Saturday, September 12, 2009

Kids and Racism

There's a sort of fascinating article in Newsweek from this past week about children and how their learning patterns and innate psychological makeup can end up leading them to engage in racial discrimination. I just found the article interesting because, personally, I had always thought that racial discrimination was just a social convention which children learned through exposure to people in the world around them. If there were an absence of racial prejudice in the world, I thought, kids would grow up to treat people as equals, regardless of race. This article, however, follows a number of university studies in developmental psychology (from some extensive studies at our own University of Texas to studies at Duke, the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, and others), and finds, first and foremost, that kids, developmentally, tend to naturally tend toward in-group favoritism. As they gather, sort, and manage new facts about the world, children have an innate tendency to try to define things by categorizing them, and one of the natural ways that they put things in categories is through physical appearance (which is, of course, one of the most readily obvious characteristics that they have at their disposal). Additionally, researchers seem to be finding that children have a natural tendency to assume (even in the absence of evidence) that people who share their own group also tend to share important characteristics with them (e.g., the people in my group are all nice or smart or friendly), a thinking pattern which psychologists refer to as essentialism. Both of these two phenomena working in conjunction can tend to produce racially biased thinking (i.e., kids look at people and mentally divide them into gorups based on physical appearance, and then begin to attribute more favorable characteristics to the group that they fit into themselves).
Developmental psychologists have begun to realize that children as young as six months old are already noticing differences in physical appearance such as skin color and other racial characteristics, and think kids are well on their way toward trying to use these characteristics to classify and define people (and trying to assign them accompanying characteristics by age 3).
All of this was pretty interesting to me, but even more interesting was the effectiveness (or ineffectiveness) of the way in which adults have traditionally attempted to address issues of race based thinking and discrimination in children. Researchers have discovered that many parents either don't discuss race issues with their children at all (assuming that children will learn on their own that all races are equal), or else they tend to speak to their kids in sort of vague, general terms, because speaking about the specifics of race issues kind of makes parents uncomfortable (parents cite this as the reason for avoiding in depth discussions on race). Research is showing that because of innate tendencies to categorize people and to favor people in one's own category, ignoring racial issues doesn't really work as an effective means of teaching nondiscrimination. Vague or general statements have been shown to be fairly ineffective as well, since children often don't really seem to be able to tie abstract concepts to their everyday experiences when it comes to race (this means that saying "People of all skin colors are equal" isn't nearly as effective with children as it would be to say "Black people and people with different colored skin should be your friends in just the same way as white people.") If parents want to help dissuade their children from developing attitudes of racial prejudice- and studies have demonstrated that such attitudes can become fairly solidified and difficult to modify by the time kids are in third grade- then it's much more effective for to have specific, explicit, concrete talks about the fact that black kids, brown kids, and all kids are equal to white kids in terms of being friends, classmates, teammates, etc, and these talks need to happen at a surprisingly early age.
Also, researchers are finding that oftentimes race is only brought up by many parents when a child says something that is deemed socially inappropriate (i.e., some kind of comment on skin color or perceived differences between races), and the parent hushes the child or tells them to be quiet. The message that many children learn from these sorts of interactions isn't that racism is an incorrect worldview so much as they learn that racism is something that shouldn't be talked about aloud, especially in public. To correct this line of thinking, psychologists suggest that race issues should sometimes be discussed in a non-disciplinary context, and that when a child does make an inappropriate comment, that parents should take the opporunity (if the circumstances are approproate, obviously) to discuss and correct prejudicial thinking.
One other thing that struck me as a little bit counterintuitive was a research finding which discounts the so-called Diverse Enviroment Theory. Diverse Environment Theory has long held that children who are growing up in a mixed race setting (i.e., exposed to people of a number of racial backgrounds) will tend to naturally overcome racial prejudices. Diverse Environment Theory is part of the philosophy behind school integration. Although researchers hasten to point out that they still see school integration as imperative on moral grounds, recent sociological research tends to indicate that it doesn't necessarily go that far in dispelling racial prejudice. In fact, studies of adolescents have tended to find that the more diverse that schools tend to be, the more kids tend to self-segregate by race and ethnicity within the school. In practice, increased opportunities to interact with one another also tend to produce increased opportunities to reject one another, and attitudes and taboos conducive of self segregation are often reinforced (e.g., divisions are created between groups that can sit together in the cafeteria, fears can build in regard to the alienation of offending peers within one's own racial group by creating relationships across racial boundaries, etc.). The studies showed that children who participate in at least one somewhat demanding activity with kids of another race (i.e., something challenging enough to actually require kids of different races to work together) were much more likely to develop significant interracial friendships. Also, simply having frank discussions about the issue can probably help.
There was also mention in the article of the fact that minority parents tend, on the whole, to talk much more specifically and frequently with their kids about racial issues. The study found that a small to moderate amount of this type of talk was probably helpful to the kids, but that extensive, regular, ongoing warnings about the perils and pervasiveness of racism could tend to form racially divisive attitudes among minority children almost as readily as actual experiences with and exposure to real world racism. Basically, if minority kids were exposed to too many warnings about racism, the kids tended to develop a more paranoid sort of worldview, and also tended to develop attitudes in which personal difficulties were more consistently blamed upon the prejudices of the world at large as opposed to being accepted as something which the child needed to take personal responsibility for and work to correct. Messages of racial or ethnic pride among minority kids seemed to do a better job of helping kids create a more positive worldview and instilling a positive self image (thereby allowing kids to overcome prejudice as well as personal obstacles and be successful) as opposed to simply warning kids about racism. Messages of ethnic and racial pride amongst white kids are a lot more controversial, primarily because the messages aren't being used to overcome a history of discrimination and potential race-based self esteem issues (meaning that if white kids are going to be taught about white pride, a big part of it needs to be about how white people have historically engaged in prejudice and committed some bad acts in the "support of" their own race- white kids generally don't need to be taught that their race is equal, and, of course, we don't need to be filling the heads of white kids with fictions about racial superiority. The racial pride issue with white kids seems to come more in a "we're all equal" flavor, with an acknowledgement that white people have made some bad mistakes at times, often due to discrimination).

Anyway, I just found the whole article really interesting. Definitely worth a read. My mom, aka, the Karebear, was teaching in Florida in the 60's when forced integration first occurred. She has stories about white parents showing up at her elementary school to protest the fact that their kids were having to go to school with black kids, and Mom dealt with classrooms full of white and black kids who were learning together for the first time. Well, as anyone those who know her know, Karebear really does love all kids, so seeing kids subjected to these kinds of attitudes affected and troubled her.
As a consequence, race issues were strongly on Mom's mind as I was growing up, and from my earliest years I remember hearing that there was no difference between black kids and white kids, and that I should be basing my friendships on the way that other kids acted and not on the color of their skin (and Mom is pretty direct. She didn't just sort of spit out general platitudes about all people being equal. I remember getting the "If the black kids in your class want to be your friend, you go play with them because they're just like you" talks.) The Steans family wasn't out marching in demonstrations or anything (I don't want to overstate what was going on in our home), but racial equality, especially in schools, was a big issue for Mom. I remember Mom reading us stories about Martin Luther King at an early age, and I really was raised with the understanding that the man was pretty much an American saint (and I say this without a hint of sarcasm or irony- the combination of King's racial equality message, his nonviolent tactics, and his strong religious faith made him one of the big, historical heroes of the Steans house when I was growing up).
The schools that I went to while growing up were mostly white. There were always a few black kids, but not very many. Still, I had black friends and Mexican-American friends and a number of Asian friends (it kind of annoys me today that I didn't let Jim Lee's mother talk me into going to Chinese school with him on weekends- she really wanted me to go learn Chinese with him on Sunday afternoons).
Anyway, I was extremely fortunate to have grown up in a household with attitudes that I didn't even know were progressive, but which, in retrospect, clearly were. I grew up knowing that my parents both strongly believed that racial integration, racial equality, and civil rights were extremely important, and I grew up hearing that kids of other races were just like me, but with different colored skin (it eventually became clear to me, especially with one of my Taiwanese friends, that there were some differences in language and cultural background, but those never seemed to matter a lick to my parents, except to occasionally hold up their family's work ethic as a model of something that we should be trying to emulate).
Anyway, all of this was on my mind as I read this article. My mom was a teacher for 30+ years in public elementary schools with probably more than half of those years spent in schools with as many or more minority kids as white kids. As much as mom's kids loved her, I know that she also kind of ruled her classrooms with some pretty strict discipline, and I know that she was pretty intolerant of racially divisive attitudes in her classrooms, trying to foster the same attitudes in her kids that I was raised with- you pick your friends on the basis of the content of their character and not on the color of their skin. I visited her classrooms many times over the years and saw kids of all races and backgrounds learning and playing together pretty seamlessly. Granted, Mom's students were young, and I don't know if those attitudes held up over the years, but it's nice to know that those kids had that kind of foundation at least at some point in their lives, and that hopefully some of those sorts of memories would remain buried somewhere in the back of their heads.

Anyway, I'm not a parent, but I found the developmental psychology involved in this discussion very interesting. If children have an innate tendency to classify people based on physical appearance as well as a natural tendency to attribute more positive characteristics to groups of people who look the most like them (and, conversely, a natural tendency to be more suspicious of people who aren't in their group- a phenomenon which the studies also found), then these findings have strong implications in terms of how we need to encourage children at an early age to start looking beyond physical characteristics when making judgments about people (and instead of just helping children to avoid learning about racism from others, we may need to be focusing on overcoming its development as a product of innate learning processes). Like I said, I'm not a parent, but I'm very interested in living in a country without racial prejudice or discrimination, so..... if you want to help make sure that your kids don't grow up with racial prejudice as part of their thinking, talk to them early on and in concrete terms about the fact that black folks and brown folks and yellow folks and white folks all can make really good friends, classmates, etc.. Apparently it's not enough to think that just being around people of other races will necessarily help overcome come racially prejudiced thinking.

I think I've tired myself out.

No comments: