Sunday, January 03, 2010

Invictus; Avatar

Hey!
Well, I saw two movies over the holiday break, and they couldn't have been more different. The first one was Invictus, a movie directed by Clint Eastwood about the struggles of the South African national rugby team in its quest to win the World Cup (based, of course, upon actual events). Although there is some amount of spectacle involved in the rugby matches themselves (which take place in packed stadiums filled with tens of thousands of cheering fans), on the whole I found Invictus to be a sort of quiet, understated movie that lets the events and characters speak for themselves. Morgan Freeman, playing Nelson Mandela, doesn't chew up scenery or lend false dramatic tension to his role. Instead, he plays Mandela with an appropriate modesty and wisdom, allowing the man's deeds and the reverberations of his actions within a broader historical context infuse the role with all of the dramatic power that is needed. Matt Damon, playing team captain Francois Pienaar, does a very convincing job of portraying a team leader who is clearly a professional athlete first, and a politician and/or idealist only as a distant second. Nonetheless, Damon allows you to see Pienaar's personal growth over the course of the film. Invictus is a movie which relies upon the intelligence and knowledge of its audience quite a bit, almost to a fault. The film takes place at a time when Mandela is assuming the role of President of South Africa after decades of strict racial discrimination and apartheid. The film doesn't contain much backstory about the injustices and the suffering of black South Africans during the pre-Mandela years, and, unfortunately, I worry that the general lack of knowledge about South Africa in an American audience may diminish their appreciation of the movie a little bit. I think that the true measure of the brilliance and strength within Mandela's ideology, which placed almost equal value upon peacefulness, national unity, and racial of equality, may be somewhat lost on some American viewers (it was a big accomplishment just for Mandela to prevent the country from sliding into civil war, but without understanding what Mandela was overcoming, its hard to understand the magnitude of his success). Mandela takes the South African national rugby team, an institution which many black South Africans had long viewed as a symbol of white oppression (rugby had been largely played and supported by wealthy, white South Africans), and turned it into a national treasure by inviting all South Africans to rally around the team (the film portrays the national team carrying out rugby clinics at a number of poor, black townships at Mandela's request, for example). It was a strategy which was a tremendous example of the man's incredible leadership instincts.
Also, in terms of asking the audience to bring some knowledge to the table, I would say that it's possible to watch the movie without a working knowledge of the rules and strategy of rugby, but I walked out of the film wishing I had known a little more about the sport. Not crucial, but it would have helped a bit.
Anyway, Invictus was a good movie. I definitely recommend it, even for people who aren't huge sports fans. It's definitely as much about the post apartheid politics of South Africa as much or more than it's about rugby.

Avatar was a much different movie. It contained metaphor and allegory, to be sure, but even if a person completely missed all of the subtext in the film, you probably still wouldn't miss the movie's main point. Avatar is all about enjoying visual effects and beauty and the wonder of the environment that the movie places you in. I saw the movie in 3D, but even if you see it in 2D, the special effects create characters, creatures, and scenery on a whole new artistic level, and James Cameron uses the technology to create something which is truly impressive to look at (and given that much of the story is about the movie's environment, I think it's fair to say that the technology really does help to make the movie work).
I'll admit that the plot in Avatar is not entirely new or unique. Essentially, it's another form of Dances With Wolves, but on another planet and with aliens. That being said, the movie is well executed, and the plot isn't stupid (which was, I think, a big fear that many people had when they heard that this movie would be somewhat driven by technology). This isn't another Transformers 2 or G.I. Joe. The dialogue wasn't entirely flawless, but it was better than we've gotten in a lot of recent sci-fi/action movies lately (it didn't make me cringe or wince, and the characters, for the most part, acted in plausible ways).
And while we've seen the movie's themes before (related to imperialism, oppression of indigenous peoples, and the unjust acquisition and exploitation of foreign resources), it's not as if the need to explore these themes has gone away. The United States still seems pretty comfortable with many imperialistic tendencies, and we still seem pretty willing to subjugate foreign populations in the pursuit of our own interests (the Iraqis and the Afghans could probably speak to that). Avatar most closely brings to mind the treatment of Native Americans at the hands of white settlers during the Westward expansion portion of our own history, but the controversial practice of securing natural resources through the use of military force is an issue that we still grapple with (after the invasion of Iraq, did anyone else see all of those bumper stickers that said, "How did our oil get under their sand?").
Anyway, like I said, the themes of the movie weren't exactly new, but I would argue that they're still relevant. And Cameron managed to weave them into a movie that's pretty fun to watch.

So I give both movies the thumbs up. If you have any interest whatsoever in seeing Avatar, you should try to go see it at the theater in 3D while you can.

No comments: