Thursday, October 29, 2009

The Bystander Effect

Once again, not too much going on. Hung out and had dinner with Jamie last night. It was good. I think Ryan's supposed to be back from his business trip tomorrow night.

This is grim, but I have to admit that I've been sort of following the story of this 15 year old girl who was gang raped for over 2 hours in Richmond, California, as other people looked on. I just don't get it. It's one of those things that creates cognitive dissonance within my whole worldview. It's bad enough that some sick bastards did the thing in the first place, but then to have bystanders and spectators who didn't report it? Kinda makes me sick.
Psychologists try to explain this behavior away through what they call the "bystander effect". Apparently this is a combination of people being unwilling or afraid to get involved, people assuming that someone else has already called the authorities or done something about the situation, and/or people who just somehow removed themselves or distanced themselves from the situation, somehow by way of the number of people watching the event.
Personally, I'm not really buying all of that. More than likely, if there were bystanders watching this thing take place, at least some of those people must have had cell phones and the ability to use them to get help. And this assault reportedly went on for hours.
In general, we only hold people criminally culpable in our country for actions that they actively commit. The general rule is that we don't hold people responsible for simply failing to act or help (with a number of notable exceptions, such as failing to render aid in an accident that you were a part of). Maybe we need to reexamine that line of thinking in.
I don't know what I'm trying to say here.
I don't want to extrapolate this thing too much, and I know, logically, that there are some serious logical flaws in holding up something that might be (and hopefully is) an isolated incident while inferring that it must be representative of a larger trend. Nonetheless, I can't help but wonder what this sort of thing says about the value that our society- particularly the younger parts of our society- seems to be placing on the value of human life and the rights of other people.
As I've said, what scares me about this whole incident isn't so much the fact that there were some rapists out there who were ready and willing to commit this assault. Society has always had criminals and predators, and, sadly, I suspect we're going to always have individuals who fall into the most violent and anti-social ends of the personality spectrum. But these sorts of individuals are supposed to be isolated, somewhat rare, extreme examples- people on the far end of some kind of contiuum of bad, nasty behavior
A bunch of people standing around watching a gang rape without lifting a finger indicates an acceptance on the part of non-participants that I find somehow even more troubling than the predation (okay, maybe not more troubling, but more unexpected and almost equally troubling in a different way). How do people become indifferent or desensitized enough to not respond with shock and alarm to this kind of thing? What are we doing to ourselves that creates this kind of reaction from people? Is it just how people are?
I give up. I'm not making much sense.
This case just bothers me.
We need to be helping each other out. I like to think that we can and do help each other out.
Maybe I'm an idiot.
This is the sort of thing Cormac McCarthy writes about when he creates books about well meaning people who just can't make sense of the world.

2 comments:

Nicole said...

From Cormac McCarthy: No Country for Old Men

I don’t know what to make of that. I surely don’t.

The crime you see now, it’s hard to even take it’s measure. It’s not that I’m afraid of it. I always knew you had to be willing to die to even do this job. But I don’t what to push my chips forward and go out and meet somethin’ I don’t understand. A man would have to put his soul at hazard. He’d have to say, ‘Ok, I’ll be part of this world.’

J.S. said...

Exactly, Nicole.