands of Americans die prematurely and/or unnecessarily every year for want of proper health care coverage wasn't enough to force some compromise, thousands of Americans being forced into bankruptcy because of health care costs didn't prompt agreement on anything, or the ongoing denial of insurance coverage for thousands more because of pre-existing conditions. None of these things resulted in any sort of visible compromise or agreement between Democrats and Republicans on the health care reform bill on any issue, but when Senators were faced with the possibility of a Christmas eve in which they might not be able to share milk and cookies with their families, suddenly they were finally able to break the log jam and agree on something. I think that maybe we need to start threatening to take away holidays from U.S. Senators every single time they can't reach an agreement on a major issue, and then maybe we'll actually see some things getting done in the Senate.
Arrggggh.

In a different but related note, GOP Senators are now saying that they will contest the new health care bill on constitutional grounds. The exact bone that they have to pick with the new bill is with its provision which mandates insurance coverage for all citizens (essentially making it illegal for people not to have insurance). Their argument, in essence, is that the constitution doesn't sepcifically provide for such a mandate, and that the constitution forbids the government from seizing private property for public use without just compensation.
I don't think this argument is going to fly, but it's an interesting one. On a practical level, states have long required people to have insurance before driving a car (although people can be self insured if they can show that they have enough cash in the bank), and this has never been struck down as unconstitutional. Another counterargument might be that this isn't really a seizure of private property for public use, and certainly not a seizure without just compensation. The money that people will need to pay for insurance actually benefits the person making the payment (to a degree theoretically equivalent to or exceeding the money spent), so I'm not sure this is a true seizure. The government isn't simply taking something from people in order to give something to the public in the same way that they do when they use emminent domain to seize property to build a road. In those cases, private property is being seized and essentially just taken by the government for its own use. Here, the government is insisting that a person enter into a transaction where the individual making the purchase is the one most directly receiving the benefit (not the government or the public). And, even if this were a seizure, there's always the argument that just compensation has been made by way of the health care coverage provided. If the Supreme Court ends up buying into this argument, I think it will be a pretty clear indication that they're just playing politics (which would be extremely disappointing, but maybe not altogether surprising).
Anyway, that's all for now.
Hope everyone is feeling a bit of Christmas cheer!

No comments: