Wednesday, December 07, 2005

Well, Howard Dean is coming under a lot of fire this week for saying that he thinks that the war in Iraq is unwinnable. The president, surprising no one, immediately jumped on Dean, labeling him as unpatriotic and criticizing him for failing to support the troops. Going further, the president said that our troops need to believe that their fight is winnable and there is a sound strategy behind this war.
And right there I think the president shot himself in the foot.
What strategy? The White House has refused to provide a timetable for troop withdrawals or to even establish a set of guidelines under which America might be able to say that the war has been won. We're fighting a "war" which is not a war in the conventional sense. There is no nation or organized group which is going to surrender to us or organize a cease fire. The war in Iraq is more akin to the war on crime or the war on drugs than any kind of traditional war. We're waging a war against a tactic, and even if tomorrow we were to wipe out every single person who has ever made use of a terrorist tactic, there's nothing to prevent new people from turning to terrorist tactics the following day in order to further their own political agendas. As long as the poor and disenfranchised seek to rise up and fight vastly superior forces, there will be horrible actions committed against civilian or noncombat targets by some individuals who use terrorism as a means of striking back at the enemy.

Perhaps Dean should have phrased his comments a little differently, but I agree with his sentiment. Furthermore, I believe that Dean had nothing more than the interests of our American soldiers at heart when he made his comments. If the war is unwinnable, we need a new strategy before more American lives are lost. Patriotism only gets you so far. There's a difference between supporting the troops and herding lemmings toward the sea. This is not a war which is going to have a discernible end. America needs a policy of international intelligence and police action for combatting terrorism- not a policy of large-scale foreign invasion.

I listened to an old Vietnam-era Richard Nixon speech on Air America this week as I was driving in to work, and it was truly chilling how similar his comments were to the soundbites that we are currently getting out of the Bush White House.
We can't set a timetable for the withdrawal of troops from Vietnam because doing so would only send a message of encouragement to the enemy.
Questioning the war effort is unpatriotic and undermines the efforts of our brave, young soldiers.
If we just have faith in the secret plans of our leaders and hold out for a while longer, things will get better.

History is teaching us nothing, people. We're mewing, sheeplike putty in the hands of Carl Rove's propaganda machine, and people are dying because of our ignorance. We're idiots, but we're damn patriotic idiots.

"Convince an enemy, convince him that he's wrong
Is to win a bloodless battle where victory is long
A simple act of faith
In reason over might
To blow up his children will only prove him right
History will teach us nothing"
- Sting

No comments: