Wednesday, November 04, 2009

The New V

'Ello! Hope everyone's doing well. The weather in Austin has been pretty incredible over the last couple of days.
So not too muc th report. Jamie made a fish dinner for us last night that was really good. Thanks, Jamie!

I also hung out and watched the new version of V with Ryan and Jamie last night. I'm still not sure what to think about this new version of V. I watched the original V miniseries and series when I was a kid, and I remember really getting into it. I also watched a good chunk of that original series last weekend on SyFy, and while it didn't hold up quite as well upon viewing it as an adult (the dialogue often seems incredibly stilted, the acting is mediocre, there's an enthusiastic use of early 80's style racial stereotypes, and the thing is often shot pretty poorly), the basic plotline and themes of the story continue to be intriguing.
[spoilers, I guess, for people who haven't learned about V over the last several decades]
V is, for people who don't know, a series that's about a bunch of aliens who come to Earth, initially pretending to be our friends and proclaiming a desire to help humanity in many ways, but, of course, in the end turning out to be aliens that are actually lizard people in disguise who want to consume humanity as food and deplete our natural resources. The original V series was loosely based upon the Nazi takeover of Germany before World War II. The Nazis, like the alien Visitors from V, initially presented themselves as friendly allies who had nothing but the good of the German people at heart. Like the Visitors, the Nazis offered benefits to the German populace that might otherwise seem out of reach (a stable economy, a powerful military that could provide strong national defense and security, etc.). It was, of course, only after the Nazis were well entrenched politically that their more aggressive and ruthless ambitions became known.
I have a couple of questions and concerns about the new series. First of all, the pacing is much more rapidfire and, in my opinion, sort of rushed as compared to the original series. In the original series, they took much more time to instill a growing sense of dread in the audience as we slowly came to realize that the visitors were not what they seemed (starting with small clues about their reptilian nature: that they feel cool to the touch, they don't eat cooked food, their presence seems to scare animals, etc.). This new series has pretty much skipped over any sense of dramatic tension that might have been involved with the population slowly coming to realize the true nature of the Visitors. In the first episode the aliens have already come to earth, ingratiated themselves with Earth's leaders and government, have taken control of the media, have established a chain of command involving human supporter lackeys, and have already been discovered to actually be bad/scary aliens with bad intentions. Oh yeah- and the initial stages of a human resistance movement have already begun. This all occurred within the show's first hour. As Ryan pointed out when we talked, the director/producers may have just decided to shorthand all of this stuff because they're assuming that the audience will already know the truth about the aliens in light of the initial miniseries from the 80's. Still, I can't help wondering what the point of telling the V story really is if you're not going to pay more attention to some of these themes. Given how quickly the show rocketed through all of these plot points, it doesn't really seem like there was much point in having the aliens show up in disguise at all. Why not just have them show up as an extremely powerful invasion force that simply occupies the planet by force? You could still tell the story of a resistance movie this way. The answer, of course, is that a show without an outright invasion wouldn't be able to call itself V and cash in upon the nostalgia value of the original series.
A show with a straightforward invasion couldn't sell itself as V, but I'm not sure that the direction that they're taking this new show leaves it with much of a claim in regard to resembling the original series, either. It's sort of annoying because I'm not sure that it would have made much difference that the audience already knew that the show was dealing with lizard aliens. The tension in the show doesn't come from the audience finding out the truth- it comes from watching the human characters as they figure out what's actually going on.
I was also, of course, annoyed that the show made such a point out of showing the aliens using universal health care services as a means of currying favor with the same population that they would ultimately seek to destroy. Seems like this reference to our current White House and the Democrats was heavy handed, lacked any kind of subtlety or grace, and was ultimately very misguided. I know that there probably are some conservatives out there who genuinely believe that Obama is some sort of alien infiltrator who has come to conquer the American people and inflict harm under the guise of kindness. At the end of the day, though, I think this is a huge stretch. It seeks to make a point that's as fictitious, fantastic, and nonsensical as the work of science fiction in which it appears. These are the same sort of sentiments that have resulted in people questioning the president's place of birth, insisting that he's a foreigner, labelling him as a Communist (and/or a Socialist or a Fascist), and generally fearing him because he's a minority leader who speaks logically and eloquently. The original V miniseries was a work of fiction that served as a metaphor to describe a historical event that had already taken place. This new version of V seems to be a fiction that's built upon another fiction- it feeds upon paranoid fantasies about a government that's looked upon with suspicion for working to provide health care, repair the economy, and which refuses to play into the ready-made traps of conservative, vitriolic media outlets. It all seems really lame and poorly thought through. For one thing, we've seen what happens with presidents who simply want to push their agenda upon the American people. We had 8 years of it under Bush, and it didn't involve much subtlety, diguise, or gestures of goodwill toward the people. Nowadays aggressive leaders just issue presidential orders, mandate things by presidential decree, and hide behind privilege when people push back.
They don't allow their key initiatives to get hung up while trying to pick up votes from the opposing party (i.e., allowing Olympia Snowe to control the health care debate in the pursuit of bipartisanship). Instead, modern presidents who get the totalitarian bug just do what they want and worry about the consequences later (e.g., Guantanamo, torture, rendition, wiretapping). The Bush White House wasn't V. It was Independence Day. It was War of the Worlds. (okay, on one of the rare occasions when it actually needed some support from an outside group, the Bush White House might have seems a little like the aliens from V. In front of the U.N. Secutriy Council, when they needed to get a resolution passed in support of the Iraq War, the Bush White House lied about Iraqi WMDs and the threat they supposedly posed to the world. We offered ourselves up as the white knights who would fix the fictitious problem. That was pretty V-like).
Anyway, I'll probably watch a few more episodes to see if/how they can turn things around, but I have serious reservations about the new V series.

Well, I just spent a lot of time on V, but now I gotta run. Maybe more later.

No comments: