Friday, January 22, 2010

Another Victory for the Machine

Hey!
Well, you would think that I would have calmed down a bit since yesterday's outburst. Or maybe not (those of you who read this blog at all during the Bush years should no me well enough to realize that I can keep the temper simmering for long, long periods of time).
I had just started to settle down after that whole Massachusetts Senate seat debacle when I started cluing in to yesterday's Supreme Court decision which essentially gave corporations the unfettered ability to spend money to oppose or support political candidates. The ruling struck down twenty years worth of precedent (so much for Alito and Roberts promising during their confirmation hearings to avoid judicial activism and adhere to precedent), and it apparently says that corporations have a protected First Amendment right to free speech- a right which the court has held to include the right to make political contributions in just about whatever way it sees fit.
Arrrgh.
Just what our country needed.
This ruling, brought to us by the court's conservative majority, is going to significantly expand the already profound ability of corporations and special interests to affect elections and sway the political process of the country. Corporations are still banned form giving money to candidates directly, but they'll be able to run political television ads which directly support candidates and otherwise engage in activities which directly spend money in support of their favorite candidates.

Here's the thing. I know that for many legal purposes a corporation is considered to be a person (or very much like a person), but I think that the limits of that legal fiction need to be met when we start getting into things like extending First Amendment freedom of speech protections to these same fictional entites (especially fictional entites which are pretty much solely concerned with making a profit). When we've gotten to that point- where profit driven organizations are essentially telling people what to think, who to support, and how to govern themselves- then the entire system has become absurd and been turned on its head.
Corporations are supposed to work for us. They're supposed to be tools for making money. They shouldn't have a place at the table when we have a conversation about how to live. If corporate interests need to be protected, there will be plenty of private citizens who will come to their defense (which I have no problem with- people can privately advocate for positions that support corporations all day long if they want to), but corporations themselves shouldn't get a say. I think that this ruling just reinforces the idea that corporations aren't in existence to benefit American society, but that American society exists for the benefit of corporations.

I know that some people are going to say that a corporation is really just a bunch of people, so there's really no big deal. But I don't think that's true.
Corporations are literally more than the sum of their parts. If any given person doesn't get on board with the overall ideology of the company (ideologies which are all too often driven by little more than the pursuit of profit), than that person can and usually will be replaced. This is how, in a sense, corporations can take on a sort of mind of their own. Furthermore, the nature of a corporation as a group of people means that individual people within it often don't feel morally or ethically responsible for the actions of the corporation as a whole. In practice, this means that employees who may not support a certain political position (or who may, in fact, be opposed to a particular position which the company supports) are helping to generate profits which may end up supporting it, anyway. If a person's best chance for a decent job are at a company that supports (through paid political ads) candidates that the individual employee doesn't support, should that employee have to quit and go find a job with a company who supports a more acceptable candidate? Doesn't this ruling move us another step toward having to consider all corporations to be political organizations?
One other thing that rankles me about the notion of corporations as participants in the political process is the sheer amount of money that they bring to bear. The resources possessed by large corporations (and the advertising power which it translates into) are pretty disproportionate to most individuals, groups of individuals, and political action groups. Other people and organizations stand a pretty good chance of being drowned out by the noise that a wealthy corporation will be able to make come election time (this noise being political ads and mailers and whatever else they can come up with). the only real limitation to the amount of money that will be spent on political propaganda materials will be the acquiescence of the shareholders, but in situations where the corporation's existence is threatened or where the corporation stands to make a lot more profit (imagine attempts to more tightly restrict or regulate a product which has proven very profitable for a company or efforts to overturn environmental protections so that a company can exploit some natural resources), shareholders are basically going to be willing to use their corporation's resouces to go "all in" and flood the electorate with political material.
We've already got lobbyists who work for these corporations running rampant all over our state and local governments, corporations and special interest groups giving money to politicians (although amounts are limited under current law- for now), and television "issue" ads which strongly impact elections (you know all of those ads which support or attack different candidates, but then end with a request for you to call and talk to your representative about a particular issue? That's the way corporations have been skirting the political ad restrictions up 'til now).
Anyway, you get the idea. Corporations are exerting greater and greater control over the American political process, and it just feels like we're increasingly living in a country with a government that's bought and paid for by business interests. If you want to know what kind of country is going to take shape as a result, just imagine the things that corporations don't care about (e.g., the environment, the priority of safety and health over profit, education- at least aside from job training, most forms of crime, poverty, etc.) and picture a world where those things are left to neglect.
Like I said. Arrrgh.

Don't know what else to say. I'm glad it's Friday. That's pretty cool.
I hope you guys have a good weekend.

No comments: