Monday, January 11, 2010

Baby Bloom on the Way!; What the U.S. Can Learn from World War II London

Hey! Hope your week is off to a good start.
My weekend was uneventful. It was cold outside, and I've been suffering for either a cold or allergies, so I mostly hunkered down with some books and movies. Took Cassidy to the dog park for awhile yesterday, and we had band practice in the evening.

Team Bloom is scheduled to bring Baby Bloom into the world tomorrow, so everyone be thinking about them and sending good thoughts, prayers, karma, and whatever else you've got their way!! Looking forward to meeting that kid!

Well, among the things I did this weekend was get up and eat my breakfast on Sunday while watching the Sunday morning talk shows. As usual, there was a lot of opinion (some more based on reason than others) and hypercriticism and political posturing under the thinly veiled disguise of objective analysis. One topic that I saw discussed on a number of these shows (it may have been covered on State of the Union, This Week, and Meet the Press) was the White House reaction to the attempted Christmas bombing on that flight bound for Detroit. Republicans have, predictably, tried to seize upon the whole incident, complaining that the president failed to address the nation quickly enough after the near disaster (I think it was 3 days after the arrest was made that the president appeared on television to comment on the incident), and showing video footage of the president golfing on his Christmas vacation shortly after the emergency was averted. Republicans have compared the situation with the criticism that Bush received when he failed to take action for 6 days following Hurricane Katrina, and they're crying about a double standard.
Well, I think that's a little ridiculous. Bush took more than twice as long to respond as President Obama, and this Christmas bombing attempt wasn't a disaster- it was a near miss where no one actually was physically harmed. In Bush's case, over 1,800 people died while untold others were trapped on their rooftops and in their attics as flood waters filled their city. Meanwhile, Bush was out at his ranch playing cowboy for the umpteenth time, and Micheal D. Brown, a Bush political appointee who was largely unqualified for his job as head of FEMA, floundered hopelessly in the planning and execution of a rescue effort. So.... different situations.
Nevertheless, the whole conversation, as well as the sort of frantic media coverage following the failed Christmas bombing, sort of got me thinking. Then last night I was watching a documentary about the bombings of London and Berlin during World War II, and something sort of struck me.
There was certainly a large amount of strategic bombing that went on during World War II as both Allied and Axis forces tried to take out munitions depots and rail yards and other resources that the respective armies would need in order to win the war, but there were also a large number of raids upon civilian population centers which were meant to do little more than lower morale to the point where war would be unsustainable- the civilian population rising up in protest over the death and destruction which had been rained down upon their cities and demanding that their government end the war. Aside from the uncomfortable recognition that American bombing of civilian population centers sounds, itself, a lot like terrorism (striking at civilians so that, out of fear, they might alter the political decision making of their country- does that sound familiar?), I also kind of noticed something else. The leaders of Germany and England, knowing that the goal of the enemy was to terrorize civilians, took pains to explain to the civilian population that the enemy was trying to break their will and bring about their defeat through demoralization. The political leaders of the time didn't invite the criticism and panic of the public by indulging fear, holding press conferences meant only to assuage anxiety and reassure the populace. In point of fact, the danger was real and there was no way to go about denying its existence.
But these wartime leaders, instead, issued a challenge to their civilian populations. Knowing that the enemy was attacking the civilian population in order to destroy their will to fight, the leaders made the strategy of the enemy clear to their populations and implored them not to give in to the fear and horror inflicted by the bombing raids. In fact, the leaders at the time made it a civic, patriotic duty for citizens to go about their daily lives- to continue their business and daily activities, even as the cities continued to suffer periodic attacks. This was a fight for survival, with thousands and thousands of soldiers constantly dying on battlefields in order to protect their countries, and the role that the civilian population was asked to play in the war was to stiffen its resolve and refuse to be cowed by the bombing. The war could only go on, it was realized, if the civilian population continued to support the military, both in terms of politics and morale as well as logistically, in terms of weapons and supplies that were supplied through the efforts of civilians. The leaders made it clear- waging the war wasn't just the responsibility of soldiers who had been deployed to some distant, foreign front. Waging the war also meant refusing to give in to fear at home, even when people were placed under a real, constant threat from the enemy. And to at least some extent, the resolve of the people eventually worked in deterring the enemy (or, at least, both Allied and Axis commanders eventually realized that their bombing campaigns were having little or no effect on either morale or industrial production).
So I'm watching this old, grainy footage of Londoners digging themselves out from rubble and then going back to work following nighttime bombing raids, and it's occurring to me that our civilian population in the U.S. seems (at least at the moment) to have little or none of the commitment that these people possessed. We seem content to wage a war so long as our war is waged by our volunteer forces, and it's carried out far away and in foreign lands, but when the reality of our "war on terror" is brought home, we sort of freak out and panic and demand that our leaders make us 100% safe 100% of the time.
Well, that's just not really the reality of war. It's not the nature of any war, let alone a war against terrorism (when terrorism is, by its very definition, the use of violence against a population in order to instill fear within it and to weaken the will of the enemy nation).
So here's what I think. I think it's time Obama had a "come to Jesus" meeting with the entire country. He needs to have a nationally televised speech where he addresses the whole country and talks about what it means to be waging a war against terrorism. He needs to reassure and reemphasize to the country that our intelligence and security forces are doing the absolute best that they can, but that, in the end, there is and will continue to be, in fact, some amount of risk to our civilian population. Instead of making ineffectual, blanket promises for impenetrable national security, Obama needs to admit that the terrorists will continue to attack us, and that despite our most valiant attempts to thwart them, some terrorists may get through.
Obama needs to say all of this while empowering the American people with the ability to defeat the terrorists by asking them not to give in to fear. The truth is, our soldiers and intelligence agencies are doing a pretty good job at keeping the terrorists on the defensive, but the final target for these terrorists is always likely to be the civilian populations of the U.S. and its allies. We can mostly keep them out, but expecting an absolutely secure system that protects us 100% of the time is just not a realistic expectation if we want to be able to live our lives and move about freely in our society.
But the thing is, I think people might respond well to this sort of challenge. Instead of feeling like helpless little targets, people need to feel like they're fighting back. It might actually help to calm people's nerves if they felt like they were confronting the enemy by refusing to show fear. If people understand that they're serving their country and confronting the enemy by refusing to give in to panic, then I think that will make a big psychological difference.
But there are some important differences between today and the era of World War II. For one thing, we have an omnipresent, 24 hour news cycle nowadays which loves nothing more than to feed panic and hysteria in order to boost its ratings. Nothing boosts ratings more than putting people into a situation where they're scared because when people are frightened, they turn to the news in order to receive information about what's going on. The media feed off fear like vultures, an in so doing, they're the incidental enablers of terrorists. It's harder to remain calm when horrible images from civilian attacks get repeatedly broadcast into your home in high definition. Suddenly people are present not only for attacks which personally effect them, but instead, they feel much more closely to every attack which is meticulously covered by the media. Second, in the highly politicized climate that we've got now, it might be hard for a president to ask his constituents to understand the need to make some patriotic sacrifices. Obama, like Bush, is, at least in theory, a wartime president, but somehow this hasn't slowed down the quantity or the fury of the political attacks against him. Asking civilians to realize that they're at war and that they might need to do their part to support the effort is only going to work if there isn't a sizable opposition screaming that people shouldn't have to make any sacrifices at all. It would be sort of hypocritical, of course, for the Republicans, who have generally been the strongest suppporters of the war on terrorism, to then turn around and tell the civilian population that they shouldn't have to put up with any of the risks associated with such a war, but...who am I kidding? If the Republicans think they can get political mileage out of it, I'm sure they'll try to claim that the only reason that war is unsafe is because Obama is in the White House. Anyway, it may be hard to encourage your population to cowboy up if someone else is shouting to them that they won't have to put up with any of this nonsense if they'll just vote their guy into office. Finally, I'm not sure that the American people really support the war on terror enough to want to steel themselves. I think that our recent wars are just faraway occurrences for most Americans- that they don't think about these things too much because they don't really affect American civilians directly. Asking citizens not to lose their sh*t if a bomb goes off in a subway tunnel or a plane falls out of the sky might make them seriously reexamine how badly they want to wage this war.
Which might not be a bad thing, to some extent. On the other hand, fear isn't really a very good basis for solid decision making. And it's not clear what we would have to do in order to quit the war on terrorism, anyway. Pull all Americans out of the Middle East? Give up on our alliance with Israel? Submit to the supremacy of Sharia (i.e., Islamic holy law)?
Prior to 9/11, most Americans felt like we were pretty much leaving the Middle East alone, but we got attacked anyway. The extremist Muslims, apparently angered by of our defense of Israel, our Western involvement in Middle Eastern business and culture, and our political activities in the Middle East (e.g., our allegiance with Israel, our alliance with the Saudi royal family, and our involvement in the Iranian Revolution, for example), seemed determined to attack us, mostly with the intention of getting us out of the Middle East once and for all.
Anyway, my point in mentioning all of this is that even if Americans don't really feel like fighting the war on terror, I'm not really sure that we have a lot of choice. I don't think we're going to give up our alliance with Israel, and with such a huge part of the world's oil reserves located in the Middle East, I don't think we're about to abandon our business dealing there anytime soon, either. On top of all that, extremist Muslims have probably already stacked up a list of grievances against the United States that could keep them fueled with animosity all the way into the next century, so even if we pulled out of the Middle East tomorrow it would probably do little good other than to provide staging grounds for the next wave of extremist attacks.
So we're stuck with this war. I don't just mean the war in Afghanistan, but the overall war on terror.
And the American civilian population has to get used to the idea that, on some very real level, we're not just observers in this war, but participants. The end game of the terrorists is to effect U.S. policy by scaring the crap out of the American people, so the people have to do their part by not getting thrown into a panic whenever there's an attack or a near miss. The government has to do their part by keeping the citizenry as safe as humanly possible, but citizens have to do their part by refusing to be afraid.
So that's the message that Obama needs to find a way to convey to people. We're a nation at war. Hopefully these attacks don't come often, but if and when they do, we need to demonstrate to our enemies that they're ineffective, and the only way to do this is to strengthen our resolve. This needs to be a message that we don't just role out in the aftermath of calamitous events like 9/11, but it needs to become an attitude toward terrorism which becomes firmly ingrained in the American psyche as a general response to attacks. Terrorism inherently requires an emotional response from the population which paralyzes it and weakens its determination. If we want to discourage terrorism, we need to deny the enemy that emotional response. It won't be easy given oru 24 hour cable news channels and divisive politics, but it's a necessary step if we're going to continue this fight over the long haul.
Ooooookay. Nobody wanted to hear all of that on a Monday, but it was on my mind. More importantly, I couldn't think of anything else to write.
Have a good week! Don't be afraid!

2 comments:

The League said...

Preach it.

Honestly, I think if the critics were nearly as freaked out as they'd like for the audience/ voters to be, they WOULD be demonstrating a lot less in the arena of histrionics and a lot more in the way of buckling down for a fight.

Its not good that it almost happened (when all evidence points to a failure), but we're in an endless war with people whoa re not going to go out and buy tanks and an air force. Playing political "gotcha" at this point has made me go from cynical about how officials are handling this war to "I have lost all faith in how the system works".

J.S. said...

Yup!