Monday, April 20, 2009

Weekend Update, Movie Reviews, Some Ponderings on Columbine, and Get Well Stephen Hawking

Hey there. The weekend was pretty good.
Friday night I had Crack practice with Sigmund and Andy. It was a good practice. I played banjo, bass, and a little bit of guitar. We mixed things up a little, and we got some different, interesting sounding stuff as a result. Anyhoo, we did a pretty good job of working together and listening to each other and riding the Crackwave. It always feels good.
Saturday I went to see a matinee showing of State of Play over at the Drafthouse with Team Steans. It was pretty good. It's about a newspaper reporter (played by Russell Crower) who is friends with a U.S. Congressman (Ben Affleck), and it involves lots of political intrigue and courageous journalistic tomfoolery.
It's a pretty good story, sort of squarely rooted in the subgenre of classic reporter movies (like All the President's Men, Broadcast News, Salvador, Citizen Kane, The Killing Fields, The Wire, and even, more recently, Frost/Nixon). State of Play may not be the best reporter movie of all time (once I started typing up that list, I started to realize there are some good movies in there), but it's got a pretty well-executed, tight plot (although the plot twists ran the risk of feeling a little contrived at times), some interesting characters, and some pretty good acting (it's probably not cool to say this since he's so popular in the mainstream and can seem like a bit of a jerk in interviews, but Russell Crowe is a pretty solid actor). Anyway, I would probably recommend State of Play to most people. It's not exactly groundbreaking, but it was a fairly intelligent, entertaining movie.
Saturday night I went over to Mandy's place to join her and some friends for dinner. It was really nice. Good food, and it was good to just see everyone and hang out.
Lazy Sunday. Read a book in the backyard, and took Cassidy to the dog park. Watched In the Valley of Elah on cable. It was good, but depressing. It's about a father (played by Tommy Lee Jones) who's investigating the death of his son, a soldier who has recently returned from Iraq. The movie has themes about post traumatic stress disorder and about the difficulties that some Iraq veterans have upon returning to the States (I've been hearing about these sorts of issues a lot at work lately because of a veterans support/advocacy group I've been working with), and it was mostly a pretty well written and well acted film. I would guess that most people's immediate reaction to the movie would be to say that it was an anti-war film, and while that may be true to some extent, I think it was really more about the neglect that some of our veterans are suffering in terms of having their traumatic mental injuries and adjustment disorders diagnosed and treated. The movie doesn't spend much time dwelling specifically on whether the Iraq War itself is worth fighting (it sort of takes a grunt's eye view of seeing the whole enterprise as "protecting Americans"). The film keeps the scope of its criticism squarely focused upon the effects of the war upon our returning soldiers (there's one scene where an Iraqi is being tortured, but the scene appears to be placed in the film with the intention of showing the dehumanizing effects of war on our troops rather than as a reflection upon the suffering that we were inflicting upon the Iraqis). At any rate, the effects of the war upon the film's returning soldiers are so devastating that you ultimately end up questioning whether the war is really worth the cost, but this question seems to be addressed pretty broadly, without taking particular issue with the Iraq War over any other particular conflict.
So, I guess, in one sense, this is an anti war movie. I don't know. It seemed like a sort of anti war movie that might appeal to a red state crowd (because the anti-war message of the film stems out of the harm that we're inflicting on our own troops instead of arising out of sympathy for the Iraqis or out of outrage toward the leaders who are making our policy decisions).
So it's not a bad movie, but it's not very happy go lucky.
And then last night I had dinner with Ryan and Jamie and hung out with them a bit.

There's an opinion column by Bob Greene on CNN's site today about the tenth anniversary of the Columbine killings and the effect that those killings have had upon the country. In his piece Greene touches upon the notion that almost our whole country seems to be suffering from some version of combat fatigue or post traumatic stress disorder or something of the kind. From a technical, clinical standpoint that wouldn't be correct. Post traumatic stress disorder, from what I understand, requires a person to personally witness or experience some severely traumatic event as a prerequisite to being diagnosed with the condition. Nonetheless, in this era of 24 hour news cycles, real time news coverage, live video feeds, real time reporting, and ubiquitous media coverage of almost every calamitous event that strikes the country, it may almost seem and feel to many people like they're actually personally witnessing many of the tragic events in the media as they unfold. We may not be experiencing true PTSD by watching all of these awful things occur (we're not actually there and we mostly don't really know the people involved), but the news coverage can make us feel like we're there, and there are a lot of these events for people to digest. Just off the top of my head, in relatively recent memory (since the time of Columbine, at any rate) we've had 9/11, Katrina, the Virginia Tech massacre, The Washington D.C. beltway sniper attacks, a whole host of awful events from Iraq (including beheadings and suicide bombings), the shooting rampage at the civic center in New York, a shooting spree at a church in Colorado, and so on and so forth in an almost endless procession of interminable coverage (and this doesn't count the international horror stories that also get coverage- things like the Madrid train bombings or the Mumbai terrorist attack). It may not be true PTSD, but then again I'd say that Greene may not be too far off the mark when he says that our entire country is slowly developing something akin to battle fatigue- a media induced version of the thousand yard stare that we used to primarily see in our combat veterans.
And I have to ask what the point is in covering all of this violence. The short answer, of course, is ratings. As desensitizing and as damaging as it may be to our psyches, people just can't seem to turn away from coverage of a disaster. I'm not sure why this occurs. Maybe the instinct goes back to the way that our minds evolved. It seems plausible that our minds would be naturally attuned to pay attention to danger, since that sort of thing would help us to survive, right? I hate to chalk to the whole thing up to schadenfreude because that seems to paint an especially bleak view of human nature and because, admittedly, I find myself often getting drawn into coverage of these awful events, but I honestly don't think I get any pleasure out of seeing people go through the tragedies. I just sort of watch and feel disturbed and fascinated at the same time.
Anyway, this is not really a new point that I'm making, but it seems almost nonsensical to expose people (often in excruciating detail) to every tragic event which occurs across the country (and the world). Most of the victims are people we don't know, and, sadly, human tragedy is the sort of thing that's going to remain with us for a long time, and is typically something which the average person can't really do anything about (Greene touches upon this "tragedy is nothing new" point in his column, reciting the story of a man who blew up a Michigan school and killed 44 people in 1927). There's an argument, I suppose, that media coverage of these shooting massacres might change people's attitudes on gun control or something, but I think that in truth people watch the coverage and just get sort of numb or desensitized to the violence. Most of the people who support gun rights see firearms as a way to protect themselves, so the same stories that drive gun control proponents to want to limit guns often produce an even greater conviction in the wisdom of owning firearms among gun rights supporters.
Anyway, my basic point is that I really do believe that some sort of psychological toll is starting to be exacted from the American people as they absorb and try to process the endless, pervasive media coverage of violence and tragedy. I'm not sure what should be done about it, and I'm not sure how much really can be done. Maybe the first step is to realize that consuming all of this news about tragedy really can have a damaging effect on a person, especially cumulatively and over the long run, and maybe people just need to be encouraged to remain aware of their own viewing/reading/listening habits and to make a conscious effort to consume all of this news about tragedy in moderation.
All of this to say that while Columbine was certainly not the first horrific tragedy to be covered extensively by the national media, it was certainly one of those stories that's become firmly ingrained in the public consciousness, and in ten years since its occurrence it feels like the number of tragedies which have been exhaustively covered, receiving "the Columbine treatment" has grown exponentially. I'm not sure whether there are just more of these events happening or whether the media is just covering a lot more of them in its endless pursuit of higher ratings. Either way, I tend to agree with Greene when he says that the constant coverage is beginning to take its toll upon the American psyche.
Wow. That went on a lot longer than I originally intended.
Oh well.
And I just read that apparently Stephen Hawking is gravely ill. I like the guy's stuff, and I wish him well. I've read his popular science book, A Brief History of Time at least twice, and although I don't understand all of it completely, I get enough of it to have my mind blown whenever I read it. I like the down-to-earth style which Hawkings uses as he patiently tries to explain some very complicated subject matter. That book, along with a few other similar books, really helped to change my view of the universe and how it works and about our tiny little place within it. Astronomy and modern physics can really change your perspective in a way that feels sort of magical and almost quasi religious. So Hawking helped to remind me how amazing this universe of ours really is.
Anyway, I wish him the best.
That's it for now. Sort of a long post, so sorry about that.

2 comments:

Unknown said...

I highly recommend the BBC original State of Play- I saw it a while back and really dug it. I'm a bit wary of the American version (as Sigmund pointed out, the idea of Ben Affleck playing a senator is pretty laughable) so I'm glad I got to read your review.

J.S. said...

Yeah, I've read a few reviews claiming that the British miniseries was better than this movie, which may be true. I'd like to see it. And Ben Affleck does a decent job in this movie, actually, but he's poorly cast. He's supposed to be Russel Crowe's college roommate and Robin Wright Penn's wife, but he's noticeably younger than either one of those actors. Anyway, the movie is pretty good if you go in with your expectations set somewhere significantly below "badass".