Hi. Tuesday. Tuesdays can be a bit... unremarkable.
I'm kind of stumped for topics. Obama has now apparently left open the possibility of prosecuting some of the Bush party officials who drew up the legal documents allowing torture (these are the legal papers which others relied upon when confronted with questions about the legality of using "extreme interrogation techniques", i.e., torture). The media is all over this story, but I'm not getting too fired up about it because I don't think these prosecutions will ever happen. Obama has made it clear on numerous occasions that he thinks our best course of action is just to move forward and to put all of these concerns behind us. More recently he has stated that he thinks any investigation and prosecution relating to the torture issue would be extremely difficult to carry out because such actions would be seen as part of a partisan political agenda. The man simply isn't interested in stoking the flames of a controversy which is likely to end up causing further political division and infighting within our country. I think Obama only addressed the possibility of prosecution because of mounting political pressure from Democrats who are angry about his refusal to address this issue.
I respect the president's position, but at the same time it bothers me. If Obama doesn't take a stand on this issue now, the message that the Republicans are going to get (and for that matter some extremist Democrats) is that they can cover the tracks of wrongdoing by making it politically difficult to prosecute controversial crimes. Essentially, the message being conveyed is that people can get away with doing bad things so long as the sabre rattling, whining, and political inconvenience is great enough to cover one's tracks after the fact. By unequivocally declaring torture to be illegal and wrong (which it seems to be under both U.S. and international law), but then by refusing to prosecute it, Obama is sending a pretty dangerous mixed message about the way that America is going to deal with crimes that are perpetrated by people who hold positions of power.
I'm not necessarily saying that we need to be handing out life sentences, but it seems that if we're going to draw a line in the sand on the torture issue, we ought to be willing to prosecute and publicly punish people who violate that law. Without prosecutions we're sending the message to elected officials that they (and their subordinates) can do whatever they want with impunity while they're in office, reassured in the knowledge that no one will hold them accountable for any wrongs they may have committed during their tenure.
Wrong message. Bad idea.
Given the fact that presidential administrations have confidentiality and national security to hide behind, no one may fully understand what they were up to until they've left office, and I think the ability to prosecute wrongdoing after the fact provides an incredibly important deterrent to people in power who might be tempted to engage in illegal acts.
Of course, another reason Obama may be shying away from the torture issue (and it would make sense that he might not publicly discuss this reason) could be that it may turn out that the American people just aren't on his side. This is a post 9/11 era where we have terrorists beheading captives on Youtube and TV programs like 24 which repeatedly depict ticking clock life and death situations where torture is the only way to extract the information that agents need in order to protect our citizens. A torture trial (or series of them) that prosecutes American officials (each of whom will undoubtedly flood the airwaves with soliloquies about how much they love our country and how they would do anything to protect it) may lead to an end result where Republicans attempt to significantly rewrite our torture laws. Such "reforms" may receive a surprising amount of public support. If torture prosecutions were undertaken at the wrong time, even even convictions might leave Obama in a "won the battle but lost the war" situation. The President might not want to address the torture issue at this point because, essentially, if he takes it on right now he may end up in a worse position than where he started (or at least as soon as the Republicans have enough votes to push something through). If you thought the "tea party" rallies were interesting, wait until you see the pro-torture rallies. Imagine the fun. Take a day off work and bring the kids out to listen to the torture advocates!!!
Maybe we should just hand these officials over to the International Criminal Court in the Netherlands or to the U.N. Security Council and let them decide guilt and punishment (yes, I know that's never going to really happen. We all know that the U.S. would never let itself be judged by the same standards that are applied to the rest of the international community- 40 countries have signed onto the I.C.C. treaty, but China, Russia, and The U.S. have all opted out).
Anyway, it's a lot to think about and involves some tough decisions. I support Obama, but I'm glad I'm not president.
And the U.S. Supreme Court handed down a ruling today which sounds like it's really going to be a game changer in terms of how the courts deal with searches and seizures that take place in a person's vehicle. Prior cases have been seen as giving police broad, discretionary powers in searching a vehicle without a warrant, typically without much regard for the reason that the vehicle was initially stopped. This new ruling seems to indicate that officers will now be allowed to search a vehicle without a warrant only if a person is still within reach of a vehicle's passenger compartment (meaning weapons could be reached or evidence destroyed) or if there's a good possibility that evidence will be discovered pertaining to the offense that led to the traffic stop.
I'm still sort of having a hard time understanding exactly how this rule is going to play out in the real world. I think that fights over the interpretation of this case may ultimately end up proving as important as the case itself. Anyway, people could potentially end up seeing a little more privacy in their vehicles as a result of this ruling. (Of course, the police probably aren't very excited about it.)
I wonder if I can make a bunch of money coming up with some sort of iPhone application that allows officers to apply for warrants on site and receive acceptances or denials in real time. I could probably market that idea, and this whole "warrantless searches" question might become somewhat less critical (part of the justification for warrantless searches of automobiles has typically been the time sensitive nature of the situation when you have someone pulled over on the side of the road- it's traditionally been sort of hard to wait on a warrant when you're in that kind of situation, but with our current technology, times could be changing).
Well, I guess that's all that I've got, I guess.
You guys be cool.
2 comments:
With regard to Arizona v. Gant, I've heard some people worry that police may now choose to leave a suspect in the vehicle (and therefore within reach of weapons or destroyable evidence) in order to get around this ruling. I'm not sure how likely that is, but it's an interesting idea (not one that I support, however).
Yeah, I really can't go into discussions on police procedure too much (as a prosecutor, I gotta be a bit careful in terms of going into involved discussion of stuff that might involve our office practices and policies on a public blog), but it probably wouldn't surprise me too much to hear that they were doing stuff like that.
Post a Comment