Hello.
Went over to Jamie and Ryan's last night for dinner. Jamie grilled some chicken and some corn. Good stuff.
I know that this might surprise some people, but I heard Sarah Palin give a speech on TV last night, and she really got me thinking about a few things. Even though her policy stances don't always come off as well polished as Obama's, when you listen to her you really get the feeling that she understands everyday people, has a good heart, and truly wants to lead the country in the right direction. I'm going to have to rethink some things between now and the midterm elections.
Happy April Fool's Day, everybody! (I know- I didn't actually fool anyone, did I?)
Oookay....
It looks like the case against Senator Ted Stevens is going to be dropped because of prosecutorial misconduct on the part of the Justice Department and the FBI. Nice.
I am so freakin' annoyed by this. My foremost complaint is with the prosecutors who broke the law in prosecuting the case (how many times do things like this have to happen before prosecutors are going to learn?), but I'm just about equally annoyed with the fact that Stevens and his cronies will now try to spin this as a message from the court system that Stevens has done nothing wrong and is totally innocent.
What happened here is that the prosecutors involved in this case got overzealous and broke ethical rules that violated the law while obtaining a conviction against Stevens. The man may or may not be guilty of the corruption charges he was facing (I personally tend to think that he's guilty, but my opinion is really neither here nor there), but the charges are dropped because the people who were trying to put him in prison broke the rules- not necessarily because there was no evidence against Stevens or because the Justice Department suddenly decided that Stevens wasn't guilty.
In fact, I think that prosecutors tend to get themselves in trouble and violate the rules when they feel extremely convinced that a person is, in fact, guilty, but when they are having evidentiary or procedural problems in convicting that person. The more intelligent and politically powerful the defendant is, the harder it often is to convict because more powerful defendants can typically afford more skillful lawyers and because more well educated, intelligent defendants tend to know more about the law and are better at personally covering their tracks than your average thug on the street. Knowing that someone is guilty- sometimes because you have facts at hand that are inadmissible as evidence in court for one reason or another- while being unable to effectively prosecute that person can be extremely frustrating for prosecutors, and it's that frustration which often leads to the sort of reckless, irresponsible behavior that apparently occurred in this case (i.e., hiding evidence from defense counsel- a big no no- and apparently even fabricating or altering some evidence- an even bigger no no).
I'm also annoyed with the Justice Department's decision to drop the case because of potential embarrassment over their own screw up. We all know that the Justice Department made a big mistake while prosecuting this case, but the jury did, after all, convict, and it doesn't seem like too big a stretch to imagine that they might convict a second time, even if some new evidence is produced which might be used by the defense to argue for innocence. Embarrassment on the part of the Justice Department doesn't negate their obligation to pursue justice when the law is broken, and I still haven't heard anything that makes me think Stevens isn't guilty of corruption. In fact, continuing to prosecute Stevens aggressively at this point might be the only way to save a little face after this debacle. Without further prosecution, Stevens is just going to go down in history as another corrupt insider who proved to the world that he was above the law.
Well, one more black eye for the Justice Department under the era of the Bush administration (they already had all of those problems caused by illegal hiring practices in which job candidates were selected for their conservative political beliefs). Arrgh.
I don't have much else. Hope everyone is having a foolish April 1st!!
5 comments:
I almost put on my Facebook status today that I was coming around and even bought myself an Obamican t-shirt....lol...but couldn't stand to even joke about it! Your Palin crack was a funny one....on the same page today. LOL! Have a good one!
Good to hear from you, Meredith! Hope things are going well with the kiddos!
Has it been too long since I've prosecuted and forgotten criminal law or isn't there a possible problem of double jeopardy for the Stevens case. The Justice Dept might not get a second chance to do it right?
Killer Kraber
Well, yeah, there would probably be double jeopardy problems with starting the thing entirely over (I really have no idea what happens when prosecutorial misconduct is involved), but this case wasn't even really thrown out or overturned. A number of hearings were still scheduled to see how the state was going to proceed given the allegations of prosecutorial misconduct, but instead of fighting to uphold the conviction or to retry it or whatever had to be done, the Justice Department just threw in the towel and said that they were no longer going to pursue the case (in order to avoid further embarrassment, according to sources). I probably misspoke when I was discussing the case procedurally, but my beef is with the Justice Department for dropping the prosecution just because they were emabrrassed by their own screw ups. You're embarrassed? Tough sh*t. You still have a job to do and an obligation to do it to the best of your ability.
Anyway, that was my main point, but there might be some double jeopardy issues. I'm really not sure given the fact that there had already been a conviction and the case hadn't been thrown out of court or anything.
Also, I'll admit that I don't really know the law surrounding cases involving prosecutorial misconduct, but Attorney General Eric Holder said in his public statement that he had decided not to seek a new trial in the Stevens case. I'm not sure how likely it would have been that the government would have gotten a new trial, anyway, but his statement seems to indicate that a new trial was at least a possibility (and one that, personally, I think should have neen pursued if it was at all possible).
Post a Comment