Tuesday, October 27, 2009

Public Option: Opt Out v. Trigger; More Bombs in Iraq; A Note on Heroes

Hi. What's up?
Not too much going on.
Ryan's still on a Corpus Christi-Galveston business trip. I think he's actually probably in waders, gigging for crabs along the seashore.

Yesterday Senate Majority leader Harry Reid announced his intention to introduce legisaltion with a public option that allows states to opt out. I think this a good compromise. States that don't want the public option wouldn't necessarily have to get onboard, so this would present a significant compromise that conservatives will have a harder time arguing against. If the public option proves to be a popular, well run system in the states that adopt it, the leaders of individual states that have opted out will have to either get onboard or explain to their own constituents why they don't have it. (on the other hand, if the public option doesn't work very well, I would guess that lots of states might want to opt out).
There's been talk about using a "trigger" for the public option instead of using this state by state opt out model. The trigger would mean that a public option only kicks into effect if insurance companies fail to meet certain benchmarks in terms of keeping down costs and providing coverage to a large number of people. It may just be because I'm a lawyer, but I'm wary of the trigger alternative. 1) I think it will just create new arguments about where the benchmarks are going to be set before a public option kicks in (Republicans will want the governement to have to wait until things get pretty expensive and way too many people are uninsured before the public option can be activated), and 2) if and when the insurance companies fail to meet their benchmarks, I think they'll use every trick in the book to try to hide the facts and deny that they're still raising their costs and denying coverage to people. The trigger seems to just put off the arguments with the health care industry for some future date. If the looming threat of a complete health care overhaul didn't force them to clean up their act, I don't think the trigger will change their behavior much, either. They'd rather just stick to business as usual (highly profitable business as usual), and fight against reform with lawyers and lobbyists.

What else? Bombs went off in Baghdad, killing 160 people and wounding more than 500 over the weekend. That sucks. I guess things aren't going to be all squeaky clean and fixed up as we withdraw from Iraq. I guess that was never really a realistic outcome in the first place. Hopefully we've trained some Iraqi forces well enough that they can begin to deal with these security problems on their own. That's probably the best we can hope for. I'm not that hopeful (and I don't think we should have ever been in that country in the first place), but it sure would be nice to have Iraq as a stable, democratic ally in that part of the world.

Well, I don't have very much, I guess. I watched Heroes last night. I definitely feel like there's way too much chit chat and not enough super powered action. Also, now they're exploring some kind of lesbian relationship between Claire (our super powered cheerleader) and her roommate. It'll probably boost the ratings, but it feels a little desperate. I think the most amazing super power on Heroes is probably its amazing ability to stay on the air.

Ciao.

No comments: