Tuesday, January 19, 2010

Political Irony from Massachusets; Sherlock Holmes

Hello! Hope everyone is having a decent day.
So, apparently the Massachusetts Senate seat that has been held by the Kennedy family since 1953 is looking like it may be lost to the Republicans in an election today. Brilliant. Ted Kennedy championed health care reform for several decades, and then he dies, and the Democrats not only look like they may lose the seat to a Republican, but they may very well lose their health care reform as well. The loss of Kennedy's seat to a Republican is likely to give the GOP 41 votes in the Senate- just enough to fillibuster and block any meaningful legislation that the Democrats might try to pass.
I tell you what, folks. I've been a Democrat for all of my adult life, but I'm, just about fed up with the ineffectiveness of the Democratic leadership and their inability to get anything done. This health care reform bill should have been passed months ago, but the Democrats have lacked the efficiency, foresight, fortitude, and willpower to pass meaningful legislation. The Democrats have had a full year where they've had a fillibuster proof majority in the Senate, a majority in the House, and a Democrat in the Oval Office, and it seems like we still can't get anything done. The White House and the Senate have squandered far too much time trying to make nice with the Republicans- a process which has met with virtually no success and which has achieved almost no bipartisan cooperation. The Democrats spent so much time trying to look enlightened (which in this case meant trying to garner bipartisan support for issues which the Republicans really had no interest in endorsing) that they lost sight of the fact that this is a battle. It's been a long time since the Senate was the gentleman's clubhouse that Senate Democrats apparently still imagine it to be.
These days we elect our political leaders to do battle on our behalf, and in that regard our national Democratic leaders have been really falling down on the job. Millions of Americans may very well end up suffering in very real and measurable ways if health care fails, and I'm going to largely attribute the defeat to the fact that Democrats have been dragging their heals throughout this process. It makes my head hurt.
And, of course, if the Democrats lose in Massachussets, this is likely to be only the beginning of the bloodbath. The 41 Republican seats in the Senate will allow the GOP to use its fillibuster power to hold off any meaningful Democratic bills for the next year, thereby allowing them to hold on until the mid term elections when the Republicans will gain even more seats (or at least the GOP will gain more seats if most current predictions hold up in any meaningful way). And then, once the GOP solidly breaks the majority in the Senate (or gains a majority), we're going to be in a total deadlock through the rest of Obama's first term in office. Nothing will get done. After the mid term elections, Obama may end up having little opportunity to affect legislation at all, other than possibly signing vetos of Republican legislation.
And this slide all begins with the people of Massachusets turning over Ted Kennedy's Senate seat to a Republican, just when the loss of that seat has the potential to cripple a health care reform effort that Kennedy fought for during most of his professional life.
Ironic doesn't begin to describe the situation.
I really find it pretty depressing. Hope that Americans enjoy their continuing lack of insurance coverage and their medical bankruptcies, because I see a whole lot more of that sort of thing coming their way (and, let's be honest- the American people have pretty much demanded this sort of treatment). Coverage is going to continue to increase in cost, fewer things will be covered, more people with pre-existing conditions won't be able to get coverage, there will be more out of pocket expenses, and increasing amounts of our national debt will go to cover health care costs.
Ugggh, I don't know. I'm sort of ranted out.

I don't have much else. I saw Sherlock Holmes over the weekend. I had read a couple of pretty scathing reviews beforehand, so I wasn't expecting much. I guess I ended up finding the movie somewhat entertaining, although it really just didn't feel like much of a Sherlock Holmes story. The movie had lots of action and adventure (probably more action than in most of Doyle's stories), but Holmes' legendary deductive abilities and detective work were shortened down into a series of hyperkinetic flash sequences and snarky comments. It felt like the director, Guy Ritchie, included just enough detective skill to remind a viewer that the action adventure hero before them was, indeed, meant to be the same literary figure who appeared in the Sir Arthur Conan Doyle works, but, on the whole, this just didn't feel like the same person that the Holmes stories describe.
On the other hand, there was some amusing dialogue and fun to be had. If Ritchie had named his characters Bill and Bob (as opposed to Holmes and Watson) and had just made the about two random detectives (as opposed to two of the most well known literary figures in mystery fiction), I think the movie would have felt a lot more satisfactory.
Oh well.
The movie wasn't the greatest Holmes work ever made, but it was sort of fun.

I also watched about 10 minutes of The Phantom Menace yesterday on cable. Having just seen Avatar, I think Lucas could have probably benefitted by waiting a few years before making his second set of Star Wars movies (and he probably should have gotten some help with the dialogue, too, but that's a whole different issue).

Anyway, that's it for now. Hope you guys are having a good one! (the weather has been nice the last couple of days, so try to enjoy it!)

8 comments:

The League said...

If you ever were frustrated why I don't tend to identify politically, after the 1993-1994 fiasco, and watching my predictions materialize over the past year as to a democratic led congress collapsing on itself... well, that's why.

I await the cold, binary decision making of our future robot masters.

J.S. said...

Well, you're far from alone in deciding that the least frustrating option is to just opt out. But the Democrats are the only really viable game in town for progressives. I just can't believe that the GOP has managed to demonize the Democrats when the Democrats were trying to do things like keep the economy from collapsing and keep Americans healthy and out of bankruptcy with better health care coverage.

The League said...

Man, if, after this cluster, I honestly believed any Dems truly were interested in anything but campaign contributions and playing it safe... well, more would be the shame on me.

The Dems proved themselves to NOT be progressives, to completely lack any vision or understanding of WHY a longshot like Obama won solidly, and missed the point when it came to delivering what people are hoping for. Like the 92 Congress, these clowns (led by shady bastards like Dodd) failed. Completely.

@#$% this %@#$. @#$% it straight in the ear.

J.S. said...

I think that the biggest problem for the Democrats is that they don't have a cohesive message that they're conveying to the American people. They're not controlling their own image (meaning, they're not managing to portray themselves as a party that protects the little guy, poromotes equality, and fights for working class Americans). Instead, they repeatedly allow themselves to be cast as a party of out of touch elitists who just want to fruitlessly spend tons of government money, raising taxes through the roof while failing to provide any measurable benefits for anyone. The Republicans have managed to somehow portray themselves as being the party of the people simply by claiming to not be what the Democrats are (while pretending to safeguard some kind of nostalgic, flawless 1950's lifestyle which never really existed in the first place). The Democrats need to completely rebrand themselves if they want any hope for success because I honestly don't really think that the ignorant ol' American public really understands what they're doing or why they're trying to do it (and if you're going to make major changes, you better have the understanding of the public as you go about making them). If the Democrats don't understand that they have major image problems, than maybe they're really as out of touch as the Republicans would have everyone believe. People supported Obama during the election, but I think that mostly that support was limited to that one moment in history. On the whole, I think the Democratic Party is really struggling badly in this country.

The League said...

I am no longer convinced that the Democrats are the party of the 1960's, the Great Society, NASA, progressives, what have you. The Health Care Debacle has thrown what appears to really be happening into sharp relief. These are career politicians. They vote by who pays for them, just like the people across teh aisle. They vote out of fear of not being re-elected, and happily sabotage the president they just watched carry their party into a majority so that they can continue taking money and not be criticized too sharply at home.

I don't think Obama was honestly in office long enough to become one of those guys. But he's already on the offensive.

http://abcnews.go.com/WN/Politics/president-obama-lost-touch-american-people-year/story?id=9613462

J.S. said...

Well, I'm not sure that the Dems are anything other than career politicians, either, but there have been some career politicians who have done some really good things (once again, I think the irony is that Ted Kennedy was one of these guys), and, frankly, I'm not sure that even in the 1960's that things were all that different in temrs of the sorts of pressures that these guys face and bow to. The guys from the 60's were just better at advocating for themselves and selling their viewpoints, so they weren't constantly on the defensive.
I still think that the real problem is that the Democrats just have a hard time presenting a solid, unified vision of what they're trying to do for the country. At some point they went from being a party that represented labor and working class Americans to being seen as a party of liberal elites who are out of touch. People are literally opposing Democratic plans that would help them just because the Reps do a better job of selling their overall image and message. Obama is our strongest leader in terms of presenting an appealing view of what a Democrat should be, but even he doesn't often present a coherent narrative regarding what the Democrats are hoping to accomplish.
We need someone who can present the Democrat's vision for a positive, compelling vision for the future, and we're failing miserably at that. The Republicans just keep repackaging some sort of throwback to a 1950's style Beaver Cleaver American lifestyle (with the promise that a tiny government and zero taxes will get us there), and people seem to be buying it- although that's not really what the past was like, and it's never really going to be what the future looks like, either.

The League said...

I was actually saying that the Dems are career politicians, but, yeah. I'd be more inclined to agree that they just need a strong voice, but I see no reason to continue to believe that the party is in agreement on any set of ideals. I'm not a true believer in any party, and am quite tired of voting for Dems just because they put up a front of being less offensive than the GOP.

Nothing about this year has indicated that the Dems are actually about and for the working class. I see Obama trying Jedi tricks with the banks, etc... But Pelosi, Dodd, etc... seem utterly puzzled as to how this whole "deliver on the promises" thing works.

Nah. If messaging is a part, its just one more symptom of a party that has no idea what its doing and shares no core plan or values, including those about trying to help the working man.

J.S. said...

Yeah, I meant that I, also, wasn't convinced that the Dems were anything other than career politicians- but once again, I'm not sure that's really any different than how it's ever been (or at least for the last 50 or 60 years). The Dems are definitely letting people down. It's just a sad comment when people have so little faith in their leadership that the GOP can convince people that they can do the best job by essentially promising that they won't do anything at all (except maybe wage some wars). there are still a few good Democrats out there (I think Bill White is one, but, unfortunatley he doesn't have much of a chance), but the people who don't align themselves with lobbyists and special interests don't seem to have much staying power (the conventional wisdom is that they need the support money to run competitive campaigns, although I had hoped that internet fundraising might have changed some of that).
Anyway, sadly, I don't really have the faith in our current leadership to argue with you too strongly. Usually the only thing that gives the Dems a boost is allowing the GOP to get back in power long enough to royally screw things up again. Too bad the country has to suffer in order for that to happen.
I'm getting tired of supporting a party that claims to have the best of intentions (although the Blue Dog Democrats have reminded me that some Democrats don't even have good intentions), and just can't get anything done.