Howdy!
Some random stuff today. First, did anyone else know that Austin, at one time, had its own resident champion gunfighter/sharpshooter? He was named Ben Thompson, and there was a story about him on ashow called Sharphsooters on the History Channel this weekend. Thompson was a private in the Confederate army, and later fought in Mexico. He was imprisoned for two years for murder, having learned that his brother-in-law was abusing his sister and then subsequently killing him, but when he got out of prison, he apparently decided to play it straight (well, sort of straight- he still shot and killed a number of men in his post-prison years). He owned a saloon in Austin called the Iron Foot Saloon, and became City Marshal of Austin in 1881. He was later murdered at a theater in San Antonio by old enemies (Thompson's story is kind of complicated, but interesting. If you're so inclined, I recommend at least checking out the Wikipedia article).
Anyway, Thompson was featured on this program about sharpshooters because he challenged "Wild" Bill Hickok to a contest of shooting ability while Hickok was passing through Austin, and apparently managed to hold his own against Hickok, using only a pistol while Hickok used a much more accurate rifle. Supposedly Hickok was impressed by Thompson, and the two became friends, with Hickok presenting Thompson with a fancy, decorated pistol as a show of respect.
Anyhoo, I just find this Thompson guy interesting. I'm not sure whether or not I had heard much about him before, but even if I had, I'm sure I never heard about his service as marshall in Austin and the shooting contest with Hickok. Just kind of some cool, local flavor. If I had the money, I'd buy a site on Congress as close as possible to the location of the original Iron Foot Saloon, and open up a new version of the place on the same site (a little updated with live music, but with Thompson's portrait in the place and his story on the menus).
In other news, I finally finished reading Blood Meridian this weekend. Blood Meridian is a Cormac McCarthy novel from the mid eighties, and there are some who say it's his best book. I found it interesting, and definitely well worth a read (especially with so many people describing it as an American classic- it was picked as one of Time Magazine's 100 best novel of the last 70 years and selected by critics in the New York Times as one of the best novels of the last 25 years). All of that being said, it wasn't really my favorite Cormac McCarthy book.
Blood Meridian is the story of a young kid (he grows up, sort of in fast forward toward the end of the book, but for most of it he's less than 16 years old) who becomes embroiled in wars with the Native Americans along the Texas-Mexico border in the 1850's. He joins an irregular army unit who set out to fight the Indians, but who are quickly massacred, and following his escape, he falls in with the Glanton Gang, a group of American scalphunters who are collecting Indian scalps in order to collect bounties paid by the Mexican government. Eventually the Glanton Gang descend into sheer banditry and the murder of Indians, military, and civilians alike.
Many of McCarthy's books feature significant amounts of violence, but in Blood Meridian it truly reaches prodigious heights. This was actually one of the problems that I had with the book. I don't mind violence in my books- I really, really liked No Country for Old Men, which had plenty of violence in it- but the violence in Blood Meridian was so ubiquitous and vividly brutal that it sort of lost its meaning after a while. McCarthy's repeated, scrupulous, matter-of-fact descriptions of savagery seemed to become almost cartoonish and ridiculous after a while, or, at the very least, their constant presence eventually diminished their impact until I found myself reading through them without much response at all. Surely one of McCarthy's points in writing the book was to tear away some of the romanticism that modern Americans have imposed upon our recollections of the old west, but in trying to make his point, it just sort of felt like McCarthy was almost going too far in the other direction. Surely there were massacres and murders and scalpings and torturous deaths that took place during this time and place, but Blood Meridian paints the west as being a place of misery, chaos, and desolation to the exclusion of almost all else, which, in turn, seems just as questionable as the whitewashed revisionism which McCarthy seems to be railing against.
Another reason I had a hard time really connecting with the book simply came from McCarthy's writing style in this particular book. McCarthy writes in Blood Meridian with what I consider to be an overly verbose and yet sort of distant manner. He carries on and on with descriptions of landscapes and horses and towns and what have you, but he does so in a style that's almost overly poetic and a bit melodramatic. Other times, in the midst of actual conflict and dramatic tension, his level of description drops off to almost nothing (don't mind the soarse writing in order to build tension when it's appropriate, but it felt sort of jarring after reading pages and pages of descriptions of the desert). I definitely got the feel that McCarthy was "swinging for the fence" in terms of trying to write an American epic (his writing is detail oriented in terms of depicting an expansive Western setting), but he doesn't do a whole lot in giving the reader any kind of substantive detail regarding the novel's characters, who remain mostly underdeveloped and who often feel more like symbolic stereotypes than real people.
Blood Meridian definitely has a lot to say, much of it seemingly focused upon the foundation of bloodshed that our country was built upon and the inherent human tendency toward violence (a tendency which, as McCarthy points out, seemed to flourish in the lawlessness and disorder of america's westward expansion), but as a novel with interesting plotpoints and characters, I'm still not convinced that Blood Meridian is McCarthy's best. (gotta say that Judge Holden ranks up there as a truly memorable character, but even The Judge often seems more like a symbol of profound, interminable, and intricate evil than a genuine flesh and blood person). Between McCarthy's writing style and all of the violence and gore, at times Blood Meridian just felt like a Segio Leone movie on LSD (or maybe PCP?).
The whole novel, in my mind, read out more like a violent, chaotic parable than the telling of a tale that was meant to be believed (yes, I know this is a little ironic given the fact that the murderous Glanton Gang actually existed and did some very bad things). Anyway, my opinion, of course, doesn't make this novel a bad one- I'm just saying that this wasn't my favorite McCarthy book.
Still, if you want to read a book that will make you ask serious questions about the sort of moral depravity was involved in the struggle to establish our country, or if you're inclined to question what sort of actions men might find themselves committing when given the opportunity to conduct themselves in an ethical vacuum (or when they're outright encouraged to commit questionable acts in an ethical vacuum), then this might be your book.
This book has a lot to say, but I still favor No Country for Old Men, and, as an epic of the American west and the frontier experience, I would probably say that I prefer Lonesome Dove (although the simple fact that I'm comparing Blood Meridian to these other books probably demonstrates that I thought it was an important book- just not my favorite).
Anyway, I'm still very glad I read it. It got me thinking, so it was definitely well worth the time.
No comments:
Post a Comment