Friday, November 13, 2009

9/11 Trials in New York;

Hey! Not too much to report.
I got around to watching Wednesday night's Glee last night. I still really like that show. The show isn't exactly subtle and at times it can be unapoligetically cheesey (this week's episode wasn't exactly subtle in its message about empathy for handicapped people), but I still find it was extremely well done. And, of course, Jane Lynch continues to impress me.
I also watched Fringe last night. I'm still enjoying it, as well. It's pretty far out, and probably not for everyone, but I like it.

And it sounds like five people involved in the 9/11 attacks, including "mastermind" Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, are going to be tried in federal court in New York for their involvement in the attacks. Critics have voiced opposition to the plan, both because of the perceived danger involved in trying these men on U.S. soil (there are theories that the tiral could generate further terrorist attacks) and because of concerns involved with trying accused terrorists in a federal court (as opposed to a closed military proceeding- some of the concern surrounding the use of federal court for the trials involves the use and possible release of confidential information during the trial).
Personally, I'm a little worried about the possibility of some kind of attack arising in relation to this sort of trial, but if experts are reasonably sure that the trials can be conducted safely, I think we should go ahead and carry them out in New York's federal court. I think that a public trial in the same city that suffered the bombings might do some considerable good in helping to heal some of the scars that our country still suffers as a result of 9/11.
Furthermore, I think it might be good to show the American people and the rest of the world that we aren't so afraid of terrorists that we're afraid to even try them in one of our normal federal courts.
There's no doubt that the 9/11 terrorists did some awful, terrible things, but I feel like subsequent to that event we have built up terrorists in the popular American psyche as being some kind of super powered monsters of almost unstoppable force. The truth is, these guys are just men, and simply criminals at that. They pulled off a well executed attack which unfolded in spectacular, devastating fashion, but these guys weren't super ninjas or specially trained elite military forces or anything. They were just a handful of guys who recognized some weaknesses in our security structure and exploited everyday, banal items for devastating effect (they managed to change the course of history with box cutters and passenger jets).
Following the attacks, I feel like the strength, might, and menace of terrorists (using "terrorist" here as a sort of general term) became somewhat exaggerated when some of our leaders realized that they could get more political mileage out of all-powerful, omnipresent, viciously evil, shadowy/undetectable beings than they could out of a simple story about poorly funded, moderately trained men who capitalized on American vulnerability and ineptitude in order to carry out their attacks. Funds are easier to appropriate and wars are easier to start when you're fighting an unknowable, demonic enemy than when you're fighting a bunch of clever, but all-too-human criminals.
Anyway, all of this being said, some hardline Muslim revolutionary could potentially set off a bomb or something as a show of opposition to this trial, but, frankly, this same thing could happen no matter where these men are tried (and, sadly, as we saw at Fort Hood recently, it doesn't necessarily take a trial in order for terrorists to suddenly inflict politically motivated violence against American citizens).
But I think trying these men in New York is a good thing. It might provide a greater sense of justice for Americans in the aftermath of 9/11, and our willingness to try these cases in New York shows both our citizens and people around the world that we aren't going to be cowed by the threat of terrorism.
As for the use of a civilian court as opposed to a military tribunal, in general I'm in favor of that, too. I think Americans need to see what's going on in this trial in order to gain a sense of justice from it, and I think that the use of a federal court will lend some transparency to the proceedings, thereby helping to reassure our citizens and the rest of the world that we're still a country that operates under the rule of law- even in the face of atrocities as evil as terrorism.
As for the confidentiality issues, the 9/11 attacks occurred 8 years ago, and it will probably be another year before the trial.
I have a hard time believing that there's much in the way of classified material that could leak out of this thing and cause new problems for U.S. intelligence agencies. If there are such issues, hopefully they can be worked out before trial. A judge will have to make rulings on confidential material to see if it should be released for the trial, weighing the need for the evidence against any possible national security concerns that might be involved.
Anyway, I think the trial is a good thing.

Well, that's it for now. Have a good weekend!

No comments: