Wednesday, April 16, 2008

Hi! Not too much to report. Doug and Jamie made little pizzas last night, sans pizza sauce, but with cheese and some interesting other things on it, including corn. Dinner was good.

Here's a piece of news that's not exactly cheerful, but sort of interesting for people who are involved in the criminal justice community. The U.S. Supreme Court is supposed to hear arguments today about the constitutionality of implementing the death penalty in child rape cases, even when there hasn't been a murder involved. The court ruled in 1977 that the death penalty was a cruel and unusual punishment for rape cases involving adult victioms, but it left open the question of cases involving children. Lousiana is attempting to execute Patrick Kennedy, a 43 year old man who was convicted of raping his eight year old stepdaughter in 1998.
On the whole, I'm not a big fan of the death penalty, kids. I really just don't trust the infallibility of the court system enough to give it the right to put a person to death. Aside from the fact that I think that there's too much room for error (my main argument against capital punishment), I also just don't think that our government needs to be in the business of putting its citizens to death. There's no doubt that there are murderers and rapists and bad men in the world who do awful things, but I just don't feel that doing awful things to people in return (i.e., keeping people on death row and then killing them) is something that heals victims, helps society, or serves as a deterrent. And it's hard to say that executing prisoners is necessary to the administration of justice when we have life in prison with no possibility of parole as an option.
Anyway, I'm not a big death penalty fan, but the case of child rape presents other, unique questions that don't necessarily exist in your standard murder death penalty case. One issue is whether the use of the death penalty in these cases might have a chilling effect on the number of child rapes which are actually reported. Many child rapes are committed by family members, family friends, or other people that child rape victims have known personally, which is part of what it makes it so hard for these victims to come forward to report their abuse. If victims know that their accusations might result in the offender being put to death, they may be even less likely to report the rape than they were if the offender were only facing prison time. Another thing that bothers me about applying the death penalty in child rape cases is the fact that these cases are often tough cases based on evidence provided by malleable children (I'm not saying that these kids intend to be dishonest, but they have a tendency to want to give the responses that they believe their interrogator is looking for, whether that person be a family member, teacher, police officer, etc.). In addition to the fact that there were a number of well-documented cases of erroneous child abuse allegations at daycare centers through the 1980's and up into the 1990's, I've personally worked on a case where the accusation of a child got the case all of the way into a felony trial (where our defendant was facing some serious prison time), and then suddenly the child changed their testimony on the stand and accused a party other than the defendant of the abuse (this was a case I worked on with my frist boss, Pat Ganne). We didn't even finish the trial. The case was thrown out.

Obviously child rapes really do occur, and I understand that child rape cases produce not only horrible phsyical trauma, but emotional and psychological damage which can cause substantial difficulty for a victim throughout their entire lives (meaning I'm awfully tempted, myself, to just want to say that we should go ahead and allow the execution of child rapists) . The problem is that you might end up executing an innocent person. Child rape cases are extremely difficult, given the age of the victims and their suggestibility (a series of leading questions produces the answer that the questioner is looking for much more easily in children than in most adults). Further, the execution of these people may add even more trauma or confusion to the psyche of a child rape victim, especially if the defendant was a family member or closely acquainted with the victim prior to the rape.
And all of this doesn't even get into examining the question of whether it's ever fair to put someone to death when that defendant didn't actually kill someone himself. (although the rape of a child might be one of the few areas where I can actually understand the desire to execute someone for a crime other than murder)

Anyway, not a very cheerful topic, but still a compelling one from a criminal justice perspective.

In other news, it's interesting to watch the news story unfold regarding the raid on the Fundamentalist Latter Days Saints polygamist compound out near San Angelo. Despite the fact that underage girls were found in the property who were pregnant and who had already had children of their own, the church members from the compound have been surprisingly savvy at "working" the media- addressing the cameramen and news organizations with claims that nothing illegal has occurred at the compound and by making appeals for public sympathy on the basis of religious persecution. I guess we'll see how the evidence shakes out, but the whole thing just seems pretty messed up. Cases dealing with groups that have such a cult-like mentality are often difficult to prove, as victims have often been indoctrinated, well-trained and (for lack of a better word) pretty much brain washed into accepting the rationalizations and justifications of the group members for their own illegal conduct. I'm not sure that's going to get the group out of trouble this time, though, given the fact that there's no consent defense to statutory rape (which seems to be the main allegation here). Anyway, it's going to be one big zoo of a court case.

Well, that's it. Hope ya'll have a good one.

2 comments:

The League said...

Honestly, I've been a little shocked at how the press has handled the story. I agree that it's not unrealistic to consider some suspicion of religious persecution in Texas, and I'm not sure this was handled properly by authorities. But I also think state and local officials have a responsibility to determine if the FLDS is meeting the basic standards of safety, education and security that would be expected for any other child in the state of Texas.

Having come from the home state of the FLDS not so long ago, one had only to watch the careful unravelling Arizona had to do to begin to make the slightest bit of headway. The compound was incorporated more or less into a city and school district, which meant that the FLDS had its own police force and educational standards (surprise... the school district used state and federal funds for non-educational purposes and little evidecen fo schooling existed as late as 2006 or so). The primary source of income for most families was state welfare, which Jeffs celebrated and called "bleeding the beast". The few women who escaped (and I do mean escaped) were nearly illiterate, almost completely uneducated and had no knowledge of basic facts, such as the name of the president.

Whether polygamy is actually a crime or not between consenting adults, evidence points toward institutionalized servitude for women to be kept as breeding stock as young as 14-16. And, with a culture in which no woman (or young man) has anywhere to turn, where police are part of the system, what sort of paranoid/ Clive Barker fantasy camp do you really need to appear?

It is messed up that these kids are being separated from their homes. But its also giving them something of a chance at life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. If they really want to go back to the FLDS at age 18... more power to them.

Its too bad the press is framing this as "Texas separates children from their mothers". It's also unsurprising that Texas will not handle this case well either legally or in the court of public opinion.

J.S. said...

Another thing that I find annoying is the fact that these polygamists consistently cry about how they're persecuted and mistreated by state and federal governments, but then many of them abuse the welfare system by having many of the wives of these men collect welfare for their many children (since there can only be one legally recognized marriage in each of these families, the law sees each of the additional wives in these families as single- then if these additional wives are not working, they get to collect welfare as single mothers with children, even though they simultaneously declare themselves to be married to a husband who, according to their religion, is supposed to be providing for the family and financially supporting his wives and offspring. They call such practices "bleeding the beast" and feel entitled to engage in such fraud as a sort of retribution against the government for the oppression that they perceive themselves to be living under. I call such practices welfare fraud.)