Friday, April 17, 2009

So what's up?
Not much to report from the home front. Sadly, Mr. Roboto, one of my two new goldfish, died yesterday. I guess he didn't adjust to life in his new home very well (or heck- maybe he was already sick or something when I took him home from the pet store- who knows?). So via con dios, Mr. Roboto. Hope you find yourself in that giant goldfish pond in the sky.
What else? The Obama administration released CIA memos yesterday that detailed some of the extreme interrogation/torture methods used by U.S. intelligence services while prosecuting the war on terror under the Bush administration. The release of the documents was immediately criticized by former Bush administration officials who claimed that the release of such documents would have a chilling effect on future intelligence gathering efforts and embolden America's enemies. Groups such as the ACLU and Amnesty International applauded the release of such information and demanded prosecution of intelligence operatives who participated in the use of interrogation techniques described in the memos.
To be honest, I'm not happy about all of the interrogation techniques outlined in the memo, but I guess things could have been worse. Most of the techniques involved psychological coercion and physical discomfort, but they didn't rise to a level where actual, lasting physical harm was being done (many of the techniques involved stress positions, isolation, and things like embarrassing nudity, but they also got a bit more disturbing with waterboarding, physical striking and slapping, and even, in one case, the use of scary looking insects to terrify one prisoner who was known to have a phobia of such things. Most of the techniques, however, had been used at one point or another on U.S. troops while training them in interrogation resistance techniques.). At any rate, the actions listed in the memo didn't involve cutting, burning, electric shocks, or many other things which might cause serious bodily injury, so things weren't as bad as what I had feared, frankly. At least officially.
But that's part of what still bothers me. There's a very real slippery slope problem, and the intelligence community being the secret, shadowy world that it is, I'm inclined to believe that for every action that we hear about, there are probably a bunch more, possibly more extreme, that never reach the public eye. And the more things that you make legally permissible, i.e., the farther the boundaries extend in terms of what we consider acceptable conduct, the farther intelligence operatives are probably inclined to go when conducting the sorts of activities that aren't going to ever make it into memos. (e.g., if we say, you can't torture at all, operatives might go ahead and secretly proceed with the sorts of activities detailed in these memos. Once they're given sanction to perform the actions listed in these memos, I think they're likely to secretly take things one step further, knowing that they're not straying too far beyond what is already permitted).
Other things that bother me include, of course, the simple use of any sort of torture techniques at all. I say this because I just think it's morally wrong to inflict suffering on people in order to gain information and because I think that the use of any sort of "extreme interrogation techniques" by the U.S. opens the door for more widespread use of all kinds of torture techniques worldwide, including on captured American troops A lot of countries aren't going to be splitting hairs in deciding one kind of torture is "acceptable" while other kinds are not. I think that from a standpoint of international law, once torture is deemed permissible, all bets are off.
I've also read time and again that torture is typically an extremely unreliable, inefficient way of gaining information. It typically doesn't make people tell you the truth- it just makes them say what they think you want to hear.
Anyway, I don't want to rehash my old "torture is bad" arguments, but I did sort of find the info in these memos interesting. I don't think that releasing these memos to the public is going to endanger America (we're letting America's enemies know that we can't keep a secret? Please! This country has more "national security secrets" than you can shake a stick at, and some of this stuff has been secret for decades.)
I think that maybe the people involved with this torture stuff should be bitching a lot less about the memos being released and be thanking Obama a lot more for refusing to allow the torturers to be prosecuted for war crimes under the Geneva Convention. Gotta admit, though, that I'm a little relieved to see that we weren't officially endorsing actions which would have caused serious bodily injury. Of course, I guess when we really felt a need to get into the real nasty stuff, maybe that's when we set up one of these rendition operations to remove our enemies to a foreign country where there might be a little less oversight (meaning you can get away with a lot more in terms of torture)? Ugggghhh.....

And has everyone heard about this new book which reimagines Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice? The new book, entitled Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, is a retelling of the classic Jane Austen novel, supposedly with up to 80% of the book including text from the original novel, but with attacking zombie hordes and Shaolin martial arts training incorporated as a pertinent background trait on the part of the Bennett sisters.
I gotta say, I've actually read Pride and Prejudice (it was part of a "favorite book" exchange with my friend Jennifer. I managed to read all of Pride and Prejudice before realizing that she hadn't even cracked open my copy of Frank Herbert's Dune and would probably never do so). And I would think that Pride and Prejudice can be nothing but benefited by the addition of zombie hordes. The characters of Pride and Prejudice can be put out of sorts by a minor turn of phrase or shift in a person's attention, so the idea of watching them deal with zombie attacks is sort of fascinating. Plus, the dramatic tension involved in surviving zombie attacks is something I can see myself getting into a lot easier than worries about whether some young woman is managing to efficiently navigate societal norms and find herself the right man. Is there anything that can't be made better by zombies? (Well, in the interest of full disclosure, I have a small zombie movie collection at my house, and I'm sort of a fan of zombie movies in general. One of the best moviegoing experiences of my life was an Alamo Drafthouse Rolling Roadshow out in Pflugerville with Jeff "Crackbass" Wilson and my friend "Jackbart" Mitchell where we sat in lawn chairs out in a field beside an abandoned farmhouse and watched Night of the Living Dead with George Romero in attendance. I tried to get Romero's autograph, but he got tired and took off when I was about two people away from him in line.)
So I need to read the book (although I have to admit- I'm not sure I'm ready reread up to 80% of the original Pride and Prejudice).
Anyway, I don't have much else.
I'm not sure if I'll post more or not, but if not, ya'll have a nice weekend!!

7 comments:

The League said...

Adios, Mr. Roboto. May you swim free on the endless currents of the ether, forever finding yourself in a path of the best niblets of fish food.

Domo arigato. You have brought much into our lives. Domo.

The Pope said...

Sorry to hear about Mr.Roboto.
Wife's cat, Murray, died last week. We found her curled up on the bed. Dead. Guess that's a good way to go.

There are many other pieces of literature which would do well to incorporate zombies, ninjas, and/or pirates. I think any Dickens novel would benefit greatly. Great Zombie Expectations and A Tale Of Two Undead Cities jump to mind.

How about Where the Red Fern Grows? Little Ann and Old Dan return from the grave as dog-zombies.

And Steans, have you EVER met a girl who has read Dune? Really?

J.S. said...

Well, I have to admit that the Dune thing was a long shot, but for god's sake I spent some of my own free time reading Pride and Prejudice! We had a deal!!! (plus, I think the irony is that she would have liked Dune. One of her favorite movies is Scarface, and how often do you find women digging that?)
Dune is rad.
"Fear is the little-death.
Fear is the mind killer..."

mcsteans said...

Nooooooooo!! Not Mr. Roboto!

For the record, I have not read Dune, but it sounds awesome. I would love to read it.

J.S. said...

Yeah, Dune is pretty awesome. It involves giant worms, women with mind control powers (I know, I know, ALL women have mind control powers), indigenous tribal people who have learned to use sound as a weapon, psychedelic spice which allows for the bending of the space/time continuum (which allows travel between star systems- the spice and the battles to control it serve as a sort of metaphor for oil), and feudalistic, aristocratic families who derisively sneer at the chaos of democracy. Take all of this, throw in some Machiavellian political intrigue and soem very memorable characters, and you have a pretty interesting read.

Sara B. said...

Fish (and hermit crabs) die when you look at them funny. I have not read Dune, either. American Psycho, but not Dune. Should I put that on my list of things to read?

J.S. said...

Well, American Psycho is a book most women wouldn't want to read (as a matter of fact, if memory serves, at least one feminist group tried to boycott the publisher after it was released).
And Dune is a great book. It's kind of hard to get into at the very beginning because it has sort of stylized language and makes you learn about a bunch of crazy Dune universe stuff by inference, but it's a great book.
And goldfish do die very easily it seems. The funny thing is that at the pet store it says "one of our heartier fish" by the goldfish tank.