There's a column in the Washington Post today by Hank Stuever called "The Trouble wiith Quibbles" which is probably worth reading. It uses the public's anticipation of and reaction to the new Star Trek movie as a vehicle to examine the current culture of pop culture consumerism and hyperanalysis.
The column makes some good points. Stuever asks questions about why our current generation of producers, directors, and writers seems incapable of producing new stories or ideas instead of just rehashing old shows or films (and why is that? This question could be a post unto itself. Now that we have so many of our works permanently preserved, is it just that hard to come up with a concept that hasn't already been well-executed previously?). He questions the current nature of film production in which fans constantly provide feedback on movies, generating vast amounts of criticism in dizzying detail about everything from casting choices to costumes to set design before a movie has ever been shown. Bloggers intensely scrutinize movies, analyzing them to the point of acceptance or rejection on the strength of trailers which only show a minute or two of a film.
Stuever also refers to the fact that modern fans seem to possess the ability to kill a movie in the womb- shouting down the very possibility of its success in online forums and/or conventions before a movie gets made.
Stuever sort of mentions all of these things as he builds up to his main thesis- the idea that original or imaginative material is unlikely to get made if moviemakers remain beholden to fans who fear the possibilities inherent in change. Good art, Stuever argues, can't get made in an environment where artists don't have room to independently struggle to come up with new ideas (and execute them).
I get it. I do. I even had some mild disagreements in advance of this Star Trek movie with friends who said that Abrams shouldn't even be attempting to make a Star Trek movie with the original characters in the cast (I argued at the time that some mild changes might be the only way to breathe some new life into the franchise).
All of this being said, I think that the sort of hypercritical audience subculture that's been created by these sorts of films (especially the constant remakes of nostalgic material) is sort of understandable.
For one thing, we're living in a generation whose childhood memories are constantly under fire from people who want to cash in on our nostalgia and fond rememberances, often in a very crass, exploitative way. For every Star Trek remake that's successful, there are a bunch of other Catwomans, Elektra Assassins, and Dukes of Hazzards that are poorly made and seem to have no greater aspiration than cashing in. In a sense, the hypercritical reactions of audiences are a sort of defense mechanism against producers and execs who have no problem exploiting all of this stuff and cranking out worthless versions of well-loved shows in order to make a quick buck. So the fans have, for some of this stuff, appointed themselves the guardians of their own cultural heritage (such as it is). I don't really blame them for that.
Do the fans take some of this stuff way too seriously? Probably, but then again, it takes a lot of passion about something to slow down the big, grinding money machine that is Hollywood.
Also, of course, the internet has created thousands of communities within communities related to this stuff. People talk and talk and argue and argue. Millions of voices all shouting into the blogosphere and various community forums.
And the way to distinguish yourself is to become a clever critic.
People do this in different ways. You have your critics who amass a tremendous amount of knowledge in a particular area, and your critics who focus on simply noticing and pointing out things that other people might overlook, not notice, or not care about. The best critics do both.
The point, though, is that in the age of the blog and the online publisher, criticism has sort of become a popular sport and a national pasttime. Hundreds of thousands (if not millions) of people have fashioned themselves critics of one kind or another (yup, here, too). Criticism is a way of turning passive viewing into an interactive activity. It demonstrates something other than couch potato status (at least it seems to), allowing people to celebrate the things that they love and voice their frustrations when things turn out to be a huge waste of time. Given a culture where so much of our time is spent passively staring at screens or listening to sounds come out of speakers, criticism is a way to remain active, alert, and engaged in a culture which would otherwise have us remain passive consumers (sort of like dollar-producing vegetables for our beloved captains of industry).
So I think the drive to become critics is understandable, too.
I guess the biggest surprise is that the movie industry is actually listening to some of our noise.
Anyway, Stuever's column is well written, makes good points about the need for aritistic freedom, and is definitely worth checking out. I'm just not sure that he had enough empathy for us quibblers.
2 comments:
I think you hit the nail on the head. Genre fiction has a long and grueling history of being treated poorly by the folks who stand to make millions from the project (often whether it succeeds or not).
As a Superman nut, I can personally attest to the horror that swept the Superman blogs and websites when Trek's own JJ Abrams was hired to re-write Superman with McG directing. The proposed script was so, so far off from anything recognizably Superman (although it would have been a potentially interesting sci-fi film) that the fan outrage killed the movie. Abrams said so himself during his round of interviews for Trek.
But... Abrams also learned a lesson about working with talent that understands the material and WHY its survived this long, as evidenced by his Trek. Whether McG learned or not we'll all see soon enough in Terminator.
For the fans, financial success is sort of beside the point, but we also know that it will help to get more of our favorite stuff on the big-screen. And, of course, we know that when the material receives the right treatment, we can wind up with The Dark Knight instead of, say, Catwoman.
And, hey, we're telling the studios (for free!) all the marketing research they really need. Columnists can make fun of it, but obviously people do care about this stuff. More so than about, say, columnists and their newspapers (that ain't a dig. That shit is real, yo.).
The irony of Hollywood is that you don't have to know your own product in order to make it. Its not like a manufacturing plant where you understand the product being developed from blue prints, etc... Its usually just some exec hoping their gamble pays off. And then you wind up with "League of Extraordinary Gentlemen" or (sob) "Watchmen". You could almost imagine the discussions in the boardroom around those two...
I agree. There's just got to be a balance in there, somewhere, I guess. I understand the desire to safeguard material that we feel nostalgic about, but at the same time, I think thtis guy has a point when he says that all of the criticism that's meant to preserve the sanctity of these works (so to speak) can be very stifling for people who are trying to put a new spin on things or be creative. On the other hand, the answer to that is probably to produce new material instead of continuing to remake everything that's already been done...
Post a Comment