Friday, October 23, 2009

Video vs. Text (In Online News); Opting Out of the Public Option; Obama Family Photo

Hola! Happy Friday, amigos!

Well, Ryan's out of town, so having been freed up to actually have some fun for once, Jamie and I went out to dinner last night with Matt and Nicole at Suzi's. It was good to hang out with them. We ate Chinese food until we got sleepy.

In the tradition of using this blog to complain about stuff that annoys me (this thing would probably be more aptly named "The Rantings and/or Lamentations of Steanso"), here's today's gripe: why do CNN and the other web sites seem so convinced that it's better to post the stories on their web sites in video clip format as opposed to in a written text? CNN, MSNBC, and some other news websites (including sites for newspapers and magazines, of all things) seem determined to post a significant number of stories in video-only format, and this practice bugs me. For one thing, it takes longer for me to watch a video than it does for me to quickly read an article and gain relevant information from it. The news videos themselves take longer to watch, and oftentimes viewers are required to watch some kind of commercial before the video plays, which only adds to the viewing time.
Second, personally, I think I tend to assimilate information much more quickly and efficiently when I'm reading something as opposed to watching a video with voiceover narration. Different people have different learning styles, true enough, so some people may learn more easily from watching the videos, but personally I think I tend to not only be able to absorb information more quickly when reading it, but I tend to remember and digest the the details of stories better after having seen them in print. We already have the actual brodcast networks that people can watch for video programming on CNN, MSNBC, and the like, and I've liked the websites, from the beginning, because they provided a written format which I could consume much more efficiently than I could by sitting down to watch an entire video program.
Also, sometimes I just get annoyed by the voices of some of the reporters and by the way that they edit/produce their stories and put them together. Oftentimes there aren't really compelling images that we need to see or which add any particular insight to a story, and yet the story still appears in a video-only format. Granted, there are occasional stories that are best told by way of visual information, but far more often I have to sit through a video in order to get the information in the story, but by the end it has never become lear why the story had to be conveyed through video. And sometimes I just don't like listening to the pseudo gravitas of reporters as they convey information to me that I'm not sure they even really understand themselves.
Maybe these outlets should have a website that contains these individually wrapped video news stories, but I still think that the same information contined in the video stories should be provided in text versions for those who prefer to consume it that way. Preferrably, I guess I'd rather just see separate websites for all-video and all text versions of stories.
Some people (okay, most people) may not care much about this video vs. text format issue, but I tend to read quite a bit of news online (both because of personal interest and so I can find stuff to talk about here in the ol' blog), and the whole video thing slows me down and annoys me. The other day I heard some stupid "analyst" or "expert" on TV talking about how the internet was going to eventually lead to the death of written news as everyone moved to video only formats, and I just couldn't help thinking, "Well, until reporters start talking at a faster speed than I can read, I just can't see how video is going to appeal to me more than print."
We may be moving print journalism away from newspapers and magazines and into an online format, but I still think (and hope) that print is a long way from being dead.

It sounds like senate majority leader Harry Reid has renewed a push for a public option (a government-run insurance plan), a move which has previously been viewed as likely to cause difficulty in passing a health care reform bill in the senate (both Republicans and a number of "blue dog", conservative Democrats have declared themselves to be against such a plan). The new angle neing taken by Democrats in trying to advance such an option would be to allow states to "opt out" of the government plan. It's thought that the ability for states to opt out might appease some centrists who have expressed concerns about the public option.

So now the opposition to the public option seems even more outlandish than before. Opponents say that the public option will evnetually lead to a single payer system, because private insurance companies won't be able to compete with a public option and will go out of business, leaving only the public option standing and thereby depriving consumers of choices. Maybe this is something of a concern, but it's a very remote one, and it's far from clear that this would ever happen (insurance companies have been posting very large profits for quite a while now, and while they may not continue to post record proftis, there's probably still a lot of room in there for viable, well run businesses). In the much more realistic, immediate situation that we're dealing with at present, it is very clear to me that Republicans and Blue Dogs already are striving to deprive the American consumer of choices by depriving them of a low cost, government run alternative. I like this opportunity for states to opt out, because if leaders like our conservative Texas politicians decide to opt out, they're going to have to answer to their own annoyed constituents if people in other parts of the country start receiving low cost, effective medical care, but Texans can't get access to it. If Republicans are so convinced that the public option is going to be a horrible failure, the least they could do would be to allow states that want it to begin to implement it (because in the end, this new plan by Reid is really letting states who want to participate to "opt in"). This would give Republicans the chance to sit back and point at the unfolding disaster they're predicting and say, "this is why we didn't want it." Instead, conservatives seem nervous about even giving the public option a chance to work. And isn't there something a little suspicious about that?

And here's the newly unveiled official White House portrait of the first family! You gotta admit that they're a good looking family.


That's it! Maybe more later. The weather in Austin is still beautiful today. Hope ya'll have a great weekend!

4 comments:

mcsteans said...

WORD re: news videos. It has long raised my hackles that I can't just click and read many of the stories on CNN.com, etc.

J.S. said...

See, that's what I'm talking about!

The League said...

advertising, I think.

But, also, the technology has made it as easy or easier to post their existing content than to run their scripts as stories. And when you watch CNN these days, you understand why you wouldn't want their scripts down as written record.

Watched HLN's morning show for the first time in years today, and its like watching the dumbest people from your high school geography class putting on fake news.

J.S. said...

Well, the freak show at HLN has been quite a bit different than CNN for a while now (I'll admit CNN is far from perfect, though), and I almost never watch it. As for providing written versions of stories, it would have to be amongst the cheapest of their expenses (and they already have to prepare news scripts).