Tuesday, September 08, 2009

More Updates; New York Addresses Housing Issues with the Mentally Ill

So the holiday is over. Too fast. I had a really good weekend and got to spend some time with a lot of good friends and family.
Yesterday morning Ryan and I took all three dogs down to the spillover. This trip represented our first trip out in public with Scout since Ryan and Jamie brought her home. She still doesn't do a really great job of coming when she's called, but within a span of about an hour she went from cowering on the edge of the creek bank to relaxing and running around and having fun with the other dogs and even playing in the water a bit. Lucy and Cassidy, for whom such trips are old hat, absolutely love the creek, and they ran and swam in the water from the moment we got there until it was time to leave. I think the trip was a great success for all of the dogs involved (and for me as well- I got to swim. Ryan had to spend a lot more time supervising novice dog, Scout).
Finished things up with some music last night at the Hop-a-Long Lounge. Rock, rock, rockin'.
The weekend wore me out.

A federal judge ruled on Tuesday that the State of New York has been effectively discriminating against mentally ill people by placing them in privately owned and operated "adult homes", which are often poorly run, chaotic, and squalid, according to the ruling. The judge ruled that the poor conditions in these homes, which are often managed and run by poorly trained, uneducated individuals who are responsible for not only helping with day to day living tasks, but also for helping to dispense strong psychoactive medications which often come with complicated dosing regimens, constituted discrimination by the state against mentally ill individuals.
Texas has a system which is similar to the one which was found unacceptable in New York.
The current system sort of took shape in the 1960's and 70's, when new, more effective anti-psychotic medications came onto the market, and trends in psychiatric treatment moved toward "deinstitutionalization", a movement which sought to shut down state run psychiatric institutions (which were seen as simply warehousing the mentally ill) and reintegrate people with mental illness back into the mainstream community. As government institutions were shut down, caseworkers turned to private adult homes (in Texas we call most of them board and care facilities or group homes) which were supposed to provide care for their residents, most of whom paid their residential care costs through social security disability payments or other government assistance. In theory, these facilities were supposed to provide a healthy living environment and a certain minimum level of psychiatric care/assistance for their residents.

Having learned a small amount about these facilities since I started working the mental health docket, I have very mixed feelings about these private facilities. Let me start out by saying that there are some of these places that do a really commendable job, especially given the resources they have to work with. Some people who work in and/or own these adult homes have felt compelled to provide safe, secure homes with good living conditions for people with mental illness, and some are doing a really good job. But there are a whole bunch of group home owners out there who are mostly interested in running very low income housing for people who have small, but reliable government disability income and who are unlikely to have the wherewithal to effectively file a complaint when conditions become unsanitary, abusive, or otherwise negligent. Some of these owners will cut corners wherever they can (in terms of everything from building maintenance to sanitation to the training and education level of employees) in order to maximize profits. The people who run these homes usually can't collect a ton of money from their residents, but they typically do get a steady government check, and most of their residents are too ill to be able to effectively voice or file a complaint if their living situation becomes untenable.
So oftentimes the residents of these homes end up living in some pretty poor conditions.
Also, because the residents of these homes are under no legal obligation to stay in the home and because the employees of the home typically have no legal authority over them, the mentally ill residents of group homes often simply wander away from these places if they're unhappy with the conditions (or sometimes even just because they're unsupervised and bored).
In my current job I often deal with cases where caseworkers have repeatedly placed a person in a group home with proper medication and promises for follow up welfare visits, only to have the person immediately wander away again right after they've been dropped off (and in my line of work, once they wander away, they usually end up doing one thing or another that lands them on my misdemeanor docket).
I understand the desire to deinstitutionalize these people and reintegrate them back into the community- I really do- but when your alternative is to warehouse the mentally ill in poorly run, overcrowded, substandard housing with very little (if any) actual psychiatric care or living assistance, it often feels like the cure for institutionalization seems more disturbing than the original problem (the problem being the segregation of the ill and the sort of institutional dependence that was created by keeping people confined in a large government facility).
I'm not sure what the answer is. A far greater degree of regulation for these facilities might be the first step, but, of course, most of these mentally ill people have very little money, so you're not likely to see vast improvements in the quality of care in these group homes unless and until there's more money available to make the homes better (the constant flow of small amounts of money from an uncomplaining population is sort of what developed the current situation in the first place- and I think a lot of these places might just shut down and not be replaced if greater demands were placed upon them without more money flowing in). Another solution would be to reestablish government run, institution-style living environments, but to try to make them better than they had previously been (i.e., more community integration, better care, etc.). I kind of like the idea of new, better mental health institutions, but I'm not sure about the feasibility of this sort of idea. Also, I have to admit that I just don't think that all mentally ill people can successfully reintegrate into the community (or at least there are some people who spend more time in jail than out when they try to do this. Maybe if they had a better place to live they would be off the streets and out of trouble more of the time).
I guess the biggest problem is that there's just not enough money to properly address this issue. Among the general public the health and well being of the mentally ill population is mostly a sort of low priority item (no one cares much about it until it directly affects their family), so it's hard to find tax money to make things better.
Anyway, this article about New York just caught my eye because it sounds like their dealing with the same sorts of problems that are going on in Texas, but the judicial system has gotten involved in their situation. It'll be interesting to see how the whole thing shakes out. I'm glad this issue made the front page of the New York Times because, in my mind, it deserves a lot more public attention.

Well, that's what I've got today. Hope you guys are having a good one! Short week!!!

No comments: