Sunday, December 06, 2009

Funding for the Mental Health Services in Texas (and the impact in the justice system)

Man, I normally don't post nearly this much on the weekends, but things just keep popping up that I can't help but comment on. There was a big ol' article in the Austin American Statesman today about the tremendous demand for additional/expanded mental health related services in Texas and about the lack of funding and support that mental health care services currently receive. I just wanted to take a moment to encourage people (especially Texans) to read this article if they have the time.
In my current position as a mental health prosecutor, this lack of funding and resources for mental health services is a constant, ongoing source of frustration and grave concern. Lack fo available beds means it has become frequent when we have a person in jail who is seriously ill and needs hospitalization for that person to be put on waiting lists that are often four months to five months long. This means that mentally ill people, many of whom are in jail on relatively minor offenses (like criminal trespass, misdemeanor theft, etc.), often end up sitting in jail for long periods of time while just waiting to be treated and stabilized (defendants in criminal cases are required by law to reach a certain minimal level of competency before their case can be addressed by the criminal court system- so mentally ill people often stand to do much more time waiting for treatment than a typical person would spend in custody on a given sort of crime). The hospitals which treat the mentally ill are simply too crowded and don't have room to take more people. Another big problem is that in situations where mentally ill people are in crisis (i.e., are displaying fully psychotic behavior that makes them a threat to themselves or the people around them) police officers are trained to take these people straight to the mental hospitals for an emergency commitment. When the mental hospitals are too crowded, though, (which seems to be a chronic problem) the mental health hospitals will refuse to accept new patients, and the police officers are supposed to take these individuals to regular hospital emergency rooms instead. Most regular hospitals are poorly equipped to handle these sorts of patients (they're not really all that well equipped for medium to long term stabilization and they're not really well situated for dealing with a person who is currently in crisis so severe that they're being brought in by a police officer), and oftentimes it takes a long time to get these people admitted to the hospital and processed in. Police officers aren't crazy about dealing with these situations for hours and hours, and the regular hospitals don't seem to be crazy about dealing with these situations, either. As a result, I think that we run into situations where officers know that they're going to have to deal with being turned away from hospitals and rerouted to other hospitals, and they go ahead and just make an arrest for whatever disturbance they were called out on in the first place. The officers know that the disturbed person will receive at least a basic level of medication and treatment in the jail, and the processing time is much faster, thereby allowing officers to get back onto the streets more quickly. I don't really blame the officers for taking the path of least resistance in this situation (and it's often a fine line for officers when deciding to take a person to the hospital or jail in the first place), but the end result is that, once again, the end result is that we get mentally ill people in the jail who really belong in a mental health treatment facility. The fact that the mental hospitals are overcrowded shouldn't be the deciding fact between whether a person gets treatment or goes to jail. Our Travis County jail does a really good job at providing services for a jail, but it's still a jail, and it's not the proper environment for treatment (nor can it offer all the same meds and services that a hospital might offer).
Anyway, on our mental health docket, we try to find workarounds and alternative solutions (we now have an outpatient competency restoration program and a few other tools), but many of these things are just sort of stopgap measures. We need more funding for hospitals (to treat people who have destabilized) and for the basic services that can keep people healthy in the first place (before they get into crisis). The mental health docket was supposed to be designed just to decide punishment terms for mentally ill defendants and whether or not people were criminally culpable for their actions in the first place. The task of trying to with and work around an underfunded mental health system with inadequate resources has become an ancillary task that we're dealing with simply because it's an unfortunate part of the reality of the caseload.
So, I encourage people to take a glance at the article if you have time. The mental health system is woefully underfunded in Texas, with many people simply ignoring the problem because it isn't a day to day part of their lives. For the people who deal with mental illness personally, in their families, or in their community, however, mental illness is an extremely pressing problem that can be made all the more devastating if left unaddressed. As a prosecutor, I think it would be great if we could get more bed space in our mental health hospitals, but equally important are the community clinic services that the article refers to. If we could get more people off the waiting lists and into a situation where they were actually being treated, we might see a lot less need for hospitalization and, hopefully, a lot less crisis situation where the police ever get involved.
I don't mean to sound like a public service announcement, but this stuff is very, very real, and ignoring the issue will only make the problem worse.
The good news is that proper medication and treatment can work absolute wonders in a lot of cases. We can do a whole lot to improve our communities and to improve the lives of people with mental illness if we direct our efforts appropriately. Texas ranks 50th in the nation in terms of funding services for the mentally ill, and that just isn't acceptable.
Okay. End of sermon.
Just saw the article and had to get this off my chest.

No comments: