A quick second post. So the Obama administration has now reversed itself on its earlier promise to release photos which showed abuse suffered by enemy captives while they were held in U.S. custody. The White House said that the photos could potentially inflame anti-American sentiment, ultimately leading to more danger for U.S. troops and making it more difficult to accomplish our ongoing missions in Iraq and Afghanistan.
Booo!!!!
So much for all of these promises of transparency by our new administration.
My gut reaction to this reversal of policy is, "Geez, those pictures must be a lot worse than anyone expected." And that ain't good.
In the middle of a heated public discussion (okay, argument) about the merits of torture (how is that for a fun phrase? "Merits of torture". We live in interesting times) versus its criminality, and in the middle of a slow, steady process in which the Obama administration seems to be trying to reestablish greater trust with other nations and between the federal government and the American people, it seems like a bad idea to suddenly say that we can't release evidence of some very bad things that American forces have done because it might upset a lot of people. In fact, (and it really pains me to say this) that sort of thing sounds a whole lot like someof the milder B.S. that we used to get from the Bush administration.
If our government is going to be committing some really nasty acts in the name of defending the American people, than the people have a right to know what sort of actions the goverment is taking on their behalf. We can't accurately gauge whether or not we want something done in the name of "protecting" us when we're not allowed to really even find out what's really going on.
I guess there may be a point to make in saying that the behavior depicted in these photos is now clearly prohibited and that the photos don't really need to be seen by the public in order to further debate about the treatment of prisoners (since this behavior has now apparently been declared illegal in unequivocal terms). On the other hand, these abusive acts have been declared illegal for now, but the next time a hardline conservative occupies the White House the policies regarding treatment of prisoners could once again quickly swing back in the direction of the abusive. It might be good to have these photos in the public record in order to remind people what our country is getting itself into before we launch into a bunch of torture and abuse the next time around.
Basically, if the White House thinks that these photos are so bad that we can't even release them to the public, I think we should be pursuing charges against everyone (right up the chain of command) involved in the situation and the activities shown in those pictures. If these photos depict activities which are so shameful and inflammatory that they can't be shown publicly, then the people involved in the photographed abuse (and those who allowed it to happen) need to be vigorously prosecuted.
Anyway, that's my take on the whole thing.
Obama, you gotta quit letting them push you around on these national defense issues.
No comments:
Post a Comment