Hi, guys!
Well, I'm suffering a bit from cold or allergies or something, but I'm hanging in there.
Since I was feeling a little crappy and out of it, I didn't even end up watching Obama's speech last night. I saw lots of clips of it, of course, and read about it, and watched a bunch of different talking heads as they analyzed it to death, but in the end, it appears that it was almost exactly what I expected. Sounds like Obama gave a pretty strong, persuasive, articulate speech which is probably going to change the minds of just about no one. Big speeches just don't sway public opinion much anymore. People are extremely skeptical of elected officials these days, they're more likely to see persuasive speech as political trickery than as a legitimate means of conveying a message, and most of all, people are too beholden to party ideology to let a single speech affect their position on a given issue. This is one of the reasons I thought it was kind of dumb to keep calling a big speech a "do or die" affair or a "game changer". (and it really doesn't bother me that people aren't that affected by speeches, since most big issues should be judged on their merits rather than ont he eloquence of a leader- but that being said, it seems like endless, ubiquitous political TV advertisements do have an impact, and this is troubling since so many of these ads can be misleading or factually incorrect).
Anyway, Obama gave a good, strong, forceful speech. He may not have endorsed the public option as strongly as most Democrats would have preferred, but he gave a good speech (and even if we end up with something like a trigger, meaning a public option kicks in if insurance companies don't keep costs down and comply with increased regulations, I think a health care reform bill could do a lot of good- a bill could be written in a way that would vastly improve our health care situation). Of course, I would still definitely prefer a public option. I think it's the best chance that we have for keeping costs under control and keeping the insurance comapnies honest.
What else?
Not much.
People have been making a big deal out of South Carolina Representative Joe Wilson yelling out "You lie!" during Obama's speech. Do I thinks it looked really trashy and stupid? Yes. Do I think it was a big deal? Not really. After all of these town halls and other heated events, I was kind of wondering if the Republicans wouldn't vocalize their discontent at some point during the speech. Part of me is surprised that there was only one outburst. I'm glad Wilson apologized, and I'm glad that Obama didn't make an issue of it. Lookin like a rude, classless jackass in front of the entire country is probably punishment enough (although I'm sure there are some people who would rather have seen many more insults hurled at the president).
Well, I gotta go. Hope you're having a good day.
4 comments:
I give Joe Wilson another 24 hours before he's hailed as a martyr and hero to the cause for standing up to The Tyrant Obama.
I'm pretty sure there were a lot of people cheering, slapping high fives, and clinking their glasses together about 2 seconds after the whole thing happened. I think the fact that he called the White House to offer an official apology will take some of the wind out of the martyr/hero movement, though. Hard to celebrate someone too much for something that they've later said they shouldn't have done.
I think you underestimate Rush Limbaugh's ability to spin and the complete certainty that Fox and Friends will spend an hour downplaying Wilson's behavior, saying "oh, he had to call... But he was had it right the first time."
Oh, I have no doubt that the wingnuts on the far right will try to spin Wilson's outburst as a heroic act, but those people are already dead set against health care reform and Obama, anyway, so let 'em rant. I'm more concerned about how Wilson's outburst will play with moderates and independents, and I would think (maybe naively) that this will play pretty poorly with them. It was clearly lame enough for the guy to realize that he had screwed up and immediately apologize (and I would think that many independents still want to see a little better behavior out of a joint session of Congress than the asshattery that's been displayed by screaming fools at some of our town hall meetings). They can't really take the tactic that he was just pushed too far and couldn't contain himself in the face of the president's lies, because where does that leave Wilson, given the fact that he apologized? If the president was really that out of line, it would seem like cowardly kowtowing to go and apologize to him after the fact.
But yeah, they'll try to spin it.
Post a Comment