Well, CNN has another story out today about the growing sense of outrage that's spreading amongst some conservatives about the president giving a back to school pep talk/speech to American school kids about the importance of staying in school, studying hard, and placing a focus upon education and the opportunities that education can provide in their lives. The Austin American Statesman reports that in Central Texas, the Leander, Gergetown, and Wimberly school districts will not be showing live broadcasts of Obama's speech. Conservatives are claiming that the president is actually trying to indoctrinate kids with a liberal agenda.
I guess Obama is pursuing a liberal agenda, if you consider placing an emphasis on education and avoiding ignorance as distictively liberal ideas (and judging by the reactions of some conservatives in this case, I'm starting to feel like avoiding ignorance may, in fact, be an exclusively liberal objective).
What the hell?
This is truly nuts.
Where was George W. Bush when planes started crashing into things on September 11, 2001? He was in an elementary school classroom (I believe in Florida)- reading stories to children and talking to them about how important it was to study. (as a matter of fact, he was having such a good time that he continued with the storybook reading, if memory serves, for about 7 minutes after being told that the U.S. was under attack)
The point is- I don't remember hearing a lot of protests and complaints from anyone when Bush was visiting with and encouraging students.
One of the roles that comes with being President of the United States is providing leadership, providing guidance, and even serving as something of a role model for the American people. The White House has repeatedly said that the president's talk is going to be nonpartisan and simply stress education. Numerous past presidents from both sides of the aisle have engaged in this sort of activity without anyone batting an eye (even if people aren't politically aligned with the president, it seems like there might be some benefit to kids in hearing some advice on education from a guy who's been a Harvard Law graduate, a constitutional law professor at a prestigious university, a U.S. Senator, and President of the United States).
So let's see.... what might be the difference between Obama and all of the past presidents who've addressed America's students? (including Bill Clinton, Jimmy Carter, and countless other Democrats who pulled off these sorts of events with little or no fanfare) There must be something that makes Obama different from all of these past presidents.... Something which would freak out a bunch of mostly white conservatives and spook them badly enough to make them see a boogeyman behind every corner and monsters in every shadow.
Well, Obama is black.
And the vast majority of this ridiculous bullsh*t is being driven by prejudice, ignorance, and fear (which is easily turned into rage with a little stirring and simmering by conservative leaders, mouthpieces, and pundits).
There. I said it.
If a white guy was in office, even a Democrat (and believe me when I say that Democrats come in flavors which are far, far more liberal than Obama), I truly believe that we wouldn't be seeing people freak out this way.
Some white folks are just kind of losing their sh*t at the moment. There are a lot of people out there who would never admit to racism, but, in truth, they're not comfortable with a world in which black people (or other minorities) actually play an active, meaningful role in running the country and affecting all of our lives. There are white folks who are kind of flipping out as they see minorities taking on roles of increasing power and leadership within the American power structure, mostly because they feel threatened as they see the traditional, overwhelming dominance of whites in the power structure being challenged. Of course, the truth is that the dominance of white people within the American power structure really is being threatened as the minority population in our country continues to grow and continues to be expand its political influence. (but I think most people who are interested in moving beyond race based thinking aren't too alarmed by this)
So having a black president give a motivational speech to your kids is sort of unavoidable, undeniable proof that minority leaders are now having a real, tanglible effect on the lives of American citizens. So that'll freak some bigots out.
Also, I think people are freaking out a bit now because people have grown increasingly insistent upon controlling, filtering, and censoring the news and messages that they receive and allow into their own households. People are now used to being able to pick news channels, internet sites, and newspapers that support whichever political slant they happen to prefer, and they label any information that's coming in from a non-aligned source (meaning one not in keeping with their political preference) as fictitious propaganda that's merely designed as an attack on their way of thinking. All of this leads to situations where parents are, sadly, filling their kids' heads with stories about how awful Obama is (or anyone else who doesn't share their views) and about how he wants to ruin the country and take away the freedom of Americans and turn us into communists. These parents have indoctrinated and brainwashed their kids with these stories, and they really don't want that illusion being shattered when a calm, well-spoken, mild mannered African American president appears on a video screen and calmly and rationally encourages these kids to study harder and do better in school. (That doesn't look like the monster you told me about, Mom. Where are the horns? How about the forked tail?)
These parents are screaming about Obama's propaganda and indoctrination tactics, but, in truth, these parents just don't want to see their own indoctrination programs disrupted. They don't want their kids presented with any real information that might allow the kids to make up their own minds.
These parents can kick and whine and scream all they want about how viewing this speech shouldn't be mandatory, but Obama is the president of all American citizens, and I know that school kids are taught all kinds of things all of the time without being given the choice about what to selectively listen to. When I was in school during the 80's I must've had to sit through at least half a dozen pep rallies, lectures, and other "Just Say No" events about the dangers and risks of using drugs. As an adult, it's become pretty clear to me that those campaigns didn't really work, as drug use in the U.S. is still going as strong as ever (and now California and other states have started decriminalizing some drugs and started treating others as health care issues rather than simply as crimes). Anyway, I'm sure that there were some hippie parents who thought this was a waste of our time, but I don't remember any fuss over it. And anyway, what's the next step? Requiring schools to take down American flags so that parents who are annoyed with the government don't have to subject their children to the sight of them? Give me a break.
Anyway, students should be exposing themselves to a whole variety of different types of information and points of view and learning to assess these pieces of information and make judgments on their own. Teaching kids not to pay any attention to any person who might potentially have a contrary point of view is an absolutely terrible lesson of intolerance to be passing on to your kids.
This has been too long of a rant already, but this issue really tickes me off (mostly it reveals that Americans are raising their kids to be closed-minded, intolerant little wingnuts- initially I thought that these protests were isolated and overblown by the media, but when 3 districts in Central Texas shut down the president's speech because of this crap, I had to reevaluate).
I also had a bunch more to say about how I think that the whole Fox News/political-propaganda-as news-media phenomenon is really creating a sort of unique and awful social schism in this country (at a time when we really don't have that much to be fighting about in comparison to other times in history), but I'm going to let everyone off the hook on that one for now. ;-)
Sorry about the rant.
But I feel better.
Hug your kids.
Teach them to be open minded and respect other people (unless and until other people do something to disrespect them).
Peace.
No comments:
Post a Comment