Hi.
Well, not too much to report. I took Cassidy to the vet yesterday (just a checkup and vaccinations) and Jamie made chicken fajita tacos last night for dinner. Bueno!
I read in article in Newsweek last night about a new movement among mentally ill patients to reject psychotropic medications and to try to learn to live with their symptoms and accept them as an intrinsic part of their lives and their identities. Members of the movement refer to it as "Mad Pride", and seem to sort of see their mental illness as a different way of perceiving and responding to the world rather than simply as a disability. They accept the pain and discomfort that comes along with their illnesses as being part of their personality and their identity, and try to celebrate some of the better feelings and insight that they think they gain through their symptoms (for instance, people with bipolar disorder may suffer emotionally during periods of depression, but enjoy feeling sort of "high" during their manic phases. People with schizophrenia may sometimes feel scared by their hallucinations or be plagued by feelings of paranoia, but they may feel like some of their hallucinations may lead to insights which border on the spiritual) .
I'm really not sure how to feel about this.
My job, for those of you who don't know, is working as a mental health prosecutor for the Travis County Attorney's Office. Part of what I do is look at cases and make recommendations in terms of sentencing and/or treatment options on misdemeanor mental health cases. Lacking formal training in psychiatry or psychology (I finished all my classes to get a minor in psychology at Trinity, but never even declared it), I work with mental health social workers and counsellors, deal with specialized defenses attorneys and judges, and get reports from psychiatrists and psychologists about the diagnosis and prognosis for defendants who are on my docket. We deal with a lot of sick people whose problems range from mild inconveniences up to people who are completely debilitated. Every once in a while we get someone who is engaging in really alarming, dangerous behavior (although I would say that's definitely the relatively rare exception and not the rule). Most of our cases, though, involve sort of nuisance crimes which end up being kind of alarming and/or annoying to people in the community (we get a lot of criminal trespass, minor shoplifting, etc., but also some assaults, terroristic threats, and other things which need to be taken a bit more seriously). I spend a fair amount of time in my job trying to figure out correct sentencing and treatment options which take into account: the safety and well-being of the genaral community, the appropriateness of treatment versus punitive criminal punishment, and the well being of the defendant, victims, and other interested parties (sometimes caseworkers or families of the accused).
Anyway, in my job it hasn't taken long to notice that we see an awful lot of the same people over and over. Part of the reason the mental health docket was created was to try to cut down on the recidivism patterns which keep mentally ill people cycling through the system over and over, but with a number of these people, we're fighting an uphill battle.
Part of the reason for the difficulty in keeping people out of the system (not the only reason, but part of the reason) is medication compliance. Many people with mental illnesses don't like taking their medications. Lots of the meds have side effects (everything from making people feel numb and "less alive" to more physical problems). Also, many times people with mental illness just don't like (and have a hard time accepting) the fact that they have a mental illness at all. "
They feel that there's a stigma attached to mental illness, and they don't like the idea of receiving a diagnosis involving symptoms that they're going to be struggling with for most of their lives. They come into the criminal justice system and they get stabilized with meds (helping to drastically clear up their symptoms), but once they're feeling better (i.e., more "normal") because of the medication, they sort of forget what got them into the situation in the first place, begin to feel like they're really not sick, and feel like they never needed meds in the first place. They quit taking their medications, fall back into behavior patterns that get them arrested, and the whole cycle starts all over again.
Not all people with mental illness fall into this cycle, but often these are the type of folks that I deal with who have been in jail. It's important to keep in mind that I'm pretty much only seeing people whose mental illness has contributed to behavior which has gotten them arrested. I don't really work with the mentally ill population as a whole, and there may be an entire population of people out there who are fully capable of going off their meds and living their lives in a relatively normal, nondisruptive way. There probably is a population that's like that.
But the people that I see on a regular basis just don't seem like they would be well served by the sort of doctrines being advocated by the "Mad Pride" movement.
Typically the sorts of behaviors that I'm seeing in people who go off their meds ends up being either harmful to the person with the illness or harmful and/or alarming to the people around them (and this often ends up causing a fair amount of disruption within the community). Of course, I recognize the fact that I'm mostly just seeing people who have demonstrated an inability to follow the rules of their community, and these people are not necessarily representative of the mentally ill population as a whole.
The problem, however, is that the message being sent by "Mad Pride" isn't going to just be received by people who can actually function well without their medications. The message might be reached by some people who can function pretty well without their medications, but it's going to reach some people who can't, and people from both groups are just as likely to take "Mad Pride's" message to heart. Plenty of people who can't really control their behavior or function normally within society are also going to be hearing this message about the desirability of refusing medication, and this really has the potential of contributing to situations where mentally ill people are posing a danger to themselves or others or significantly disturbing the lives of large numbers of people around them (some people with illnesses may not really be hurting anyone, per se, but when people spend their time wandering around the neighborhood naked or sitting on their roof all night and loudly howling at the moon, the situation still seems like more than the reighbors can be reasonably expected to accomodate).
To some extent I think the "Mad Pride" movement is a fairly predictable reaction to mental illness by a group of people who want to feel "normal" and who dislike the stigma of being diagnosed and classified as suffering from mental illness. Grouping together with likeminded individuals and resisting the constraints of societal expectations is pretty normal and probably even pretty healthy on some level.
On the other hand, if someone is suffering needlessly (really, really depressed, for example) or engaging in behavior that's harmful to themself or someone else, it doesn't seem like it really improves the situation to make a political cause out of refusing medication. I'm extremely sympathetic with people who suffer from mental illness (as well as the family and friends of ill people who are also affected) and there's no doubt that the whole thing is terribly unfair (most serious illnesses of any kind seem unfair to me), but I'm not sure that rejecting medical treatment is the appropriate answer. I'm also sympathetic to the idea that we shouldn't just be medicating people in order to make it easier for other people to deal with mentally ill people. If a person is really causing no risk or harm to others but is simply engaging in some unusual or strange behavior, there may not be a need for that person to be on meds. I think we should be very wary of trampling on the rights of mentally ill people simply toward the end of making it easier for the rest of society to "deal with" these people. On the other hand, I really do think that most mental health providers are genuinely trying to help the people that they're treating- not just doping them up in order to make life easier for the people around them.
Also, another side of the argument is that if mentally ill people want as much freedom as possible and want to to lead independent, autonomous lives, they need to take on the responsibility of taking care of themselves and managing their symptoms so that they don't interfere with the rights of the people around them. Sometimes this may require medication. (It's interesting to note that in this Newsweek article, even Will Hall, a member of "Mad Pride", refers to the various mental illnesses of its members as "dangerous gifts". It seems that even the paitents who are advocating freedom from medication are acknowledging that some psychiatric conditions can be quite harmful if left untreated.)
Mental illness, medication, and the need to balance the rights of the ill against the rights of citizens within the community all pose very interesting and tough questions from an ethical and legal perspective. Personally, I think that questions regarding mental illness and moral and legal culpability are going to be some of the key issues that the entire criminal justice system is going to be grappling with over the next several decades. I don't mean to head down a road where we aboslve people of any personal responsibility and label every act of criminal behavior as an illness, but people (including judges, lawyers, and the police) are becoming more and more aware of mental health issues as each year passes, and the mental health field (once viewed with skepticism as a sort of enterprise primarily concerned with excuse-making and false justification by some within the legal system) is beginning to intersect with the world of criminal justice in ever-increasing numbers of cases and in increasingly profound ways. More and more people have a greater understanding of psychiatry, having had personal experiences with doctors and medications or by having watched loved ones go through such experiences, and people are slowly coming to understand the power of medications and therapy in alleviating psychiatric symptoms and helping to get people's lives back on track. Even for cynics and skeptics it's pretty remarkable to see a person unable to communicate or form coherent thoughts one day, but see them get on medication and then carry on normal, intelligent, cordial conversations a week later. Pretty remarkable.
Anyway, I don't know what to think of all of this stuff (meaning the medication and personal rights issues brought up in the article), but it's interesting and important and definitely a conversation worth having.
That's about all that I have today. I hope I didn't bore you guys too much with this stuff, but I find it pretty interesting.
Have a good one!!!
No comments:
Post a Comment