Wednesday, November 04, 2009

The Italians Make a Crime of Rendition

In a case that I consider kind of fascinating, an Italian court has convicted 23 Americans of kidnapping and other charges related to the rendition of a Muslim cleric who was abducted from the streets of Milan in 2003. Rendition, for those who don't know, is a practice that has been used by the CIA and other American agencies to abduct terrorism suspects and remove them to other countries for interrogation (typically to countries that are more open to the use of more aggressive, intense interrogation techniques). Among the sentences handed down were an eight year sentence for former Milan CIA station chief Robert Seldon Lady and 22 other five year sentences for other Americans. Diplomatic immunity was granted to three other high ranking Americans, including the CIA's former Rome station chief. None of the Americans were present for their trial, and all were convicted in absentia. They remain fugitives in the eyes of the Italian government. Osama Moustafa Hassan Nasr, known as Abu Omar, is a Muslim cleric who was snatched from from the streets of Milan and flown out of an American air base to Egypt, where Abu Omar says he was tortured. Abu Omar is accused of having preached violence against Americans in his sermons and of having recruited terrorists to travel to Iraq in advance of the American invasion. He was under surveillance by Italian authorities at the time of his capture.

I don't want to condemn the actions of the CIA agents who carried out this operation under orders, and I don't want to treat terrorism or terrorists with any less seriousness than the matter deserves. That being said, I just don't think it's right for American agents to go snatching foreign citizens off the streets of foreign countries just because we feel entitled. As usual, I try to turn the situation around and imagine how the U.S. would feel if foreign agents were executing similar actions within our borders. As a hypothetical example, if Israeli agents had been snatching American residents or American citizens off of American streets (without any kind of notice or permission) because of alleged crimes against the Israeli people, we would probably have a huge problem with that sort of thing (seizing Americans without due process so they could be sent to some other country to be interrogated and tortured is, hopefully, something that our government would seriously frown upon). Extraordinary rendition is a terribly arrogant practice which not only violates human rights, but which shows a serious lack of regard for the legal rights and autonomy of other countries. If we, as Americans , have a suspicion that a foreign citizen is a terrorist who poses a serious threat, it's incumbent upon us to seek some knowledge and cooperation from other countries before we go around grabbing and torturing people (well, I don't think we should really be torturing people at all, but most people who read this blog have already heard me ramble on about that a lot). Failure to gain that sort of international cooperation constitutes the "might makes right" sort of foreign policy that turned the public sentiment of many foreign countries against us during the Bush years (and I know there are people who say they don't care what the rest of the world thinks of us, but those people, quite frankly, are just being stupid. To put it very simply, we may not absolutely need any particular country at any particular time, but to have a large number of nations turn against us economically, politically, and perhaps even militarily [at least in terms of lending their support] would be an extraordinarily bad thing).
Anyway, Amnesty International is applauding the convictions in this case, and I support them as well. You can't just fight terrorism by becoming terrorists yourselves, and extraordinary rendition (illegally kidnapping people who are still only suspects in order to secretly torture them) is a terrorist act. I'm sorry, but I demand better from my government and my intelligence officials.

No comments: