Oh yeah. I meant to comment on this earlier. The U.S. Supreme Court refused to hear the case of a German citizen who was seized by Macedonian police, turned over to the CIA, taken to Afghanistan and tortured (ok, physically abused, to be more specific) before being returned to Albania in 2004 where he was released in the Balkans. German officials say they were unofficially informed by their American counterparts that the man, Khaled al-Masri, was accidentally seized in a case of mistaken identity (although U.S. officials won't officially comment on the case). So here's another good reason to reconsider the use of "extreme interrogation techniques". Our government, in all of its limitless efficiency and unerring effectiveness, apparently occasionally inflicts its handiwork upon the wrong person. And then our conservative high court refuses to hold anyone responsible for these mistakes.
I'm really glad that my surname doesn't have an Arabic ring to it.
13 comments:
No justices dissented in the refusal to hear the case...not even Ruth Bader Ginsburg, who was a chief litigator for the ACLU. There is more to this story than we know. Let's not use this to make the case that "we're evil."
As I read the article, I noticed that neither Masri nor the ACLU used the word "torture." Why did you?
As for my use of the word torture, it was used in the text of the article to refer to this man's treatment, and it seemed a fair word for physical abuse during interrogation. Torture is defined by Webster's as "the infliction of intense pain to punish, coerce, or afford sadistic pleasure". Seems like Torture is a good fit here. (since the U.S. was inflicting pain in order to coerce this man into talking) The word rendition wasn't used, either, although that's clearly what happened in this case. By the way, don't read too much into the fact that I called us evil. I think that our country has some grave problems that need addressing, but I was being a bit of a smartass when I called us evil. (I'm trying to hate the sin but not the sinner, even when I think that sinner is the U.S.)
I'm not sure why Ginsburg didn't dissent, but that doesn't make me feel any better about the court's failure to hear the case. Maybe she's gone soft or maybe she was afraid that if the court actually took the case they would do more harm than good. All I know is that the court passed up a chance to apply the rule of law to a bunch of questionable U.S. practices in this case.
I do not think that you believe we are evil and I will not suggest that anymore. My appologies.
If "torture" is a good fit and it certainly makes a powerful statement, why would the ACLU shy away from using it in this case?
Not sure. Maybe they were negligent in their duties.
Is it possible that physical abuse is not always torture? Is it possible that applying the word torture when it didn't occur would hurt the ACLU's case?
Can we agree that the flippant use of the word torture is not good for America?
Look, I'm not going to start modifying my speech on the basis of what supposedly is or isn't good for America. First of all, I think what's good for America is to deal with the truth- not to hide behind inoffensive, incorrect labels. This exact kind of thing popped up in George Orwell's 1984 (written in 1948) when Orwell wrote of a fascist government who tried to hide its unethical acts behind tricks of language and rhetorical trickery (he referred to it as newspeak or doublespeak, and he specifically referred to torture in his book, with the fictional evil government in his book substituting the word torture with "tough questioning" or "physical persusasion" in order to confuse the public and make their bad actions more palatable. 60 years ago Orwell realized that the Nazis had manipulated the public with their propaganda and covered up their evil actions with a careful use of semantics, and he was so infuriated about it that he wrote one of the classic cautionary tales of all time. I refuse to ignore the lessons of history in order to protect what our misguided leaders are doing now. I would rather give our country praise than criticize it, but I want our country to earn that praise- not ask me to alter my speech to cover up our wrongdoing.
For some reason, the person bringing the lawsuit didn't use the word torture and his ACLU lawyers didn't use the word torture. There must be a reason for this. It doesn't make sense to use language that incites hatred for America without cause. Might you be guilty of newspeak yourself?
Obviously, just because this very short article didn't quote these parties using the word torture doesn't mean they've never used that word to refer to these events (I would, in fact, be shocked if this man who was abused in Afghanistan never referred to the actions of the U.S. as torture). I wish you were half as concerned with the actual actions of our government as you are with worrying about whether we look bad, Anonymous. Why don't you go start your own blog to help disseminate your compelling arguments instead of haunting this one?
I'm glad my surname doesn't have an arabic ring to it either, and that I'm a white american. Of course, I have a friend who is a card carrying republican, from a large Irish Catholic family, third generation American, who recently was put on the airport watchlist for the second time.
I agree. We can play hide the ball with words all day. Fine. Let's call the interrogation techniques: "happy time with friends". You do realize that it's the actions not the words that incites hatred of our country across the world. I too am concerned that you're more concerned with our world image than our actions. I'm also surprised because I thought most republicans could care less about what the UN, EU, China, Russia, and the rest of the world thinks about us. There wasn't much crying when we lied to the UN and then gave them the finger and invaded Iraq.
I agree again. I would love to post comments on anonymous's blog. Please point us to it. I would enjoy reading it.
You can visit anonymous's blog at www.theholocaustneverhappened.com
"But those German guys I talked to never used the word "Holocaust"......"
Douchebag....are you so simple and naive that you need **everything** spelled out for you???
Understood.
Well, I hate to see people get their feelings hurt, but Anonymous, you're just not hearing what we're saying, you're arguing in circles, and you're just not presenting arguments that are changing anyone's mind. I can tell that you are trying to be a patriot and want to defend our country, but you have to understand that in our own way we're trying to do the same thing (we don't want to see our country turned into something we see as being unethical or evil). I'm just not up for more games of "lets see who can get the last word in", though.
Incidentally, I think the best argument IN SUPPORT of torture in this debate is the old hypothetical where there's a bomb set to go off in a crowded football stadium, you have one terrorist in custody who knows where the bomb is and how to disarm it, and you have about ten minutes to find the bomb and disarm the thing before the bomb detonates. Hypotheticals like that present a real world scenario where torture is something that has to realistically be considered as a potential tool, no matter how it's labeled. (and, frankly, it's difficult to make a counterargument against torture for that hypothetical). Fortunately, in the real world these types of time sensitive scenarios just don't pop up that often, so I still don't think that this hypothetical goes far in supporting the broad expansion of the use of torture (or extreme interrogation or whatever) that this administration seems to favor.
Post a Comment