Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Art and Belief, A Bit of Glee, Parental Rights Versus Medical Responsiblity

Hello! Hope all's well.
Last night Cassidy drove me over to Ryan and Jamie's for a really good chicken dinner (some people say that I shouldn't let my three legged dog drive me places, but in our defense, Cassidy really isn't hampered much by her missing front leg. My car, the Blue Bastard, is an automatic, and Cassidy doesn't seem to have much trouble working the turn signals, either. She's not good at parallel parking, but who is?). Anyway, Jamie made a good chicken dinner, and once again, my brother's lack of self control in the Central Market meats section has really worked to my benefit.
We also watched an episode of This American Life, a show which was originally a radio program on NPR, but which has developed into a television documentary series on Showtime as well. Ryan digs the show, and had ordered a DVD. It was good. The episode that we watched was about a Mormon artist in Salt Lake City, Utah, who was producing paintings depicting various Biblical scenes involving Jesus (the episode was titled God's Close Up, and it debuted April 5, 2007). The program went on to describe how this artist had been seeking out men with beards to use as models in recreating various scenes involving Jesus and his contemporaries, but how the general disapproval of the Mormon Church regarding the growth of facial hair had made it somewhat difficult to find appropriate male models. As a result, the artist making the paintings had been required to look outside the mainstream Mormon community for his subjects, and ended up making friends with a number of homeless people, drifters, and dropouts from the Mormon Church (and the larger Salt Lake City community in general) as he spent time with these people, gently persuading them to serve as models for his projects. Many of these people were atheists and agnostics- many of them having been raised in fairly strict religious households before rejecting their religious upbringing and leaving the church.
There was definitely an interesting dynamic created by this Mormon painter and his sort of outcast, rebellious subjects as they worked together to create works of art depicting Jesus.
As the documentary pointed out, it was hard to overlook the fact that Jesus and his disciples were, from a social and political standpoint at their particular point in history, much more akin to the sort of ragtag group of outsiders and wanderers who were working together to make these paintings as opposed to resembling the powerful, wealthy, well-connected group which now represents the Church of Latter Day Saints and/or many other large, well-established churches. The work on the paintings sort of gave the believers and the nonbelievers some common ground and a reason to talk about the similarities and the differences in their points of view.
Anyway, it was a good show.
We also watched part of the first episode of Fox's new sitcom about high school musical productions called Glee. We only saw part of it because somehow Team Steans had a recording failure with their DVR, but it seemed pretty funny. As I told Ryan, though, this show seems to be walking a sort of fine line, and if it starts steering away from the comedy and more into plotlines where it expects me to become invested in these high school glee club characters, I'm gonna pull the plug. I can handle comedy from a show about the glee club, but I'm definitely not down for a soap opera style show about a bunch of high school kids and all of the drama that's not really drama that such stories involve. I know some other people dig that sort of thing, but for me Glee is in a funny or die type of situation.

In the news, a mother and her son have gone into hiding following a court order from a judge that the boy, Daniel Hauser, receive chemotherapy treatment. The boy's mother, Colleen Hauser, has insisted upon treating her son with exclusively homeopathic methods and alternative medicine, and the boy recently appeared in court and told the judge that he believed the chemotherapy would kill him. According to the report I heard on CNN last night, however, doctors have said that there was an 80% to 90% chance that the boy could be effectively treated with proper chemotherapy, but probably only a 5% chance that he would survive without such treatment. The Minnesota judge who heard the case ordered the boy into treatment, stating that the boy's status as a minor, coupled with the fact that the boy was basically unable to read or write (the reasons for this are unclear), suggested that the boy didn't fully understand the benefits and risks of chemotherapy treatment or the ramifications of his decision. The boy's dad was apparently swayed by the reasoning of the judge. The mom took the kid and ran.
It's a troubling case, but I tend to come down with the judge. From what I understand, legal precedent in these sorts of cases requires treatment for minors whenever it stands a reasonable chance of actually helping, and the failure to provide such treatment constitutes neglect. From a less legalistic, more ethical standpoint, I don't really see much difference between the current situation and one where a child is injured in some kind of serious accident, but the parents try to obstruct EMTs or other medical personnel from providing medical aid.
I'm not really against alternative, holistic medicine as a supplement to more traditional medical treatment, but when a course of treatment is available which has been proven to be largely effective, I think it's negligent to allow parents to refuse traditional treatments for their children in favor of stubborn, exclusive reliance upon methods which have not been shown to be nearly as effective.
There's a whole other topic tied up in this that deals with a significant movement (maybe even a subculture) in American society- a movement which rejects scientific testing and methodology in favor of anecdotal evidence, distrust of mainstream science, and an almost religious dedication to the belief that alternative remedies are inherently preferrable to more widely accepted scientific and medical practices.
To be honest, I don't get it. I wish I could think of a way to put this a little more gently, but I think that part of the issue springs from a lack of understanding of basic scientific principles. I'm a lawyer by trade and a philosopher by way of educational background (and a wanna-be musician by way of casual aspiration), but I had enough biology, chemistry, and anatomy in high school and college to have a decent, fundamental grasp of how the body works and what scientists are up to when they formulate different medications or establish treatment regimens. I also had enough science classes to understand the scientific method and to understand how experimental trials and testing work.
Anyway, for the most part I understand how stuff in the body works well enough to understand what doctors are saying when they tell me about how drugs work and about how different treatments are going to effect my body (e.g., how diuretics work, how serotonin reuptake inhibitors work, how opiates and other painkillers work, etc.). The cause and effect relationships between what the doctors are doing and how their treatments effect my body don't seem that mysterious (up to a point, anyway). There may be side effects or some unintended consequences, but I understand that these things are somewhat predictable, and can usually be dealt with.
But I think that modern medicine is much scarier, mysterious, and more intimidating to a lot of people (and, to be honest, I really don't like going to the doctor at all, myself, because I usually think that they sort of overpromise on the results that they can deliver, and because, frankly, when I go to the doctor I start thinking of the million other things that can go wrong with me while I'm there. There's something about going to the doctor which sort of forces me to think about my body, my own mortality, and the fact that even if I'm currently pretty healthy and trying to take care of myself, inevitably the machine which is my body is going to wear out. I'm not sure why going to the doctor takes me down this path of thinking, but it often does). Doctors offices and hospitals can often seem very cold and impersonal, and far too often people don't really understand how their medications work or what those medications are doing to their bodies. Alternative medicine has sort of cornered the market on feel-good, warm and fuzzy treatment, but they've sort of gotten away with that, at least to some extent, because they're not held to the same level of accountability as traditional medicine.
By relying on nutritional and herbal supplements, aromatherapies, meditation, and other treatment methods which don't fall under the same sort of scrutiny that pharmaceutical medications involve, purveyors of alternative treatments are able to "promise" health benefits and positive results which have not been proven through the same sort of clinical trials and scientific testing that more heavily regulated medications have to go through. Most alternative treatments don't really have a risk of being harmful- they're approved as safe through food and nutritional regulations- but the public doesn't really have any true assurances that many of these products actually produce the effects which they claim to bring about. Some of the products make claims which sound like they're based on real science (and many of them really are based on legitimate science), but often the benefits being produced by the products are exaggerated (and, sadly, sometimes all but fabricated entirely). In the hands of some companies which produce herbal and nutritional remedies, scientific knowledge gets the spin doctor treatment in its use as a selling tool. Products which may have small, incremental benefits meant to increase overall health over the long term are sometimes recommended for use in treating acute symptoms, products which may have one specific benefit in strengthening one part or the body may be purported to have benefits in other, unlikely ways, and dramatic results are frequently promised for products which may only create subtle changes, if any.
But many of these products seem better than prescription medications or traditional treatments. The people who market them explain how they work in simple, easy to understand terms, and consumers are convinced that the "all natural" or "holisitic" brand items must inherently be better for them and more effective that their traditional counterparts. The fact that most of these products have few, if any side effects is held up as proof of these claims.
Side effects, however, are often the result of products that actually work effectively, making relatively dramatic changes within the body. I'm not saying that side effects don't suck(because some of them definitely can be very negative), but I will say that side effects are often present because drugs are powerful and because they're actually producing some kind of results.
For some conditions there's nothing wrong with sticking to an entirely holistic approach. Many holistic and/or alternative treatments really do have positive benefits, both as a result of the products and as a result of placebo effects (and I'm not trying to be snarky by saying this- placebo effects can produce real, measurable benefits that can sometimes legitimately contribute significantly to a person's health).
To the extent, however, that a child is dying and there's an established, proven treatment protocol which can save the kid's life, I still say you've got to give traditional science a chance to work. To refuse tested, effective treatment methods in such a case is to engage in ideological fanaticism and zealotry at the probable expense of a child's life, and it just seems wrong. The parents shouldn't be allowed to sacrifice their own child in order to justify their belief system (remember Obama's views on the importance of doubt from his Notre Dame speech over the weekend? I think those ideas are very pertinent here), and a kid who's grown up in a household that has indoctrinated him in that kind of viewpoint just can't be trusted yet to make a rational, informed decision.
Allow the parents to continue to provide alternative treatments for their child, but don't deprive the kid of more mainstream treatment options which have already been shown to be effective.
I guess that's what I'm saying.
Well, I need to run, but I hope ya'll are having a good day!
Peace.

3 comments:

Sara B. said...

At least Cassidy can reach the steering wheel.

J.S. said...

Well, yeah. You don't think I'd let my dog drive if she couldn't reach the steering wheel, do you? That would be ridiculous.

mcsteans said...

Yeah, I've had more than a few people upon them learning of my medical troubles ask if I've tried holistic medicine. Yeah.....my kidneys don't work. You let me know when they can grow a plant that will jump start an organ.

I do feel really bad for that kid, though. I'm with the judge all the way on this one.